Theodore Nott x HufflepuffReader

Summary: You were known as the sweetest Hufflepuff at Hogwarts, from tutoring students to being Madam Pomfrey’s helper, you were constantly busy you liked it that way… Theodore Nott - The Slytherin Prefect, you had caught his attention, and everyone knows Theodore Nott never gives up on something or someone he wants.

Originally posted by nolongerwritinghere-deactivated

You could hear the cheers from the quidditch game Gryffindor vs Slytherin, the biggest game of the year as you heard everyone say, as much as you wanted to watch the games you knew it was your number one priority to be ready for the injured players.

You were happy being Madam Pomfrey’s helper having it on your file knowing it would do you well in the future, you always dreamed of being a healer, you just had to prove you were good enough and you knew you were nearly there.

“Y/n darling I need your help” You heard Madam Pomfrey say, as the room began filling up with chatter, you closed the file standing up walking from behind the curtain, safe to say you weren’t surprised when groups began carrying in the quidditch players in.

“Place him on the bed please,” You say to the group of Slytherins carrying who you knew as The Slytherin Prefect - Theodore Nott, they did as were told before moving back “What happened” You questioned, feeling his pulse “One of them Gryffindors set a spell on him, made the broom go out out control, before smashing into the ground Theo still on it,” Blaise says to you “I bet it was that filthy little mudblood” Draco says pacing back and forth.

He was distracting everyone in the room, you turned to Pansy “Please take him out, to cool down” You say politely as she nods following your instructions, once everyone was out it became quiet again the only sounds being the injured students groaning and Madam Pomfrey speaking.

You had wrapped Theo’s hand carefully, he was lucky it was only minor injuries, a sprained hand, black eye, little cuts on his leg, arms, and head but nothing major… You had begun writing up his injuries in his file when you heard him beginning to groan. You stood up slowly walking over seeing him look around the room confused.

“Good evening Mr. Nott”, You say smiling softly “How are you feeling” You question pouring him a glass of water, which he drinks in one gulp “Why am I here” He questions beginning to sit up “Please be careful you have some injuries.” You say causing him to look down at his wrapped-up hand “Do you have a mirror” He asks beginning to mess with his hair, you nod passing him the mirror from the desk behind you.

“Damn” was all he said before placing it down “Even looking like this, I look amazing” You laugh softly, causing him to send you a soft smile “It seems as though you are feeling better, There are still 30 minutes left of dinner, I would suggest going to get some,” You say signing his pass, as he stood up “thank you” He mutters taking it from you “Aren’t you coming to dinner” He questions you shake your head softly “I still have many patients to care of, enjoy your night Mr. Nott” He nods before walking away, “The name is Theo by the way” He shouts across the room before leaving.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You had finally finished your shift, it hadn’t been a bad day you managed to get some studying in but that resulted in you being even more tired. You walked through the dark halls, you loved Hogwarts when it was dark and quiet it was peaceful and beautiful.

“Hey wait up” You heard a deep voice say behind you causing you to turn around seeing Theo Nott running up to you. “You know you really shouldn’t be moving your hand so much,” You say looking down at his wrapped hand.

“It’ll be fine, it has been through worse,” He says smiling “I actually wanted to thank you for taking good care of me yesterday” You smiled softly “You are welcome MrNott but it is part of my job” You respond laughing softly, you saw Theo’s smile grow wider “Yeah - Yeah I know that, but you know I feel like you and Madam Pomfrey don’t get the recognition use deserve you know” He leans against the wall crossing his arms, keeping his eyes on you, you couldn’t help but raise your eyebrows.

“Well thank you, Theo, are you feeling alright” You question making him chuckle “You finding it concerning a Slytherin being nice” that statement made you feel guilty because it was true you heard what everyone said about them and you yourself have had many bad experiences with them.

“Don’t worry Y/n, I won’t be insulted if you feel that way, I mean at least the Slytherin house is living up to their reputation” He began moving closer to you, you back away until your back hits the stone wall behind you “I don’t mean to intimidate you” He mutters looking down at you.

Theo wasn’t that taller than you, you were 5'7 and it seemed as though he was 6'0, you noticed how his eyes glistened from the moonlight, your faces being lit up by the candles on the wall, you couldn’t find the words to talk, you didn’t know what was happening to you, the only sound coming from you both was your breaths, you both continued to stare at each other.

“Mr. Nott” You both heard Filch’s voice echo through the hallway, causing Theo to back away from you “Ahh Miss L/n I must say I do not think Professor Dumbledore will be impressed to hear his top students were breaking the rules,” He says stopping in front of you both. “Of course, not Mr. Filch, but I must assure you no rules were broken I am simply doing prefect duties and Miss L/n has just finished her shift in the infirmary, I had gotten confused and pulled Miss L/n up thinking she was just wondering around.” He says a smile spreading across Mr. Filch’s face “Of course Mr. Nott, please escort Miss L/n to her homeroom.”

