While Cup of Gold was John Steinbeck's first novel, and he spent five years working on To A God Unknown before putting it aside, The Pastures of Heaven, published in 1932, was the world's introduction to Steinbeck, whose social insight and intellectual depth are woven into stories about the struggle for survival in and around Steinbeck's hometown of Salinas. This novel consists of ten tales set in a thinly veiled version of Corral de Tierra, a valley in the hills twelve miles from Monterey, which Steinbeck names "Las Pasturas del Cielo." It's a pencil sketchbook, a minor work from Steinbeck, which means it would rate it a masterpiece by most anyone else.
The Pastures of Heaven is a beguiling collection similar in structure to Tortilla Flat or Cannery Row. If any character can claim to be the main one, it's Bert Munroe, a failed businessman who purchases the old Battle farm, a vacant property regarded as cursed by the people of the valley. Two generations of Battles were beset with epilepsy, madness and bad luck, while the family that came in 1921 vanished one day without a trace. While the Munroes find their success in the valley and are good neighbors, each character Bert Munroe associates with encounters some malady, directly or indirectly due to his presence.
Edward Wicks maintains a peach orchard and vegetable garden. Eking out a living, he derives pleasure in being considered a wealthy man, studying stocks and bonds and keeping a ledger in which he tracks his fantasy investments. His neighbors come to respect Wicks as a shrewd businessman and dub him "Shark." When his homely wife Katherine bears a gorgeous daughter named Alice, Shark becomes obsessed with protecting her virtue. All boys and men are suspected of having evil intents toward his girl, and when Shark returns from a funeral, the storekeeper T.B. Allen reports on Alice's mingling at a town dance with Bert Munroe's son, a cad named Jimmie.
As Shark walked quickly along toward the Munroe place, his thoughts raced hopelessly. He was sure of one thing, though, now that he had walked a little; he didn't want to kill Jimmie Munroe. He hadn't even been thinking about shooting him until the shopkeeper suggested the idea. Then he had acted upon it without thinking. What could he do now? He tried to picture what he would do when he came to the Munroe house. Perhaps he would have to shoot Jimmie Munroe. Maybe things would fall out in a way that would force him to commit murder to maintain his dignity in the Pastures of Heaven.
Franklin Gomez is a rancher whose hired hand stumbles home one morning with the story of a devilish child left in the brush next to the road. The baby, abandoned due to its physical deformities, is raised by Gomez by the name Tularecito, "Little Frog." At the age of six, Tularecito can do the work of a grown man, and exhibits masterful artistic ability carving animals. He nevertheless unnerves his neighbors. At the age of eleven, Tularecito is enrolled in school, where his first teacher discovers what happens when anyone destroys Little Frog's art and quits in hysterics. His second teacher, Miss Molly Morgan, breaks through to the boy by reading him faerie tales and Tularecito goes in search of his people, the gnome people, a quest which takes him to Bert Munroe's ranch.
Munroe pays a visit to a new resident, Helen Van Deventer, who has moved to the valley with her emotionally disturbed teenage daughter Hilda, who informs her mother that she plans on running away with Munroe. Junius Maltby is a clerk from San Francisco who moves to the valley for health and marries his widowed landlady. An unapologetic bookworm who's allergic to work, their orchard and vegetable bottom falls into ruin, but Junius cannot be any more happy as long as he has a book. When his wife dies of black fever, he's left to raise their son. Robbie grows up in squalor, dirt poor but happy, until Bert Munroe's wife ruins it all by donating some clothes to the boy.
Rosa and Maria Lopez are left forty acres of rocky hillside by their father and go into business making tortillas. The sisters begin providing special favors to male customers who purchase at least three items. Nothing is made of their enterprise until Bert Munroe decides to play a joke on the wife of the ugliest man in town, who he catches accepting a ride to Salinas in Rosa's carriage. Munroe is elected to the school board, where he meets their new schoolteacher, Miss Molly Morgan. Molly has lost contact with her father, but maintains romantic illusions about the life he's living, fantasies that are shattered when Munroe regales the board with tales of his drunken ranch hand.
One time their father went away, and he never came back. He had never sent any money, nor had he ever written to them, but this time he just disappeared, for good. For two years they waited, and then their mother said he must be dead. The children shuddered at the thought, but they refused to believe it, because no one so beautiful and fine as their father could be dead. Some place in the world he was having adventures. There was some good reason why he couldn't come back to them. Some day when the reason was gone, he would come: some morning he would be there with finer presents and better stories than ever before.
The people of the Pastures of Heaven can't catch a break around Bert Munroe. Raymond Banks owns the valley's most admired ranch, a clean poultry farm. Beloved by the children, Banks is friends with the warden at San Quentin and maintains the somewhat unusual habit of serving as witness to hangings there. Munroe becomes obsessed with this and against his better judgment, asks Banks if he can come along. Pat Humbert inherits an old farmhouse with five rooms from his aging parents at the age of thirty and after they pass, refuses to spend any time in or on the house as he can. This changes when he overhears Bert Munroe's daughter Mae discussing Vermont houses.
The Whitesides are the first family of the Pastures of Heaven. Their patriarch, Richard Whiteside, constructs a house so grand that it would pass from generation to generation and serve as the homestead for a dynasty. Fate deals his wife Alicia the blow of being able to deliver only one child, which they name John. He inherits his father's love of Greek history and philosophy and admires the house even more. His heir Bill gravitates more toward mechanics than literature or history, and the Whiteside dynasty is threatened when Bill becomes engaged to Bert Munroe's daughter Mae, who makes it known that she prefers to live in town.
Time will tell whether The Pastures of Heaven features stories vivid enough for me to bring up in conversation the way I do with Tortilla Flat or Cannery Row, stories that spring to my mind as effortlessly as some generate fantasy football stats. Unlike Steinbeck's later portmanteau books, this one lacks vagabond wit and biting political satire I love in his work. This early Steinbeck is almost Gothic in its presentation of a "cursed" family, decent folk who nonetheless seem to be carrying some sort of evil with them, visiting misfortune upon their neighbors in strange ways. With the insight that comes so effortlessly to Steinbeck, he indicates the people of the valley might have been asking for it.
It is a difficult thing and one requiring great tact quickly to become accepted in a rural community. The people of the valley had watched the advent of the Munroe family with a little animosity. The Battle farm was haunted. They had always considered it so, even those who laughed at the idea. Now a man came along and proved them wrong. More than that, he changed the face of the countryside by removing the accursed farm and substituting a harmless and fertile farm. The people were used to the Battle place as it was. Secretly they resented the change.
The more time I have to think about The Pastures of Heaven, the richer it becomes. To call it the "worst" John Steinbeck book I've read so far is like calling Bridget Fonda the "worst" actor in her family tree or Ringo Starr the "worst" Beatle, meaning it should be considered blasphemy. But as of today, due to popular demand, here's my list of John Steinbeck books ranked from favorite to least favorite:
1. East of Eden (1952)
2. The Grapes of Wrath (1939)
3. Sweet Thursday (1954)
4. Of Mice and Men (1937)
5. The Wayward Bus (1947)
6. Tortilla Flat (1935)
7. The Winter of Our Discontent (1961)
8. Cannery Row (1945)
9. Travels with Charley: In Search of America (1962)
10. The Pastures of Heaven (1932)