Something something people not knowing the history something …
I am increasingly of the view that the besetting flaw of modern, internet-based, leftist-progressive culture is the tendency to take concepts that were intended as consciousness-raising, “have you noticed”/“makes you think” moments and treat them as all-encompassing rules for life. The Bechdel test is not a yardstick for feminism and/or artistic worthiness. It’s not a test you were ever meant to apply to any single work. It’s a thought experiment intended to illustrate how the entertainment industry as a whole discounts the interiority, desires, and relationships of women except as they relate to men. But again and again you’ll see people - and perhaps especially people who define themselves as feminists - who treat it as the one and only meaningful measure of a work’s value. In reality, there are feminist works that don’t pass the Bechdel test, and works that pass the Bechdel test that are not feminist, and works with tremendous political value that do not foreground feminism because they’re about something else.
And if the Bechdel test is a relatively old example, this is a phenomenon that keeps cropping up. “Some artifacts in museums were stolen or looted, with colonialism and racism providing a cover for acts that in other circumstances we’d easily recognize as criminal” has become “all museums are piles of loot and stealing from them is righteous even it it’s to melt the artwork down and funnel the profits to organized crime.” “Zoos sometimes abuse their animals and the goal should be to reintroduce specimens to the wild” has become “open all the cages and let the animals out (to spaces where they will almost certainly die/be killed to stop them killing people)”. “Ethnic foods are sometimes treated as more palatable, and sold for more money, when they’re marketed by white people” has become “people should only prepare and eat food from their own ethnicity”. Again and again, it feels like these ideas that were meant to make us think, to pause a moment and notice the unspoken assumptions and elisions that exist in our world, have been turned into catchphrases that shut down thought. I think the reason that happens is that people enjoy the feeling of righteousness that comes from calling out institutions like museums or the film industry, but along the way you can become just as dogmatic and tunnel-visioned as the bodies you were calling out.