You had never gotten into trouble before, you really hoped this wouldn’t go onto your file. “This is how you thank me after helping you get better, you get me in trouble with Filch.” You say crossing your arms, an amused expression on your face… You were shocked when he wrapped his arm around your shoulders beginning to walk you down the hall.

“Well I got you out of that trouble didn’t I” He says stopping outside your homeroom door “Hm I guess so, but if this goes onto my file, you will have two injured hands,” You say before muttering the password, the door opening the door “Goodnight,” You say sending him a soft smile before the door closed.

Safe to say you were confused by what just happened, why was Theo Nott even speaking to you, you found it nice that he approached you thanking you for helping him, but the whole conversation afterward, the backed up into the wall had you flustered, you had never even seen anyone like that in Hogwarts, yes you had been asked out on dates but you always turned them down, you were too busy, your career meant more to you that a stupid relationship.

———————————

It had been two weeks since that night with Theo, you managed to avoid him since, he still sent you smiles across the corridors or dinner hall, of course, you couldn’t be rude and sent him one back… But you couldn’t allow yourself to now get distracted especially by a boy.

“Y/n sweetie, you can go now, go have some fun it is Friday night,” Madam Pomfrey says walking towards you, “Madam Pomfrey I assure you, I do not mind staying, if I leave all I will do is study” You watched her raise her eyebrows “I am unsure about that, it seems you have a visitor” That made you confused, who would visit you at 11pm on a Friday night, you stood up from your chair looking around the curtain seeing Theo walking back and forth.

“Go on sweetie” You smile softly grabbing your cardigan, walking over to him… You were confused on why he was here, by the news you heard of the Slytherins winning the Quidditch game, you would imagine him partying by now.

He looked up at the sound of your shoes clicking against, a smile appearing on his face “Hi” He says standing up straight, “Hi Theo” You respond back “Is there anything I can help you with” you say knocking him out of his daydream, you couldn’t help but blush under his stare. “Oh yeah, um I don’t know if you heard but the Slytherins won the game.”

You nod “I did, by how many Ravenclaws arrived at the infirmary, I figured out use won,” You say chuckling softly, “Yeah it got pretty brutal out there, I hope it wasn’t too busy for you if you must know I actually attacked fewer players then I usually do just so you would be able to finish early” You look up at him surprised, wrapping your arms around yourself to try and shield you from the cold.

“How sweet of you Theo,” you say sarcastically making him chuckle “Well the main reason I am here is to actually invite you to the celebration party” He questions looking down the hallway, nervous of what your answer would be “I have never been to a party before,” You say quietly, he looks back you surprised “Well if you say yes, I can promise you this will be one of the best parties of your life”

“That is a big promise to make,” You say raising your eyebrows slightly, he nods “It is a promise I tend to keep too, so will you be joining me,” He says holding his arm out for you to link, which you.

You were surprised you actually decided to go, you hadn’t thought about it, but it was something about Theo that intrigued you, you didn’t want to think when you were around him and you had no intentions of doing so.

You heard him mutter the homeroom password before walking us both in. You were immediately met by loud music, you grabbed Theo’s hand tightly instead of his arm, he turned to you smiling softly “Come on” He says squeezing your hand, pulling you through the crowd towards the stairs.

You were confused, to say the least when you stopped outside his room “Why are we up here” You question confused, “Don’t worry, the real party is in here” He says pushing his door open you were immediately met by a strong smell of weed, Theo pulled you in carefully.

You weren’t surprised to see Draco, Pansy, Blaise, Mattheo, Enzo, Crabble, and Goyle all sat in a circle, playing games, drinking, and smoking, the door opening caught their attention as they all turned to you.

“Wait isn’t she a Hufflepuff” You heard Crabble mutter only to receive a smack from Pansy followed by a shut up, “Hi Y/n come sit down.” She says moving over to make room for you, you looked at Theo as he nodded letting go of your hand as you sat beside Pansy who sent you a soft smile…

You didn’t know how long you had been here for, Pansy had managed to get a few drinks down you, you lost count after 5, it was fun, you actually felt free and you never imagined it would have been with a group of Slytherins… You were now watching Blaise and Draco wrestle to see who was stronger, you ended up leaning against Theo’s bed, whilst he sat behind you on it his legs either side of you, you felt his soft breath hit your cheek as he bent down “You having fun” He whispers into your ear, you nod slowly.

You gasped quietly, closing your eyes as you felt Theo’s lips on your neck, leaving trails of kisses his other hand moving your hair to one side “This feel good” He questions kissing towards your ear, “We shouldn’t” You mumble pulling away slightly, you felt his hand on the back of your neck turning your head towards him as he leans sideways, his thumb pulling your bottom lip “Come on Y/n, nobody will find out” He mutters his hand pushing your head towards his, your lips smashing his “no Theo” you say pushing him away.

