0% found this document useful (0 votes)
210 views10 pages

Design Development of 9.759km Long Six Lane Extradosed Bridge Project Crossing River Ganga in The State of Bihar, India

1) The document describes the design development of a 9.759km long six lane extradosed bridge project crossing the River Ganga in Bihar, India. 2) An extradosed bridge concept was chosen over other options like balanced cantilever or steel truss bridges due to span length requirements for navigation clearance and the ability to reduce deck stiffness. 3) The bridge design was finalized with a 450m unit block length consisting of a 150m central span flanked by two 75m end spans, with monolithic connections between the superstructure and substructure.

Uploaded by

Aashish kumar
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
210 views10 pages

Design Development of 9.759km Long Six Lane Extradosed Bridge Project Crossing River Ganga in The State of Bihar, India

1) The document describes the design development of a 9.759km long six lane extradosed bridge project crossing the River Ganga in Bihar, India. 2) An extradosed bridge concept was chosen over other options like balanced cantilever or steel truss bridges due to span length requirements for navigation clearance and the ability to reduce deck stiffness. 3) The bridge design was finalized with a 450m unit block length consisting of a 150m central span flanked by two 75m end spans, with monolithic connections between the superstructure and substructure.

Uploaded by

Aashish kumar
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 10

Design Development of 9.

759km Long Six Lane


Extradosed Bridge Project Crossing River
Ganga in the State of Bihar, INDIA
P R Vital Veera1, Inki Choi1, R Kasi Viswanath1
1 L&T Construction, Chennai, Tamilnadu, India

Abstract
The paper narrates the purpose of the six Lane highway project linking between
north and south zone of Bihar state with 9.759km long extradosed bridge crossing
River Ganga and necessity of adopting extradosed bridge concept for crossing the
entire 9.759km length. Development of structural scheme like bifurcation of the
overall bridge into individual blocks, span configuration, type of connection between
substructure and superstructure have been articulated. Also necessity to adopt well
foundations; design development as per construction methodology; expansion joint
with Needle Beam concept; deck segment section finalization have been explained.
One of the most critical phase in the project is the junction development over main
bridge. Which establishes the connection with the island by ramp structures in the
midway of the Bridge. The proposed ramp structures just above the High Flood
Level in junction development to facilitate as a rescue shelter during high floods.
The paper concludes with benefits and difficulties of extradosed concept is used in
this project over traditional balanced cantilever bridges for widen decks to
accommodate six lanes of vehicular traffic with both side footpaths.
Keywords: Extradosed Bridge; Well Foundations; Expansion Joint; Bihar.

1 Introduction
Bihar, a state in eastern part of India has the immense potential of industrial growth
which needs better connectivity of villages and towns with nearest cities and cities
are interlinked with highway and expressways. The government of Bihar initiated a
comprehensive plan to develop highways through Bihar State Road Development
Corporation Limited (BSRDCL). As a part of this development, BSRDCL has
proposed the construction of Six Lane Extradosed Cable Bridge over River Ganga
between Kacchi Dargah and Bidupur banks under Engineering, Procurement and
Construction (EPC) mode of contract. The total project corridor length of 22.76km,
in which 9.759km width of Ganga River needs to be crossed by bridging inhabited
areas on both sides.

Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use


Figure 1 Site Location showing Project Alignment
The functional requirements of project as per client requirements and site
constraints are shown in Table1 and are used for development of concept within
these boundary limitations.
Table 1: Functional Requirement of the Project
S. No. Functional Requirements
1 Total Main Bridge Length – 9759m
2 Total Main Bridge should be Six Lane Carriageway
Each Span Navigation Clearance - 100m horizontal and 10m vertical
3
above HFL
4 All foundations for main bridge should be Well Foundations
High Embankments on approaches to Main Bridge should be avoided
5
for height more than 7m and should be replaced with Elevated Viaducts
The width requirements for the main bridge deck also produced in Table 2 as per
client requirements and also has to satisfy the provisions as per Indian Standard
“IRC SP 87:2013[2] - Manual of Specifications and Standards for six Laning of
Highways through Public Private Partnership”.
Table 2: Carriageway Width of Main Bridge
Description Dimensions
Carriageway 2 X 10.5 = 21.0 m
Crash Barrier 2 X 0.45 = 0.90 m
Footpath 2 X 1.50 = 3.00 m
Shy distance + Paved shoulders 4 X 0.50 + 2 X 1.5 = 5.00 m
Railing Kerb 2 X 0.30 = 0.60 m
Median including Crash Barrier 2 X 0.45 + 2.00 = 2.90 m
Total Deck Width 32.4 m

Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use


2 Need of 9759m Long Bridge to Cross River Ganga and
Extradosed concept
The project intends to connect Northern Bihar with Patna and to make connection
with Island villages. The present perennial channels of Ganga River carry the flow
within the width of 2.7km which keep on meandering in any direction within the both
banks of the overall river width i.e. 9.759km as per study on past 100 years
morphology data of River Ganga at this location. With reference to the studies on
morphological changes, the main bridge is proposed for the entire 9759m length to
cross River Ganga as a best suitable option at this location.
Ganga River is an important navigation channel in India and termed as National
Waterway 01 (NW-01) as per Inland Waterways Authority of India (IWAI). The river
needs sufficient navigational clearance as per IWAI, which is 100m for horizontal
clearance and vertical clearance (below soffit of girder) of 10m above navigational
HFL for the entire bridge as stated in the Indian Standard IRC-06[3]. Based on this
criteria, three different studies conducted by Client with different superstructure
options i.e. PSC Segmental balanced cantilever, Steel Truss and extradosed Stay
Cable. By considering the span length requirement to accommodate navigational
clearance and six lanes wide deck, the extradosed stay cable bridge emerges out
to be a better option based on site constraints.
The following points further reiterates the suitability of the extradosed bridge option
a. The precast balanced cantilever concept needs two separate decks with each
having three lanes, it is limited by the lifting capacity of erection tackle. It is
unfavorable in this project based on construction period and cost.
b. Steel Truss can be one of the better options but costs much more compared
to prestressed concrete Bridge. Refer Table 3 for preliminary cost estimation.
c. Extradosed concept is hybrid design methodology between balanced
cantilever & Cable Stayed bridges, where deck segment stiffness can be
reduced compared to deck stiffness for balanced cantilever option by
introducing stay cables externally.
[1]
Table 3. Preliminary Price Comparison for 9756.5m (During Conceptual Stage)
S.No. Type of Structure Preliminary Estimated Price
(Crores* in INR)
1 Balanced Cantilever Bridge 2598.38
2 Steel Girder Bridge 5443.17
3 Extradosed Bridge 2231.18
* 1 Crore INR = 10,000,000 INR

3 Concept development and design details


Based on the Client’s decision and as per the preliminary cost estimation,
extradosed bridge concept is adopted in the project. Accordingly 150m span is
considered for main bridge and further optional studies with different span
configurations between expansion joints are carried out.

Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use


Span Configuration Initial optional study as below -
Option 1: Bearing system with 4 pylons, unit block of 600m (75+150+150+150+75)
Option 2: Bearing system with 5 pylons, unit block of 750m
(75+150+150+150+150+75)
Option 3: Monolithic with 3 pylons, unit block of 450m (75+150+150+75)

With reference to the above three options, Option-3 is finalized based on technical
aspects Long-term/Temperature effects; Pre-camber control; Construction
methodology as well as optimization of structural components.
As shown in the Figure. 2, typical unit block with a length of 450m between both
side expansion joints. The connection between superstructure and substructure is
made monolithic based on design criteria which helps to ensure stability during
construction and also eliminate maintenance for bearings. Seven stay cables on
each side of pylon have been used and anchored in the median of deck. Due to
stiffness of deck and lesser height of upper pylons, stress variation due to traffic
load in stay cable is much lessor than conventional cable stayed bridge and this
helps to mitigate the concern regarding fatigue in stay cables.

Figure 2 Elevation of the Typical Block


Also the extradosed bridge improves architectural view of the bridge, the aesthetic
appearance of Kacchi Dargah Bridge is shown in Figure. 3.

