Something that I’ve thought of before regarding the Benny and Maisy storyline is… does the world reset when Benny kills? Or just the island?
Like, if Benny kills someone, and the island resets, does the world outside the island keep moving along? Meaning if Maisy were to ever leave, she’d find herself months or years into the future, since the island resets cause time there to lag quite a bit behind normal time.
whatever time anomaly that benny possesses control over is localized entirely to the island. the way i think i want it to work is; while the world outside the island continues to move, anything on the island is sent back according to benny's influence. like, the year continues to move, the date on the calendar keeps changing, but the state the island is in reverts to before benny kills someone.
if its the 1st when they die, they're back on the 2nd, and they live the 2nd as if it's were the 1st. this can make holidays and birthdays feel a little strange; if you die on your bday, you come back the day after wondering how you missed it.
idk, its like, the shenanigans cause gaps in memory, and while a murdered villager doesn't fully remember getting killed, they do feel a certain fear when they see benny or the place where the death happened?
ive had to rethink how i want bennys reset ability to work. i want him to have more motivation to keep maisy on the island. he's got a time limit now, and he needs to make her want to stay.
perhaps there's a point where he realizes that she really is planning on leaving, and that breaks something in him. maybe he breaks his reset ability to keep the island on one singular day, so maisy cant leave.
(ive been thinking about it, and i think if i wanted there to actually be a way that maisy (potentially aided by angus) could "defeat" benny...they'd have to take him off the island where he couldn't reset.)