You heard him huff in annoyance, you stood up stumbling slightly Theo grabbing your waist “You getting laid” Draco questions chuckling “I wish man, she too stuck up” Theo says making the group laugh… You were drunk but not that drunk to let someone talk bad about you in front of you, you spun around slapping him, hearing the group gasp.

“Don’t you ever try that again” You say pointing your finger at him “You are pathetic, trying to get me drunk to take advantage, get a life” You mutter harshly before grabbing your cardigan walking out the room.

“Well, that was entertaining” You heard Enzo says before Theo tells them to shut, you shoved yourself past the crowd and out the Slytherin dorm room, feeling hot tears run down your face, you walked into the bathroom stopping in front of the mirror looking at yourself.

You look pathetic, crying over a Slytherin, what did you expect they were horrible people. “Y/n” you heard a quiet voice say behind, you look behind you seeing Moaning Mrytle. “Hi Mrytle, I am sorry for disturbing you so late,” You say smiling slightly but you could see the concern on her face “Why are you crying, I don’t think you have cried at all whilst being here” She questions, you sniffle grabbing a tissue wiping your eyes “Because I actually thought I could trust a Slytherin,” You say laughing bitterly “But of course, he took advantage of a Hufflepuff, how could I not see it,” You say turning back to the mirror looking at yourself.

“Miss L/n you must not let a Slytherin upset you, you are better than them, and beautiful and beautiful women do not cry,” She says standing beside you “Show them that Hufflepuffs aren’t just nice and quiet” You glance at her slightly before looking down at your hands “I guess you are right, I must go now and get some sleep but I will see you tomorrow,” You say smiling at the ghost as you walked out.

———————————-

It had been a week since that night, you acted as though that night never happened, carrying on with your usual day-to-day plans, exam week was coming up meaning everyone was studying, with it being exam week that meant you couldn’t do as many shifts at the infirmary as you were used too.

“Hey Y/n can you read this” You look up from your book seeing Pansy standing in front of you, you hadn’t spoken to any of the group since that night “I am a little busy at the moment, but I am sure someone else would love too” You say grabbing your book and bag rolling your eyes, beginning to walk away.

“Look Y/n I am sorry for Theo did, but I honestly did not know what he was doing, all I got told was that Theo was bringing you as a way to say thank you”, She says a guilty look on her face, you couldn’t help but chuckle “Yeah that was a really good thank you.” Pansy seemed like she was telling the truth, you sigh “Fine I will read it” You say walking back over.

Theo watched you and Pansy in the library as you were explaining the work to her, “You really got to get over her, she’s a Hufflepuff” Mattheo says walking over to him “shut up” He mutters walking away from his friends.

“Pansy come on!” Draco shouts catching both your and Pansy’s attention “Just watch the way you spell them and you should be fine, but other than that it’s great” You say moving back “Thank You Y/n, do you want to do walk into town with me” Pansy ask grabbing her bag, you look up at her shaking your head “I am good thank you though” you say standing up “They aren’t coming” She says quickly, you raised your eyebrows slightly “Sure” you say slowly, Pansy turning back to her friends “I will just catch use later.”

———————————–

You and Pansy had actually become good friends over the past few weeks, you were pretty sure she had spent time with you other than her actual house friends, she always hanged around the infirmary no matter how many times Madam Pomfrey told her to leave she never did, she would sit by in all classes, sleepover in your dorm… Without admitting it she was slowly turning into your best friend…

You still hadn’t spoken to Theo, you weren’t avoiding him you simply ignored this existence, you were doing fine, well until you would see Theo with other girls jealously would show on your face… Whilst Theo he was still trying to figure out why he would treat you like he did that night, he tried for weeks for you to even become his friend, he just got embarrassed getting pushed away by you which he understood, he just couldn’t deal with being embarrassed.

“This is great Taylor, well done this is such an improvement,” You say passing the young girl her book, who smiled happily before skipping away, you were shocked when you felt someone jump onto your back “There you are!!” Pansy says hugging you tightly before jumping down, you turn to her seeing her friends standing behind you.

“I literally searched the entire castle for you,” Pansy says trying to catch her breath, you couldn’t tear your eyes away from Theo, who couldn’t look away from you either, this was the closest use had been since that night “Right I actually have to talk to you,” Pansy says catching your attention, you looked at her confused as she pulled you away from the boys.

