Murdered at First Sight - Production & Contact Info

Cast	+ Add Cast
105 cast members

Name	Episodes	Known for
Bryanna Fox Self - Criminologist Self - Criminologist See fewer	12	Making Manson (2024)
Kerry Daynes Self - Forensic Psychologist Self - Forensic Psychologist See fewer	6	Jack the Ripper: The Hidden Victims (2022)
Carrie McGonigle Self - Amber's Mum Self - Amber's Mum See fewer	1	Buried in the Backyard (2018)
Parm Sandhu Self - Former Chief Superintendent Self - Former Chief Superintendent See fewer	1	The Interrogation Room hosted by Vivica A. Fox (2023)
Matthew Shepard Self - Victim (archive footage) Self - Victim (archive footage) See fewer	1	Dear Jesse (1997)
Joyce Underwood Self - Jeralee's Mother Self - Jeralee's Mother See fewer	1	Wheel of Fortune (1983)
Dave Brown Self - San Diego County Assistant Sheriff Self - San Diego County Assistant Sheriff See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Yingying Zhang Self - Victim (archive footage) Self - Victim (archive footage) See fewer	1
Jeff Underwood Self - Jeralee's Dad Self - Jeralee's Dad See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Celia Daniel Self - Tashan's Mother Self - Tashan's Mother See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Camille Browne Self - Killer (archive footage) Self - Killer (archive footage) See fewer	1	Weediquette (2016)
Linda Aitchison Self - News Editor Self - News Editor See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Bob Benton Self - Escondido Police Department Self - Escondido Police Department See fewer	1	Buried in the Backyard (2018)
Jeff Edwards Self - Former Crime Correspondent, Daily Mirror Self - Former Crime Correspondent, Daily Mirror See fewer	1	Who Killed Jill Dando? (2023)
Judy Shepard Self - Matthew's Mother Self - Matthew's Mother See fewer	1	Youth Outloud! (2001)
Emily Hogan Self - Former Student, University of Illinois Self - Former Student, University of Illinois See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Mary Schenk Self - Journalist Self - Journalist See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Brendt Christensen Self - Killer (archive footage) Self - Killer (archive footage) See fewer	1
Jim Osborn Self - Matthew's Friend Self - Matthew's Friend See fewer	1	Laramie Inside Out (2004)
Anthony Manganaro Self - FBI Special Agent Self - FBI Special Agent See fewer	1	See No Evil (2014)
Natasha Rigler Self - Eyewitness Self - Eyewitness See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Dennis Shepard Self - Matthew's Father Self - Matthew's Father See fewer	1	Matt Shepard Is a Friend of Mine (2014)
Morgan Bragg Self - Beckley PD Self - Beckley PD See fewer	1	See No Evil (2014)
Benjamin Hatfield Self - Prosecuting Attorney Self - Prosecuting Attorney See fewer	1	See No Evil (2014)
Dave O'Malley Self - Laramie Police Department Self - Laramie Police Department See fewer	1	Matt Shepard Is a Friend of Mine (2014)
Sam Blackburn Self - Senior Investigating Officer Self - Senior Investigating Officer See fewer	1	Crimes That Shook Britain (2008)
Bill Gore Self - San Diego County Sheriff Self - San Diego County Sheriff See fewer	1	The Conspiracy Files (2006)
Zhidong Wang Self - Yingying's Family Attorney Self - Yingying's Family Attorney See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
David Farrer Self - Prosecuting Counsel Self - Prosecuting Counsel See fewer	1	Britain's Most Evil Killers (2017)
Chandima Daniel Self - Tashan's Dad Self - Tashan's Dad See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Phil Harding Self - Deputy Senior Investigating Officer, Derbyshire Police Self - Deputy Senior Investigating Officer, Derbyshire Police See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Pip Short Self - Reverend Self - Reverend See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
