Sins of the Flesh (priest!Dave York x f!reader)
Pairing:Ā priest!Dave York x f!reader
Summary:Ā His mind shouldnāt be on the new catechesis teacher as he cleaned the chalice after handing communion. His thoughts shouldnāt be on the young girl he knew for so long as he blessed the congregation and finished mass.
But you were different now. Something in you had changed. āLord, have mercy on me.ā
Word count: +10.9k
Warnings: religion! catholic religion to be precise, a lot A LOT of religious references and undertones (shot every time you find one lmao), age gap (around 15 years, reader is legal), smut, unprotected p in v, oral sex, breaking of celibacy vows!, catholic guilt, me making divine metaphors⦠i think thats it.
A/N: first of all this is all @asta-lilyāās fault, she asked why no one had turned this man into a priest and i said āok ill do itā so i did it, she is to blame. also i wanna say thanks to the pocket wives that encouraged this creation, sorry my loves, this isnt as slutty as yall thought lmao, and thanks to @alliterative-albatrossā who gave me all the bible verses that shaped this story as well. and i wanna thank the creator of this playlist that i listened over and over while writing this, and yeah, sorry for this monstrosity, love you <3
Masterlist // Read on ao3 // ko-fi
comments and reblogs are eternally appreciated š

moodboard by @asta-lily
āSo whoever knows the right thing to do and fails to do it, for him it is sin.āāJames 4:12.
Sunday 1.
Like a piece in a puzzle.
Thatās how you fit in.
There, sitting in the middle of a ten people polished wood bench, eyes on the four feet tall crucified Jesus on the wall above the altar, ready for the first sermon you were to hear after coming back home.
Home. That was the name.
That church felt like home.
You were enjoying sitting there, among the children you met a couple of hours earlier when you were introduced to them as their new catechesis teacher, breathing in and out the myrrh incense burning and invading the navel and your lungs, filling them with new energy, getting them ready to feel the love that you were sure was about to pour over you.
You heard your name behind you and you turned around to see Mrs. Stevens, one of your motherās friends waving at you from two rows behind.
āHi, honey!ā she smiled at you and immediately you reciprocated āI heard you were in town, are you staying this time?ā
You drowned a chuckle inside your chest and bit your lip, nodding. Just realizing you even had missed the venomous messages hidden behind the kind words mouthed by old catholic moms.
āYes, Mrs. Stevens, Iām staying this time.ā you replied, the woman lifted her hand a bit to the sky and you smirked to her.













