Helle's Reviews > On Beauty

On Beauty by Zadie Smith
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
6909470
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: english, 1001-books, favourites

Sassy, smart and street-wise is what this novel is; what Zadie Smith is. With a literary nod to a favourite novel of mine, Howards End - which is anything but sassy and street-wise - this is a novel that only Zadie Smith could pull off. As in White Teeth and NW, it is teeming with snappy conversations, larger-than-life characters, literary references and unlikely plot developments (partly grâce à Forster); in short On Beauty is full of life and soul.

The prose crackles and sparkles, and once again we witness Zadie Smith’s trademark ear for different dialects and sociolects, rap and literature. And while many of her sentences are eloquent and the topics serious, they are also full of mirth. It is perhaps what I appreciate the most: her wit. Because it is invariably coupled with heart and smarts.

Here Howard, middle-aged intellectual Brit transplanted to the United States courtesy of his voluptuous, African-American, non-intellectual (and utterly wonderful) wife, Kiki, is having a conversation with a curator at the college where he teaches (who speaks the first line):

’Ag’inst Rembrandt’, the second man said. He had a high-pitched Southern voice that struck Howard as a comic assault for which he had been completely unprepared. ‘That was the title your assistant mailed us – I’m just tryna figger what you meant by ‘ag’inst’ – obviously my organization are part-sponsors of this whole event, so –‘

‘Your organization –‘

‘The RAS – Rembrandt Appreciate – and I’m sure I’m not an innellekchewl, at least, as a fella like you might think of one…’

‘Yes, I’m sure you’re not,’ murmured Howard. He found that his accent caused a delayed reaction in certain Americans. It was sometimes the next day before they realized how rude he had been to them.


Forster dealt in social classes: the cultured intellectual Schlegells, the moneyed business people - the Wilcoxes, the working class man - Leonard Bast, who were all trying to bridge the gap between their classes; between literature and life – to ‘only connect’. In On Beauty Zadie Smith takes us to a college town in New England, and so her groups are Americans, Brits, whites, African-Americans, intellectuals and non-intellectuals, students and rappers, teenagers and their parents – all trying to find their place in the world, to connect or, as in Howard’s case, work through a mid-life crisis. And as in White Teeth, she has created characters that jump off the page and really exist. But On Beauty shines much brighter than WT and NW, in my opinion.

The novel was further from Howards End than I had expected but turned out to be a fantastic book in its own right, allusion to favourite novel or not. When I read her acknowledgements at the end, I nearly broke down (in gratitude? wonder? renewed and double appreciation of Forster and Zadie Smith?) This is what she writes:

It should be obvious from the first line that this is a novel inspired by a love of E. M. Forster, to whom all my fiction is indebted, one way or the other. This time I wanted to repay the debt with hommage.
35 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read On Beauty.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 11, 2015 – Shelved
February 13, 2016 – Started Reading
February 18, 2016 –
page 325
73.36%
February 20, 2016 – Finished Reading
June 24, 2021 – Shelved (Other Paperback Edition)

Comments Showing 1-24 of 24 (24 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ilse (new) - added it

Ilse Ah, what a pleasure to read! This sounds so wonderful, Helle. My reading group was considering it, but the moderator put it off because she didn't like it. Reading your enticing review, this definitely has to get a go - I took it with me on a few holidays, but never started it.


message 2: by Karen· (new)

Karen· Now you trouble me, because I read White Teeth and thought it overblown, overpraised and overlong. Kind of decided that I didn't need to follow it up. Now you persuade me I was wrong....


message 3: by Dolors (last edited Mar 13, 2016 12:00PM) (new)

Dolors Oh Helle, you have killed two birds with one stone with this magnificent review because you have not only managed to notch up Zadie Smith on my list of pending authors, but also rekindled my thirst to re-read Howards End.
I utterly adored the passion that oozes from your double homage to Forster and to Z.Smith and the way you infuse life into the collage of characters in the contemporary story through comparison to the classic. Your voice was far too loud and clear for me to ignore it, so I just added this novel straight to my virtual cart (view spoiler)


Helle Ilse wrote: "Ah, what a pleasure to read! This sounds so wonderful, Helle. My reading group was considering it, but the moderator put it off because she didn't like it. Reading your enticing review, this defini..."

She did what? Oh, she sounds like a domineering moderator (a bit like the one in my group, come to think of it). Zadie Smith isn't for everyone (sic!) but she has so much pizzaz and is really a unique voice in English literature. So if you want to try her out, this is the novel, I think. Thanks, Ilse, as always, for reading and leaving such thoughtful comments!


Helle ·Karen· wrote: "Now you trouble me, because I read White Teeth and thought it overblown, overpraised and overlong. Kind of decided that I didn't need to follow it up. Now you persuade me I was wrong...."

Oho, Karen, glad to be able to trouble you, but rest assured (I say, trembling a bit) that this is better than WT, which also annoyed me a bit for the exact same reasons. James Wood called WT 'hysterical realism', which seemed apt, and while this one does perhaps have a bit too much rap/street lingo at times, the characters are better wrought, and there are simply more 'good moments' here. I would give ZS one more chance...


Helle Dolors wrote: "Oh Helle, you have killed two birds with one stone with this magnificent review because you have not only managed to notch up Zadie Smith on my list of pending authors, but also rekindled my thirst..."