James Benham Self - Chief of Police, Pocatello Police Department Self - Chief of Police, Pocatello Police Department See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Steve Hall Self - Door Supervisor Self - Door Supervisor See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Joshua Swaray Self - Tashan's Athletics Coach Self - Tashan's Athletics Coach See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Oceanna Daniel Self - Tashan's Sister Self - Tashan's Sister See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Angela Chard Self - Robin's Wife Self - Robin's Wife See fewer	1	One Life (2024)
Kert Howard Self - Stake President Self - Stake President See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Stephen Woliter Self - Senior Investigating Officer Self - Senior Investigating Officer See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Kirk Nelson Self - Detective Lieutenant, Pocatello Police Department Self - Detective Lieutenant, Pocatello Police Department See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Chris Thurman Self - Family Friend Self - Family Friend See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Jeralee Underwood Self - Victim (archive footage) Self - Victim (archive footage) See fewer	1
Andrew Horn Self - Church Warden Self - Church Warden See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Ralph Browning Self - Ron's Brother Self - Ron's Brother See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
John Anderson Self - Local Councillor & Charity Leader Self - Local Councillor & Charity Leader See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Leon Haque Self - Tashan's Friend Self - Tashan's Friend See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Des Thomas Self - Senior Investigating Officer Self - Senior Investigating Officer See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Steve Wade Self - Senior Investigating Officer, Northumbria Police Self - Senior Investigating Officer, Northumbria Police See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
J. Steven Beckett Self - Senior Counsel, Beckett Law Office PC Self - Senior Counsel, Beckett Law Office PC See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Dave Gee Self - Family Friend Self - Family Friend See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Peter Kerr Self - Former Vicar Self - Former Vicar See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Rexanna Browning Self - Ron's Wife Self - Ron's Wife See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Joanne Chard Self - Robin's Daughter Self - Robin's Daughter See fewer	1	Remembrance Night (2022)
Reagan Tokes Self - Victim (archive footage) Self - Victim (archive footage) See fewer	1
Michael Rainsford Self - Mikey's Father Self - Mikey's Father See fewer	1	The Two of Us (2025)
Josh Rainsford Self - Mikey's Brother Self - Mikey's Brother See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Joe Thomas Self - Crime Reporter Self - Crime Reporter See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Clifton John Williams Self - Retired Detective Chief Inspector Self - Retired Detective Chief Inspector See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Emma Finnegan Self - Mikey's Friend Self - Mikey's Friend See fewer	1	Murder in Your Ear (2020)
Gary Ridgway Self - Suspect (archive footage) Self - Suspect (archive footage) See fewer	1	Seeking Answers (2017)
Kelsey Smith Self - Victim (archive footage) Self - Victim (archive footage) See fewer	1
Mary Stavik Self - Mandy's Mother Self - Mandy's Mother See fewer	1	20/20 (1978)
Lorin Lafave Self - Breck's Mother Self - Breck's Mother See fewer	1	ITV Lunchtime News (1972)
Carlie Brucia Self - Victim (archive footage) Self - Victim (archive footage) See fewer	1
Joshua Komisarjevsky Self - Killer (archive footage) Self - Killer (archive footage) See fewer	1	The Cheshire Murders (2013)
Craig Schaeffer Self - Prosecutor Self - Prosecutor See fewer	1	See No Evil (2014)
Carl Carter Jr. Self - Beverly's Son Self - Beverly's Son See fewer	1	#TextMeWhenYouGetHome (2022)
