"spring binstub --all" contradicts what Rails 6.1.0 "rails new" recommends

[mattbrictson]

As of Rails 6.1.0, rails new generates its own "spring-ified" binstubs:

bin/rake
bin/rails
bin/spring

These binstubs are different than the ones that spring itself recommends. If you run spring binstub --all you will get a different set of files.

Prior to Rails 6.1.0, rails new used to call spring binstub to generate the bin/spring binstub. But as of Rails commit 72d10e21, spring binstub has been removed and Rails has slightly diverged from the Spring recommendations. It now uses these binstub templates: bin/spring, bin/rake, bin/rails.

Should this repository be updated to match the official Rails recommendations?

Or alternatively, should the README be updated to make it clear that you should not run spring binstub --all for Rails 6.1 projects?

[deivid-rodriguez]

I noticed this today too.

I'd say the new templates should be ported to this repository. Spring only makes sense when used with Rails so these should match.

[mattbrictson]

Rails doesn't generate Spring binstubs anymore (as of Rails 7), so I think this issue is no longer relevant. Closing.