notnun:
Jun You Ji Fou (君有疾否) | Ru Si Wo Wen (如似我闻)
A.K.A. Art Thou Ailing?
Links: Novelupdates | half-eaten mantou (Chrysanthemum Garden)
Tags: Historical, Action, Adventure, Comedy, Drama, Romance, Yaoi
Chapters: 92
Read on: 03/23/2025 to 03/26/2025
This novel captivated me for the entire length!! Mantou did such a good job translating this and you can feel their care in every decision made while translating. I very much enjoyed this novel, and its one I will definitely come back to read again.
Upon realization that he knew practically nothing about his political opponent, the Imperial Censor Su Shiyu, after an incident, the Imperial Marshal Chu Mingyun quickly brainstormed ways to gain information without suspicion. Investigating Su Shiyu without alarming those he shouldn’t normally wouldn’t be easy- but he had a plan. All he needed was for Su Shiyu to listen to him.
Imperial Marshal Chu thus sets his plan into motion and declares his undying love to the Imperial Censor Su in the palace after work, within earshot of other officials.
Su Shiyu: …. Are you ill?
Chu Mingyun: Yes, with lovesickness.
They can’t trust each other, but can’t help but fall in love with the other. Their trajectories and stances are complete opposite and from the start they’re doomed to a bitter ending.
Su Shiyu is the minister who is always gentle, always smiles, and does not hesitate to enact the law-even on his own relatives. He projects the image of being heartless- but who can truly have a heart of stone? He cannot waver because he already has in the past, and that cost him dearly. I loved the push and pull between them… The heartbreak Su Shiyu feels every time he struggles with his ideals versus his growing love for Chu Mingyun, and deciding to lock all his feelings and reactions deep in his heart where no one will see. I love him.
Chu Mingyun is ruthless, overbearing, but charming. He has been gathering military power for years, slowly building up his men’s loyalty to him- not the Emperor. He sees that the current Emperor will only lead the country to ruin, and is reaching forward to rectify it.
He is the one who started pursuing Su Shiyu first intending to make it easier for him to gather information on him, but fell even harder for him completely unaware. His bursts of dependency coupled with his threats to completely monopolize Su Shiyu after both had already fallen hopelessly in love with each other.. Su Shiyu allowing it while also unable to reciprocate…. Whew. It was almost agonizing seeing the two of them tear at each other in subtle and overt ways as the plot came to a head….
And I swear almost every character introduced after the first arc or so felt doomed. In a good way! It didn’t feel like the author was introducing characters to kill them off- each person was deliberate and had their own interconnections with the main protagonists… Which made it hard to see some of them get swept up in the plot and killed. I really like how the author slowly reveals the real mastermind- the readers get to be as similarly frustrated as Su Shiyu and Chu Mingyan while they investigate and connect the dots left by the evidence behind. And there was a good balance between the politics, the war, and the feelings and tension between our two ministers 🥺
In short, I’ve gained a new novel I love, two characters I adore and 100% teared up at the end of the novel with the historical account of the dynasty. I will definitely read the author’s other works! Mantou is working on a second of their novels and I definitely will await the completed notification in the CG discord 👀
- How was the translation? Excellent. Half-eaten mantou is an excellent translator, clarifying the many poems included in the text and pointing out when they had to translate things more liberally. I really appreciate the transparency and love Mantou has put into completing it. There were very few typos and missed words in the text. The inclusion of official art of a few of the scenes in the novel were also great 🥺
- Would I recommend this novel? Yes! Its not as dense as some historical novels and like I said has a good balance of everything.
- Would I reread this novel? Absoluuutely. 100%
Trigger warnings: Suicide, Poison, Sexual harassment*, Using “retarded” in the medical diagnosis sense, Gore, Child abandonment, Domestic Violence (mention), Torture, Drugs (Aphrodisiac), Child death
*Done with a purpose, disguised as him taking advantage of Su Shiyu. Past the first pat-down Su Shiyu acquiesces to Chu Mingyun’s actions and its not unconsensual. Su Shiyu would simply Not Let Him if he didn’t want to be there.
Thank you for reading my review, once again no readmore this time !! 💜💜💜
(Edit: I’d initially only placed some of my own input in the tags, but I decided that I should at least attempt to say something…)
Thank you so much for your kind words, especially regarding a translation that I really still find so much to improve on (though admittedly won’t devote much time to doing so at least for the time being, because of real-life commitments, as well as the fact that I will be removing it very soon to support the official English release anyway).
More importantly, I think you’ve captured the gist of the novel beautifully in your review (and I noticed you’ve read it within just 3 days, too). Parts where the novel may have been prone to misunderstanding were thoughtfully appreciated, and I completely agree with the parts of the novel you celebrated. It’s one of my favourite novels, and I’m really relieved to see that those things didn’t get lost in my translation…
If anyone’s seeing this, I’m seconding notnun’s recommendation of this novel – not my TL (anyway it’s probably not going to be up for much longer), but the official English translation by Rosmei, or the official Chinese physical copy by XIRON aka Mo Tie 磨铁 (Volume 1 | Volume 2) if you can read Chinese (or even the Thai release if you’re Thai…if it’s still available for sale?). You could also consider listening to the audio drama on Miss Evan – the voice actors (mainly YangKang but also the rest of them) + BGM + post-production (not to mention the art) were exquisite in my opinion! Those will definitely be fantastic ways to support the author, who has been putting up their stories for free on JJWXC. ♡