Kimberley Burg's Reviews > Resistance Women

Resistance Women by Jennifer Chiaverini
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
57329714
's review

really liked it
Read 2 times. Last read January 2, 2019 to January 14, 2019.

Just started this book and feel an eerie similarity to our current situation in the United States as the unthinkable builds in 1930's Germany. Well written if not fast paced. The slow pace of the book provides a sense of the unthinkable unfolding and reminds the reader of how glacial change can be destructive, perhaps more so than a catastrophic sudden shift. A lengthy book reflective of the topic and the period.
209 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Resistance Women.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 2, 2019 – Started Reading
January 2, 2019 – Started Reading
January 2, 2019 – Shelved
January 2, 2019 –
page 0
0.0%
Finished Reading
January 14, 2019 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-39 of 39 (39 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Nancy (new) - added it

Nancy does it have bad words, or sexual scenes?


Tri-reader I felt the same way about the similarity to our current US situation as I read the book.


Stacy You know what- I kept thinking the same thing when I was reading it- how much it is like our current situation


message 4: by Poppy (new)

Poppy Even tho is hard to even think what about the Holocaust is the most disturbing, I'm always unsettled by how gradual it all was. I don't want to get paranoid or anything, but I always think of this whenever I get lazy in regards to keeping up with politics, legislation and the sort-it just wakes me up a bit to the importance of paying attention to small changes and a gradual, imperceptible/unnoticeable shift, because of the eventual situations they may precede.


message 5: by Cathy Wilson (new)

Cathy Wilson Can't wait to get this book. I love Chiaverini. I've read every book she has written.


Roberta Nelson i agree that this book is unsettling as it is so similar to what is happening in our country. Some of the sentences belong in today's papers..............very scary.


Gale Clark I am in the process of reading the book and I agree, it sounds like today in the US political world-It is scary. The research for this book is excellent.


Kathy Muzzey I am midway thru the book and I too feel the similarities to our current environment due to the policies of this administration. Very scary!


message 9: by Leigh Anne (new)

Leigh Anne Bedingfield How does it “sound” like our politics today? That is a big statement.


message 10: by Tomi (new) - added it

Tomi Cheeks THIS WAS ECACTLY MY THOUGHT TOO!!!


Barbara Well, one way is one can compare Antifa to the Brown Shirts!


Jennifer Jayne Metzler I completely agree. One of the paragraphs about change just for the sake of it was very reminiscent of today's politics. I am not done yet but many chilling similarities.


Lucinda I agree also. We are to be mindful of world events and learn from the mistakes of the past and work hard that they are not repeated.


Christine All the way through this book I was also reminded of our current situation in the U.S. The similarities are impossible to ignore. Scary!


Marie-Eve I'm currently reading it, up to page 142 and having read many WW2 books and novels, I'm really enjoying it.


Darlene Toth I do not see the correlation with the US
And facist Germany??


message 17: by Joy (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joy Watkins I felt the same way about our current situation. At one point when they are talking about their leaders, they say they don’t know who to believe(so true in our country today) and at another point they are thinking that the unbelievable could never occur in their country. I too have felt this about America. I never thought our country would just shut down or that people would treat one another the way they are now. It’s crazy!


Elytta Durkee I couldn’t agree with you more. I felt the same way. Eerily similar to today’s leftists in this country.


Joyce So many comments posted reflect my own impressions halfway through book. Refusal to accept election results, calling main stream press liars- sound familiar. Dictators share similar traits, regardless of geography.


Suzanne Mundy This was a favorite of mine. I like Chiaverini's stand alone books better than the quilting series. I am currently reading "Mrs. Lincoln's Dressmaker".


Suzanne Mundy I liked it very much. I really like her stand alone books.
Good historical fiction.


Jenna fossum I agree that there’s similarities in this book to the US today. It was scary reading some parts.


Zippy Oh my hosh I am just so happy to see that others saw the parallels to current day piloting in the United States


Sarah Spille I know you wrote this years ago but my goodness I can’t help reading all the current similarities into this book


message 25: by Evan (new) - rated it 4 stars

Evan Hammerman Barbara wrote: "Well, one way is one can compare Antifa to the Brown Shirts!"

Don't forget to add the Marxist, anti-family, anti-Semitic, domestic terrorist organization Black Lives Matter.


message 26: by Evan (new) - rated it 4 stars

Evan Hammerman Zippy wrote: "Oh my hosh I am just so happy to see that others saw the parallels to current day piloting in the United States"

All through the book I noticed that the Democrats are also consolidating power the same way the National Socialists did, by "not letting a good crisis go to waste" and taking advantage of the COVID pandemic. The Democrats already have the media sewn up. Look how they got away with their treatment of President Trump.


Susan Kluger I agree that the book eerily reflected the mood and attitude of our country today. Fascism can pop up anywhere if the citizens allow it.


Ashley Murphy I've read a lot of WW2 books in the last 2 years and the similarities in all of them to the situations today are scary. We have also asked the question on how the Holocaust could happen, but with current situations the way they are, you can easily see how it happened and it's so sad. Did we learn nothing?


message 29: by Judy (new) - added it

Judy Gordon It is interesting and noteworthy that so many see parallels to current political issues, but see them from different sides of today's politics.


message 30: by Evan (new) - rated it 4 stars

Evan Hammerman I think the American people have finally seen what the Democrats are about. The Democrats are rightfully dreading the coming midterm elections.


message 31: by Rita (new) - rated it 5 stars

Rita Moore I too was struck eerily by the similarities to todays politics.


PANicholson Just reading this book and as a child of a mother who survived Nazi Germany, I can’t help but see the early similarities to her experience and our current political situation which seems impossible, but showing signs of fascism and control of women, education, and our political system.


Lolsen5 Dang, five years later… just finished this and was thinking the same!


message 34: by Teri (new) - added it

Teri U'Sellis Couldn’t agree more. A bit terrifying.


Michelle Sauer February 2025, as I am reading this, I can't help but make massive comparisons from this book to current events in the US. Terrifying. So many similarities.


Margaret Me too.


Patricia Boegli I agree! Years later and a more precarious political situation. I had to take time to remind myself I wasn’t reading a current newspaper.


Kayla Arntz It’s terrifying how people can be so easily manipulated into blaming others, who are struggling as well, for the problems that the people in charge create. I’m scared


Heather November 2025- so many parallels to the US today, that if we changed the names, locations, and dates, we’d be reading a book about our life in the present tense.


back to top