“What” you say confused, she smiles slightly “They are getting annoyed that I keep canceling plans with them, and I kind of accidentally said you and I would join them at the Slytherin party tonight” You chuckle at her words before stopping “oh you are serious” she nods before looking behind me, following her stare you see her friends leaning against the wall watching you both “They want you to join” you turn back her crossing your arms, “Pans” you say but cut yourself off she begins frowning “fine” you mutter hearing her cheer and hug you tightly, you ignored the boys muttering a yes as they fist bumped each other…

———————————————-

You were not happy to be here, stuck on a couch between Draco and Enzo and to make it worse Pansy was kissing Draco and some random blonde girl was with Enzo, you sighed standing up walking over to the drink table… You already promised Pansy you wouldn’t leave and at least try to enjoy the night, but there was nothing to enjoy and you just wanted to go to sleep.

“Hey” you heard a familar voice say beside you, you glanced towards the voice seeing Theo standing beside you getting himself a drink “hi” you reply back looking away “listen um can we talk somewhere private” Theo questions, you think for a minute before nodding “sure” you watch as he offers his hand for you to grab, which you just look at before looking up at him “I can walk by myself thank you” you rolling your eyes, you followed him through the crowd and up the stairs up to his room.

He opens his door allowing you to walk inside, you look around the room hearing the door close behind you, you sip your drink taking a seat on the end of his bed as he watches your every move “Has anyone ever told you it’s rude to stare” you say raising your eyebrows, you didn’t have time to wait for him to start talking, did you feel bad for how you were treating yes, but did he deserve it also yes.

You rolled your eyes standing up “I didn’t come up here to sit in silence Theo” you say beginning to walk towards the door “I am sorry” Theo says making you stop and turn to him “I am sorry for what I did and what I said, I do not know why I acted that way after you turned me down, but I like you, I really really like you, you are literally the most beautiful and sweetest girl i have ever met in my life, no matter how hard I try I cannot get you out of my head, everywhere I go you are there, ever since that day in the infirmary you have invaded my mind” he says letting out deep breath running his fingers through his hair, “and I have felt guilty ever since that night, we were having fun and we were being touchy with one another I tried shooting my shot with you to see what would happen, but when you turned me down I was embarrassed and I know that is no excuse for trying to force you to kiss me or embarrassing you in front of my friends and I am truly truly sorry about that” he finishes stopping in front of you.

You felt like you were in a trance, unable to move or say anything, once again just like that night your second conversation, use didn’t say anything the sound you could hear with the breathing “You look beautiful Y/n” Theo says softly pushing a strand of hair behind your ear “Theo” you whisper looking up into his eyes away from his lips “Why are you making me feel this way, I shouldn’t feel this way towards you” you mutter beginning to back away.

“What - what do you feel Y/n” He questions walking towards you, you shake your head “no,no I do not have time for this, I am far to busy with studying and the infirmary, my mother she told me one of you Slytherins would try to distract me this year… I need to go” You say running your hand through your hair reaching for the door.

“Y/n I would never sabotage your future, if that is what you are scared about, I will do everything to help you get where you want to be” He says touching your arm softly, you melted under his touch… you hid your emotions well but whenever he was around you just couldn’t.

“Come here” Theo says softly pulling you towards him, as he wraps his arms around you tightly “I know your family have had a bad experience with us Slytherins but I will hurt you the way your parents got hurt” You looked up at him softly, you were letting your barrier down he could tell.

You smashed your lips to his, you felt him begin to kiss back your hands reaching for his shirt beginning to pull it “y/n, y/n” he says pulling away, now it was your turn to be embarrassed “listen I want to okay, but not tonight and somewhere better then this, plus you are drunk Y/n and I really hope you remember this in the morning” He says taking your hand softly.

“We can either go back to the party or go to sleep” You look around before smiling “i am not drunk Theo, I am just tired” you say quietly “how about we sleep” you suggest watching a bright smile take over his face “yeah- yeah do you want to stay here or I can walk you back to Hufflepuff common room”

“Can I stay here” you question, he nods quickly walking over to his drawer pulling out a long shirt “here you can wear this, the bathroom is just over there” he says pointing to a door, you nod taking the shirt off him walking in the bathroom.

You were glad you went with no makeup tonight, you tied your hair up before washing your face with water, pulling the shirt over your head leaving your dress on the side folded up neatly, you walked out seeing Theo laying on the bed shirtless… he looked amazing, you hadn’t expected to end the night like this.

He looks at you before opening up the duvet, you smile softly walking over climbing in beside him, you watch as he lifts his wand up muttering a spell as the lights turn off, the only thing lightening up your faces was the moon, you both lie down facing one another.

He looked perfect

She looked beautiful

you slowly felt sleep taking over you, feeling Theo’s arm wrap around your waist pulling you closer to him… Safe to say that is the best sleep you both had ever gotten before.

(Theodore Nott story is now up!! - hope you all enjoy!! If you have any suggestions of what you would like to be written let me know!