scum villain is a greek tragedy disguised as a regular tragedy disguised as a comedy disguised as a danmei
this is going to be long, and this is only PART ONE.
a.k.a, Analysing the plot of Scum Villain’s Self Saving System through Aristotle’s Poetics, because I Have Mental Issues
And then also the tragedy of Tianlang-jun forever ago. Having power and happiness, and losing it to his trust in Su Xiyan, his "undemonlike" belief in kindness. When we see him in SVSSS, he's already lost everything, his story is long over. All that's left is hatred and sadness. When he realizes his trust in Su Xiyan was mever misplaced, there's no more point to his hatred.
And Zhuzhi-Lang, who's frequently mentioned and very obvious fatal flaw is his need to repay his debts. Like, so many characters bemoan his inability to let the smallest kindness go. And his inability to truly understand what kindness others would want. To the point that he loses whatever kindness he initially recieved. His humanoid form, his power, his life. There really is no other end for him in a tragic text like SVSSS, and that's not fair actually, and fuck that.
And Yue Qingyuan, losing the only person he cares about over and over again, because he can't see past his need to help him (And because he refuses to ever fucking communicate, the self-sacrificial self-hating bastard). He's foolhardy in choosing Xuan Su, far too soon, and too powerful for him anyways, because he needs to get back to Shen Jiu as soon as possible. When he finally gets Shen Jiu back, he does everything to try and make him happy, except the one thing Shen Jiu actually wants, to have saved him in the first place (or to actually tell him that he tried to go back, he just failed). In PIDW, he sacrifices himself again, just for the chance to save Shen Jiu from his fate. And in SVSSS, he loses Shen Jiu entirely, for no other reason than that he could never have him. I just. he makes me sick /pos. The only time he tells the truth about what happened, the person who needs to hear it is already long gone.
I feel like Mobei-Jun and Shang Qinghua of SVSSS are the only not-technically tragic characters. Maybe if you include their extras, but even then it still feels like more of a stupid sweet (sadistic) love story. It definitely could have ended tragic, but, it feels like even for all of Airplane's flaws (his lack of spine, his willingness to do whatever must be done to survive, his disregard for his own pain or feelings) he's kind of just vibing in the gutter the whole time. Maybe he lost everything when he transmigrated, but he ends up getting everything he ever wanted in Mobei-jun. so like. not a bad deal. My favorite snivelling rat <3
Anyway I'm gonna go stare into the middle distance mourning the things that could never happen in SVSSS, and the many side tragedies that will forever haunt me (and then read a bunch of fanfics)







