Chapters:
4/4
Words: 30,864
Fandom:
Stranger Things (TV 2016)
Rating:
Teen And Up Audiences
Warnings:
No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships:
Will Byers/Mike Wheeler, Dustin Henderson & Mike Wheeler, Eleven | Jane Hopper & Mike Wheeler, Mike Wheeler & Nancy Wheeler
Characters:
Mike Wheeler, Will Byers, Dustin Henderson, Robin Buckley, Eleven | Jane Hopper
Additional Tags:
Post-Season/Series 04, set in the timeskip, Mike Wheeler Loves Will Byers, Will Byers Loves Mike Wheeler, Gay Mike Wheeler, Past Eleven | Jane Hopper/Mike Wheeler, Hurt/Comfort, Angst, paintinggate, Lettergate, First Kiss, Getting Together, no beta we die like billy, POV Mike Wheeler, mentions of suicidal ideation, Mike Wheeler Has Issues, references to season 5, Feelings Realization, Implied/Referenced Sex, Internalized Homophobia, Period-Typical Homophobia
Summary:
“Would you kiss me if I was a girl?” Mike whispered.
“No.” It was so immediate, so sure. Mike’s heart dropped.
“Oh. Okay. I mean, yeah of course. Me neither, like, either way.” Stupid Mike, stupid.
They fell into an uncomfortable silence but neither of them moved, Mike felt like his feet has melted into the concrete below them. He didn’t dare look Will in the eye, even if there wasn’t much else to look at.
“Now ask if I would kiss you as a boy.”
or
Mike realised Will’s feelings, then realises his own, then fucks it all up, then fixes it.
Work and chapter titles from Not Running by The Beths
BONUS PNGs of Mike’s letters from the third chapter and list from the last chapter can be found in this post
question when people write post volume 2 fanfic are they ignoring that the duffers confirmed mike knew he was will’s crush, or do people not know? or a secret third option?
just in case you want to hear will's soft "mike" without all the annoying background noise :) also please pay attention to will's hand lingering on mike's shoulder.

i hate the bg music to this scene so thankyou dearly
one thing I have not seen talked about when it comes to Will's ending and future is: he should have a dog. he had a dog once and he lost it, suggesting he likes dogs, and therefore he should have one. it should be big and friendly and cuddly. it should often barge into will's in home art studio uninvited, messing up several of his sketches in his rush to lick will's face. it should be a reason will has to leave the house and go on long walks (the only exercise he enjoys). it should notice whenever will is having a bad nightmare about vecna and stick its cold nose against his cheek to wake him up. it should have a very nerdy name. please and thank you
im pissed and disgusted by the queerbait so
here is a masterpost on everything that doesnt make sense because byler isnt canon, plot holes that exist because byler isnt canon, all the ways mikes character was ruined by making him straight, AND how it was homophobic. i include explanations and categorize things by color coding! this includes scenes in the show, interviews, and posts from the stranger things team. (note: im not going to include things noah said-explained in tags)
warning, it’s very long because im including EVERYTHING. I found and listed 114 examples here. enjoy—or don’t.
as someone who literally studied this stuff, i’m sorry but why on earth would the duffers put mike and will’s first meeting on will’s memory tape if it wasn’t meant to mean something. that’s not a random choice. that’s not a cute callback. that’s the kind of moment you highlight when you’re saying “this relationship is the root system.”
and then making mike the first emotional touchstone on the tape? come on. that’s storytelling 101. you don’t give that kind of narrative priority to a relationship you plan to sideline later. you don’t build an entire visual motif around will’s interiority and then centre mike in it just for fun.
so why would they do all of that, the memory tape, the first meeting, the emotional framing, only to turn around in volume 2 and the finale and act like will and mike’s relationship suddenly doesn’t matter. it makes no damn sense. it’s not even about shipping at that point, it’s about basic narrative coherence. you don’t plant a flag that big and then pretend you didn’t.
bylers if you see this go read this fic immediately. its so well written, will make you feel slightly better about the coming out scene, and is just the sweetest and most heartfelt thing you’ve ever read.
i just realised byler can watch the princess bride, just like, at any moment after the final battle. they can go straight home from killing vecna and watch it. and mike can see westley do everything buttercup had ever asked of him and feel a strange pang of familiarity, and spend the entire rest of the movie unable to take his eyes off will. he can listen to the movie talk about “the most passionate kiss there ever was” and not be able to think of anything other than topping that kiss tenfold.
Will can watch this romance play out, pretending its gross but secretly wanting and yearning to be loved that fiercely one day. wishing that every caring action mike had taken towards him was as pure and loving as westley’s towards buttercup. he can laugh at the comedy and cheer at the triumphs, and be so painfully unaware of mike’s eyes firmly fixed to the side of his head through all of it.
they can finish the movie and begin getting ready for bed, and will can ask mike to pass him the blanket from the couch and mike can say “as you wish” with such seriousness will has no choice but to believe him. mike can tell him to ask for something else. will can say “kiss me”. and mike can say “as you wish” as they crash into each other.
Milevens who romanticise the fact that Mike supposedly can't live without El (spoiler alert: it's not even true) and Bylers who romanticise the fact that Will believes that he needs Mike and Mike needs to be needed (also not true, those are both deeply rooted beliefs that stem from insecurity and need to be unlearned) should all take a few steps back and reflect on themselves.
"[Insert ship] is sooo unhealthy and toxic, [insert other ship] is obviously superior!!1!!!1!" and then you make signs of insecurity in the relationship out to be signs that they're soulmates or whatever the fuck. Get a fucking grip.
I am quite fond of the character it has to be said
The feeling of getting comments on your fics is the craziest thing. Like, I wrote this in my free time because it's something I wanted to read and someone thought it was good or it made their day and they took the time to tell me that??? Incomparable.
WHY IS THERE A FISH IN THE SHOWER IM CRINE
because will is a little shit and it was a good prank
I finished these screenshot studies yesterday and posted them on insta, twitter and bluesky (forgot to post here woops), before watching Vol 2.
I have MANY thoughts about Vol 2. TLDR, I still have faith in Byler, but holy shit. The writers are making some VERY QUESTIONABLE decisions. But, it's not over till it's over. We should really wait until the finale (which I'll be seeing in a theatre on Jan 1st, woo) to fully react. But, I am PISSED at the "he was my Tammy" line. What in the legitimate fuckery. I am banking on the fact that Will has been an unreliable narrator, and that we've not had Mike's POV yet.
Even if the ending is as bad as Voltron or GOTs, we'll still have the fandom <3