As someone who gets a LOT of these sorts of notes, I would like folks to consider this, henceforth.
From now on, every time someone says “this ____ is racist”, and you feel the need to counter with “well to be fair, ____” I want you to:
1) Pause.
Take a breath! You do NOT have to respond immediately, or at all! Did you understand what was written? Do you understand why the person who experienced what they believed was racism feels that way? Do you recognize that racism is never fair?
2) Ask yourself why you feel the need to defend against this sentiment.
Is it personal? Is it because you’ve seen it in your own behavior, or perhaps a friend’s? Are you worried that one day you might do this thing, or enjoy this thing? Is it about your entertainment? Did you offer this much grace to the potential victim before you began to invalidate their experience? Does this happen often? Do you fight against racism as often as you find yourself disagreeing when something is?
3) Can you accept what it means if you are objectively proven wrong?
If you disagree or want to “provide the benefit of the doubt”, and you are proven incorrect- are you willing to accept that you have been racist? Are you willing to accept that people essentially saw you being racist for racism’s sake? And may not feel safe around you anymore? Does it even matter to you? Is that who you want to be?
It happens endlessly where people want so badly to defend either themselves or some imaginary person they could potentially be, that they don’t see who they’re being right now. You want to advocate for the Devil, but you don’t appreciate being treated like the Devil you’re representing!
I’m not saying never question anything. Far from it! Not everybody is right, trust me. But I feel like y'all be so ready to respond, and for what? Y'all be so ready to debate someone’s lived reality, and then are insulted when they don’t trust you! I guess my point is to think before you speak. If you aren’t sure, ask questions or do your own research. Approach to understand, not to respond.
Sometimes I just think if you finished the thought out with “to be fair to the racist-” you’d realize just how annoying and frankly dangerous you sound. Because that’s what you’re saying, and you want it to be accepted with openness and objectivity.