*** Note: this review follows a format intended for the "Group Read" in the Action/Adventure Afficionados discussion group. It may not conform to what your used to, but, it'll make sense... at least I hope it makes sense. End Note***
1. Did you feel that this was a good zombie novel?
Well, it’s a good book, it has Zombies in it, but it might be premature to call it a “Zombie Novel.” It was more action adventure with a risk of zombie apocalypse…and…it was a GOOD one.
2. Action scenes. How did they work for you? What kicks the action up a notch for you?
The action scenes were good. At times I think we got too much into the “blow by blow” but, I’m not sure I’d cut that part because this is a case where one bite and it’s the end of the world or a bullet to the head (or both).
I really found the cranberry fight to be very intense. It reminded me of the TNT movie Gettysburg and the stand on Little Round Top. That kind of old world pitched battle where the defenders stand in ranks firing into the rushing tide hoping they are not swept away by them. It kind of reminds me of Carl Sanburg. You know…
“Pile the bodies high at Auterlitz and Waterloo….Pile the bodies high at Ypres and Verdon…I’m the Grass, I cover all….Let me work.” Or something like that.
It really reminded me of those Revolutionary War battles or Civil War battles where it’s stand, fire, reload while the next rank fires and the bodies pile up on the ground at your feet. It’s so important to get the “High Ground.”
3. Characters? Who did you like the most, the least? Who was least fleshed out (no pun intended), and who the most?
Wow, I liked the supporting cast, and of course Joe was a great anti-hero/smart ass. I think it’s a tossup between Rudy and Church for most liked. We didn’t get much info on Church, but, I took that to more an artistic choice to keep him a mystery, than a “lack of fleshing out.” I would have liked to know how much like Church, Ledger actually is, because it seems like they have similar roots. I would have said “Grace” but about half way, we got all of the info on Grace to know what we needed to know about her.
I think we could have known more about Ollie, but probably Bunny Rabbit (love the name) was the one we got only a little sketchy info on. I think Top got unfolded gradually and I might have liked maybe an intro story on him at some point (flash back?) though I’m not sure where I’d put it.
So that leaves Toys as the guy who had the biggest role and we had the least information on. We also have a lot of open questions about him.
4. The science. Was it plausible? Did Maberry do a good job of explaining things without slowing the story down?
I don’t think the science slowed things down. I think we barely got enough of it. We got what was important and Maberry was inventive using Rudy to track down some of the info on “Prions” so we weren’t wallowing around lost in the dark when Hu started explaining things.
Plausible… dahhh… works for me? I’ll buy it. Of course, I’m not much of a Neuro-pharmacology expert. In other words, I’m ignorant enough to buy it, like it and enjoy it.
5. Pacing? Too good, not good, perfect?
That depends on what kind of story you consider this. To me this matched up better with books like “The Sentry” (Robert Crais) and “The Pawn” (Steven James), more so The Pawn. This was about trying to catch terrorists before they end the world. Maybe another good comparison is “Hades Factor” by Gale Lynds and Robert Ludlum (mostly Lynds). So, as a Zombie Book, it probably seemed a bit slow and deep on mystery. For an action adventure (Rollins Style) it’s closer in pace but didn’t built to the huge over the top action sequence conclusion like those do (I thought the Craberrie was more tense than the final scenes). And, even though this was not a book of magic and the occult, it was a lot like the Dresden Files in pace. The high pitch in the middle to last third of the book, the end more intense in meaning and answering mysteries, less intense in action.
So, as it appealed to me, it was in the Steven James's "The Pawn" mode most of the time and, the pace was good for that. I won't say "Perfect" but, it's certainly not an issue I'd raise. It was "good."
6. The Department of Military Science. What do you think?
The Monster Control Bureau without Monsters that matched up better with the Shequay from “The Rook” than anything. Church reminded me of “Archangel” from the old “Air Wolf” series. It was very much like “Fringe” the TV Show, which used the FBI and created a pocket division to suit the story needs. “Seen one Top Secret-Super-Secret Police/Spy organization, seen ‘em all”
I happen to like the institution in Action Adventure/Espionage and other type things. They were a heck of a lot easier to like than Larry Correa’s “Monster Control Bureau.”
7. Favorite moments.
Ledger meets his team.
8. Overall rating: out of 1-10 or 1-5 stars?
4 to 4.5 stars out of 5. For me it seemed that Mayberry went out of his way to show the courageous side of humanity as it is, imperfect, scarred and very capable of evil and good. I really liked the PTSD (ish) elements. There were some technical issues but, overall, he got the most important parts about what Trauma does to people right. Alpha Team’s survivors performance going down, not up things like that. Rudy’s inclusion made things work a lot better. It seemed that the difference between what made the good guys “Good” guys and the bad guys “Bad” guys had more to do with a shred of compassion for each other. .. a very small shred. In a genre that might as well have not bothered with this particular side of humanity and still be popular, that’s worth some credit from me.
I get tired of heroes slaughtering mountains of men, witnessing unspeakable horrors and not coming away with anything more staining and debilitating than muddy shoes and somebody else’s problems.
9. Books you'd recommend like this one?
Oh, yeah, I recommend it!
10. Will you continue the series?
Absolutely, in my own methodical way I’m sure to read them as long as they keep the things I like about them going so, count me in on the next book. (I’m not particularly fast at reading series anymore, only one has captured my attention long enough to push through book by book, in a long time, and that may have been a combination of things unusually coming together at the right time for me.)