I didn't know who Rennie Sparks was when I read these stories back in 2017 but I made a note they were ok by the time I came to review them I had forgotten everything about them even though I had read them again during the COVID lockdown. That forgetfulness is not a good sign, so I gave them a quick read again (not thoroughly or all but enough all the same) and realised why I remained so unengaged with Sparks work. She writes beautifully, but with no passion. I didn't believe any of her characters represented either real lived experience or understanding. They were collections of traits, characteristics, buzz words and emotional trip wires, but they weren't real.
If you are going to tell me stories like these I expect to respond viscerally - I didn't, it was like looking at a well executed, but lifeless drawing. Also, there was an uncomfortable element of manipulation, there was too much inbuilt Pavlovian reaction, Ms. Sparks felicity as a songwriter means she knows how to push her listeners emotional buttons. But a reader needs more. It is not that an author has to have lived his characters lives but if they are no more than puppets they will be lifeless.
Its not often I shelve a well written book as waste-of-time but good writing isn't everything.