Ok but that still misses the entire point of taking down the Veil. Which is the core issue of the game. No two people apparently have the same information about who Solas is as a person, what his goals are, and what motivates him.
It’s why discussions about him so often devolve into abject bullying and hostility. Because literally no one is on the same page, and that’s as much a feature of his design as it is a massive inconsistency issue.
Depending on who you speak to, it can feel like people are playing vastly different games from one another, and that’s because they essentially are. Solas is unique as an NPC for a few reasons, but primarily because everything from his history to his motives changes based on who’s speaking to or about him. Moreover, his personality itself changes based on how your Inquositor has treated him and others.
Then, making matters even worse, you have the fact that the character essentially went through constant rewrites that would completely change major aspects of him, his story, and his motives. Add to that the amount of insane leaps of logic that have been made by bad faith interpreters which would then be mistaken for canon, because people who don’t like Solas don’t spend enough time with him in game to realize they have false information.
The two that drive me the most insane though are the following:
1–Solas wants to revive the Elven Empire
No. Emphatically no. He has never once said he wanted this, said anything to imply he wanted this, and actively hates the idea of romanticizing Elvhenan.
2-Solas is planning genocide
Also no. It’s genuinely upsetting to see how many people throw around the word genocide to shutdown the conversation with moral grandstanding…all to justify their hatred of a fictional character.
Stop doing it. It’s not just a gross misuse of the word, it’s obscenely disrespectful considering there are actual genocides happening in the world.
Genocide is the deliberate and coordinated effort by a regime to enact mass murder against a certain group or population, usually an oppressed out group, with the intention of wiping them out entirely.
Solas is not doing any of that. He is not planning mass murder, he is planning to take action against an existential threat and anticipates heavy casualties as a consequence. He considers this a price acceptable in order to avoid far worse outcome for everyone. As far as he’s concerned, he was trying to prevent the end of the world by taking pre-emptive action against an inevitable ecological disaster. The Veil is not permanent, it was coming down already, and letting it fall naturally would be far worse for everyone than a controlled takedown where he can mitigate the damage.
As for those casualties, he considers them acceptable but only because total extinction is the alternative. Just like when the Veil went up originally, it’s a matter of choosing between bad and worse. He trying to choose the bad to prevent the worse. And it’s already been made clear, over and over, that The Veil falling won’t just automatically kill everyone.
If Solas, who canonically does not lie, is to be believed—and I tend to beleive the experts—then the casualty count was estimated to be in the thousands, which is pretty bad but not nearly as bad as the millions Rook killed. Rook also left Thedas in a poisoned, dying, and borderline inhospitable state, which doesn’t seem like much of a win when Solas’ plan was badicslly to purify and restore the natural world. You know Project Zero Dawn from Horizon: Zero Down? His plan was basically that, but with fewer casualties up front.
Even without the ticking clock element, it’s been made abundantly cheat that the Veil does more harm to the world than good. Demons primarily exist in Thedas because Spirits get unwittingly pulled through the Veil, a heavily traumatic experience, and they are left broken and warped. The Veil is also responsible for the phenomena of Tranquility.
Im not sure how Weekes and Epler think Trabquility works, but Tranquility is when a person is cut off from the Fade. If the Titans are Tranquil, then it means they were connected to the Fade. So taking the Veil dorm would theoretically reconnect them to their dreams and possibly even end the Blight permanently.
The Veil also makes it harder for Mages to control their magic, which is why magic in Thedas is so temperamental and dangerous, and therefore why mages are hated and oppressed.
I think I’ve made my point by now. Varric and Rook were never going to be able to talk Solas down, because neither of them actually understood what he was doing or why, nor did they make the effort to find out. You can’t win an argument if you don’t know what it is you’re trying to argue against, and you cannot solve a problem you do not understand.