Figure 3 Aesthetic appearance of Extradosed Bridge


3.1 Analysis and Design
The design of extradosed bridge is developed in accordance with IRC bridge
design specifications and SETRA recommendations for stay-cable design, testing,
and installation. Design speed adopted in the project is 100kmph for main

Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use


carriageway. Further, construction stage analysis is carried out considering the
erection sequence, time dependent material property and changes in boundary
conditions. Also detailed FEM analysis using plate model is carried out in order that
the load transferring mechanism from the Stay cable to deck and internal strut is
clarified.
3.2 Geometry
The extradosed main bridge consists of 22 blocks of two-span continuous having
span arrangement of 75m + 2X150m + 75m with three monolithic pylons. Lower
pylons are having heights of 18.35m. Double-D type well foundations are adopted
based on scour conditions and subsurface soil data. Part of the span loads from
superstructure are transferred to foundations through upper pylons by stay cables
on each side of pylons.
Depth of box girder is typically 4.0m and varies up to 5.0m near to pylon over a
length of around 14.5m on both sides of pylon. As deck width of superstructure is
32.4m and bridge is located in high seismic area (Zone IV), the weight of the
superstructure deck is minimized by providing internal and external struts along
with transverse PT in the top slab of the deck. Internal struts at cable anchorage
zone is strengthened by internal tendons to transfer the stay force to webs. Typical
cross sectional view of precast segmental box girder with internal and external
struts are shown in Figure. 4.

Figure 4 Cross sectional details of Girder


Double leaf reinforced concrete (RC) column is adopted for lower pylon which is
connected to the girder as a monolithic connection. The shape of the proposed
lower pylon has key merits such as imparting flexibility against thermal or long term
displacement thus providing feasible solution to eliminate bearing. The issue of
bearing maintenance is eliminated with this arrangement. However, in order to
mitigate the long term displacement due to creep/shrinkage, pre-setting back of
both cantilever tips is adopted by using prejacking before closing the gap with the
key segment.
3.3 Well Foundation
Based on detailed soil investigation, sub-surface profile along the main bridge
corridor generally consists of loose, dense and very dense sand below the ground
surface. Also hard and stiff clay layer is present in the upper part of ground at few
boring locations. Scour is one of the governing parameter for stability and design
adequacy check of well foundation. Scour is derived based on silt factor, design
discharge (i.e. 106,839cumecs as per hydraulic study) and width of water channel.

Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use


Based on preliminary check of scour depth, well foundation depth has to be decided
to proceed further design checks like Safe Bearing Capacity and Stability.
Graphical representation of silt factors corresponding to different pier locations are
shown in Figure. 5.
2.2
2.0
1.8 Design Silt Factor
1.6
1.4
Silt Factor

1.2
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0 Location

Figure 5 Silt Factor Distribution for all Pier Locations and Design Silt Factor
Accordingly, the design silt factor of 0.9 is finalized based on above graph. Then
the scour parameters of the bridge are estimated based on hydrology data and
geotechnical investigation report. Typical cross section of Double D well foundation
is shown in Figure. 6 with High flood level, Scour level, etc.
The embedded portion of the well foundation from the scour level is called the grip
length. In order to design the well foundation, the provisions in IRC 78:2014[4] need
to be satisfied prior to analysis of the complete model i.e. the minimum grip length,
the maximum depth of scour and the minimum steining wall thickness. Stability
checks are performed as per IRC: 45-1972 as the subsoil condition below scour
occur cohesionless. Once the stability checks are satisfied then the structural
design has to be done as per IRC 112:2011[5].

Figure 6 Well Foundation Details (All dimensions in m).


3.3.1 Methodology for sinking of well foundation
Construction Methodology adopted for well foundation includes self-sinking by
gravity and specialized sinking methods. Additional sinking efforts like air and water
jetting are considered to overcome the skin resistance of the well foundation during
sinking as specialized sinking methods. The following are the sequence of activities
and actual site photos related to well sinking.

Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use


a. Placing cutting edge on the ground
b. Sinking cutting edge and casting the steining wall
c. Sinking, Casting and dredging process

d. Setting rock anchors & beams with Hydraulic jack setup


e. Sinking by hydraulic jack, casting of steining & dredging
f. Completion of casting & Sinking up to founding level

g. Completion of casting & Sinking up to founding level


h. Sand filling & Casting of well cap

On Site Activities
i. Rebar Arrangement
j. Concrete Pouring
k. Mucking & Sinking Arrangement and ready for next lift

3.4 Needle Beam


For any typical block (Figure 3), proposed expansion joint at middle of span as
shown in Figure.7. This type of joint is commonly used in balanced cantilever
erection. Merit of this type joint is that the number of end span pier is minimized
and there is no additional temporary structure required for end span erection.
However, excessive deflection at joint in the middle of span mainly due to long term
deflection induces discomfort to the drivers and also involves significant
maintenance cost.
To mitigate this concern about the expansion joint in the middle of span, a structural
beam adopted as shown in the Figure 7. This beam once installed at final
construction stage will restrain the deflection due to traffic loads and provide better
comfort level to the driver as well.

Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use


Figure 7 Needle Beam Arrangement near EJ
3.5 Stay cable
A single plane of cables consisting of 7x2=14 Nos. per pylon are located on the
bridge centerline. Stay cables are planned to be tensioned from inside the deck
and spaced at a distance 6m along deck and 1.5m along the pylon height. The
cable design is verified in SLS, ULS and resistance verification for rupture of
extradosed cable are done using SETRA Recommendations (SETRA 2001). In the
present design condition, ULS condition is governing for the design of cable.
3.6 Methodology for erecting precast segments
The construction methodology of the typical block of main bridge involves the
precast segmental balanced cantilever construction method using derrick crane.
The pier table is constructed by cast-in situ method. The construction scheme
proposed for the main bridge is shown in Figure. 8.

a. Fabrication of reinforcing bar and casting concrete for lower pylon.


b. Installation of the temporary support system for pier table.
c. Construction of pier table and pylon.

d. Transportation of segments by trailer.


e. Installation of segment in due sequence by derrick crane.
f. Tensioning the cable and tendon in due sequence.

Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use


g. Lifting of key segment formwork by derrick crane.
h. Lifting of internal movement joint.
i. Construction of key segment.
j. Installation of internal movement joint (Needle Beam).

k. Installation of the expansion joint.


l. Installation of wearing surface and road facilities
Figure 8. Construction methodology
The construction load considered in the analysis model is divided into two groups.
One is for the stage by stage analysis and the other for stability check during
construction. In general, construction loads are very varied and the IRC: 6[3] do not
define the characteristic values of the construction loads for these kind of similar
bridges. Thus for construction loads, Eurocode 1991-1-6 is referred.

4 Junction Development in Island


4.1 Need of connection with Island

Raghopur is an inhabited island with agricultural farms and villages sited between
two perennial channels of River Ganga in Vaishali district in Bihar. At present the
island is connected to Patna by pontoon bridge in dry season and by waterway
during rest of the seasons. The need of connecting the island is essential not only
based on present habitation but also for the future development of the Patna City
as a satellite location to the City and at the same time the effect of flooding needs
to be considered as per the past records can be addressed properly. Accordingly,
it is decided to provide the facility platform immediately at the end of Ramps from
Main Bridge which can be useful as rescue platform during floods.
4.2 Design development of Island Junction
Developing the junction in the Island over main bridge and connect the island on
both sides with ramp structures is the challenging task in the project. At a junction
block, the deck width has to be increased gradually to 52.2m as per IRC standards
to facilitate connecting ramps. It should also satisfy the navigational criteria and
client’s requirement as extradosed bridge concept. The navigational clearance for
each span needs to be maintained as the river can be meandering in any direction

Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use


until it is guided in future with river training works. Developed the extradosed bridge
design concept satisfies both the criteria as well as varying deck width as shown
in Figure 9.

Figure 9. Junction Development in Island

5 Conclusion
Once construction is completed the six lane extradosed bridge would be the longest
extradosed bridge in the world having total length of 9.759km with 150m each span.
The project will become testimonial and one of the major landmarks for similar
projects around the globe. Internal and external struts along with transverse
tendons in top slab are adopted in decks in order to minimize the segment weight
is one the best value engineering. Pier table monolithically connected with pylon
tower thus eliminating the need of any bearing with recurring maintenance. Needle
beam expansion joint at the mid span is adopted in design in order to provide
smooth driving facility to the vehicles. Extradosed option is one of the best options
for long spans between 100m to 150m than balanced cantilever deck with internal
prestressing. This is also evidenced while carrying out various design options at
the project design development stage.
This iconic bridge is well poised to become a global Bench Mark in long span bridge
construction and will also be a source of encouragement to develop similar
landmark bridges in India and elsewhere.

REFERENCES:

[1] Feasibility report on project provided by client Bihar State Road Development
Corporation Limited (BSRDCL).
[2] Manual of specification and standards for six laning of highways through public
private partnership - IRC SP 87 - 2013,
[3] Standard specifications and code of practice for road bridges, section ii – loads
and stresses - IRC 6 - 2014,
[4] Standard specifications and code of practice for road bridges, section vii –
foundations and substructure - IRC 78 - 2014,
[5] Code of practice for concrete road bridges - IRC 112 – 2011,

Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use

You might also like