Michaela Petit Self - Victim (archive footage) Self - Victim (archive footage) See fewer	1
Jennifer Petit Self - Victim (archive footage) Self - Victim (archive footage) See fewer	1
Missey Smith Self - Kelsey's Mother Self - Kelsey's Mother See fewer	1	The Night That Didn't End (2018)
Chloe Bednar Self - Breck's Sister Self - Breck's Sister See fewer	1	999 Murderer Calling (2024)
Carley Bednar Self - Breck's Sister Self - Breck's Sister See fewer	1	Web of Lies (2014)
Jeanne Brucia Self - Carlie's Aunt Self - Carlie's Aunt See fewer	1	See No Evil (2014)
Greg Smith Self - Kelsey's Father Self - Kelsey's Father See fewer	1	The Night That Didn't End (2018)
John Biersmith Self - Kelsey's Boyfriend (archive footage) Self - Kelsey's Boyfriend (archive footage) See fewer	1	See No Evil (2014)
Kim Carter Self - Beverly's Daughter-In-Law Self - Beverly's Daughter-In-Law See fewer	1	#TextMeWhenYouGetHome (2022)
Kevin Bowhay Self - Retired Detective Self - Retired Detective See fewer	1	Mother, May I Murder? (2023)
Matthew Barbis Self - Carlie's Cousin Self - Carlie's Cousin See fewer	1	The Rose Brucia Foundation: Stranger Safety (2012)
Dave Altimari Self - Investigative Reporter Self - Investigative Reporter See fewer	1	Aaron Hernandez Uncovered (2018)
Hayley Petit Self - Victim (archive footage) Self - Victim (archive footage) See fewer	1
William Petit Jr. Self - Survivor (archive footage) Self - Survivor (archive footage) See fewer	1
Cynthia Hawke Renn Self - Jennifer's Sister Self - Jennifer's Sister See fewer	1	People Magazine Investigates (2016)
Pedro Cadenas Self - Killer (archive footage) Self - Killer (archive footage) See fewer	1
Jeff Allison Self - Pulaski County Sheriff's Department Self - Pulaski County Sheriff's Department See fewer	1	#TextMeWhenYouGetHome (2022)
Joseph Peter Smith Self - Killer (archive footage) Self - Killer (archive footage) See fewer	1
Toby Davis Self - Sarasota Police Department Self - Sarasota Police Department See fewer	1	See No Evil (2014)
Steven Hayes Self - Killer (archive footage) Self - Killer (archive footage) See fewer	1
Gary Nicholson Self - Senior Assistant States Attorney Self - Senior Assistant States Attorney See fewer	1	Murdered at First Sight (2022)
Candace Bridges Self - Overland Park Police Department Self - Overland Park Police Department See fewer	1	The Night That Didn't End (2018)
Bob Miller Self - Overland Park Police Department Self - Overland Park Police Department See fewer	1	See No Evil (2014)
Lindsey Evans Self - Kelsey's Sister Self - Kelsey's Sister See fewer	1	The Night That Didn't End (2018)
Jorge Rodriguez Self - Victim (archive footage) Self - Victim (archive footage) See fewer	1
Beverly Carter Self - Victim (archive footage) Self - Victim (archive footage) See fewer	1
Arron Lewis Self - Killer (archive footage) Self - Killer (archive footage) See fewer	1
Carl Carter Sr. Self - Beverly's Husband (archive footage) Self - Beverly's Husband (archive footage) See fewer	1	Web of Lies (2014)
Crystal Lowery Self - Killer (archive footage) Self - Killer (archive footage) See fewer	1
Dave McEachran Self - Former Prosecuting Attorney Self - Former Prosecuting Attorney See fewer	1	The Hillside Strangler: Devil in Disguise (2022)
Mandy Stavik Self - Victim (archive footage) Self - Victim (archive footage) See fewer	1
Molly Brighton Self - Mandy's Sister Self - Mandy's Sister See fewer	1	48 Hours on ID (2010)
Ken Gates Self - Whatcom County Sheriff's Office Self - Whatcom County Sheriff's Office See fewer	1	48 Hours on ID (2010)
Doug Sutton Self - Mandy's Teacher Self - Mandy's Teacher See fewer	1	20/20 (1978)
Lewis Daynes Self - Killer (archive footage) Self - Killer (archive footage) See fewer	1
Amber Dubois Self - Victim (archive footage) Self - Victim (archive footage) See fewer	1
Chelsea King Self - Victim (archive footage) Self - Victim (archive footage) See fewer	1
John Gardner Self - Suspect (archive footage) Self - Suspect (archive footage) See fewer	1