Hurrah, Dolors. So pleased to have shone the spotlight on these two very different, yet somehow connected authors to invite a visit and a re-visit from you. I'm certain you will all benefit from those visits! I love your comment, as per usual, and wholeheartedly approve of your decision to thrown caution to the wind and fill up that cart with life and soul - in short with new wonderful books!


message 7: by Fionnuala (last edited Mar 14, 2016 12:43AM) (new)

Fionnuala Love your enthusiasm for this book, Helle. I had heard it was a homage to Howards End - and knowing the usual mixed milieu Smith writes about from WT and NW, I was curious how she'd carried it off. You've convinced me she succeeded very well.
Going by that quote though, it sounds as if she's hard on Americans - or at least Howard is...


message 8: by Agnieszka (new) - added it

Agnieszka Wonderful review , Helle ! Your enthusiasm just emanates from every passage ! I ‘ve read only White teeth and her essays and was delighted . Zadie was there smart and sassy , pleasure to read . And Forster's Howards End is one of my favourite novels so it’s almost sure that this one would be something right up my street .


Helle Fionnuala wrote: "Love your enthusiasm for this book, Helle. I had heard it was a homage to Howards End - and knowing the usual mixed milieu Smith writes about from WT and NW, I was curious how she'd carried it off...."

Thanks a bunch, Fionnuala. Yes, ZS did indeed succeed with this novel, but I don't think she's harder on Americans in this novel than on Englishmen, perhaps even the reverse. Kiki was by far my favourite character, and she was American. Howard, on the other hand, is a tweedy English twit; his annoyance with certain people only made him look that more pathetic. I do think it's interesting, though, that ZS herself feels her other works are also indebted to Forster. I certainly didn't notice it in WT or NW...


Helle Agnieszka wrote: "Wonderful review , Helle ! Your enthusiasm just emanates from every passage ! I ‘ve read only White teeth and her essays and was delighted . Zadie was there smart and sassy , pleasure to read . A..."

So happy to hear that you, too, love Howards End, Agnieszka! I've got Zadie Smith's essays on my tbr-list, so I'm pleased to hear that you liked those as well, and yes, that strange mix of Forster's Edwardian, classic outlook and ZS's hypermodernist one should be right down your alley. ZS has got a new novel coming out later this year, by the way. Swing Time, I believe it's called. First novel in years. Thanks so much for your comment, Agnieszka!


message 11: by Fionnuala (last edited Mar 15, 2016 05:56AM) (new)

Fionnuala Helle wrote: "Thanks a bunch, Fionnuala. Yes, ZS did indeed succeed with this novel, but I don't think she's harder on Americans in this novel than on Englishmen, perhaps even the reverse. Kiki was by far my favourite character, and she was American. Howard, on the other hand, is a tweedy English twit; his annoyance with certain people only made him look that more pathetic. I do think it's interesting, though, that ZS herself feels her other works are also indebted to Forster. I certainly didn't notice it in WT or NW.."

Glad to hear all that, Helle, as I had felt we were very much in the point of view of Howard in that quote, and I didn't find even a trace of author irony there. Now that I read the quote a second time, I can see she is perhaps subtly sending up Howard too.
About the Forster influence in her other work, it must be pretty subtle too because I didn't pick it up either. It's true I read White Teeth ages ago and before I became interested in Forster but I read NW much more recently and missed his influence completely.


message 12: by Seemita (new)

Seemita Oh yes, Madame! Zany, sassy, stylish and succulent - that's what this review was for me after a looooong day's work! For someone who is yet to read Smith, this is a fabulous induction course; a snippet I am going to remember! But do you suppose I could pick White Teeth to start her? Cuz that's what is gathering dust on my shelf! ;)


Helle Fionnuala wrote: "Helle wrote: "Thanks a bunch, Fionnuala. Yes, ZS did indeed succeed with this novel, but I don't think she's harder on Americans in this novel than on Englishmen, perhaps even the reverse. Kiki was..."

Ah, glad to hear it's not my inability to see intertextual references where they're intended, Fionnuala; or at least, we're two who can't quite see them. I've re-read three of Forster's works in the last few years while also reading WT and NW, and it never struck me there were links. As to Howard and author irony, I think it's because ZS alternately dips inside each character's head, and so the irony shifts depending on who we're with. I have to say, I think it's slightly wonderful that someone so hyper-modern as ZS loves Forster. I feel it's very much the 'old aunt' part of me that loves him and certainly not my more modern side (if such a one exists)...


Helle Seemita wrote: "Oh yes, Madame! Zany, sassy, stylish and succulent - that's what this review was for me after a looooong day's work! For someone who is yet to read Smith, this is a fabulous induction course; a sni..."

Well, thankee, Madame Seemita. Hope the work isn't dragging you down but will leave room in your brain to dip into a bit of literature soon; sounds like you deserve it! Since you've got White Teeth waiting for you on your shelf, I guess you should begin with that, but while it's certainly also sassy and zany, it doesn't have the stylishness and the heart of On Beauty, if you ask me. I recall reading an interview with ZS in which she said that NW was her attempt to write an adult novel (after On Beauty, which she called a 'comic fantasy'). She was, after all, only 23 when she wrote WT, and there's something of the all-powerful, aggressively smart youth about it. But hey, you may love WT. It's a great, big sprawling book, and many people loved it whereas I admired the talent behind it.


message 15: by Seemita (new)

Seemita Helle wrote: "Well, thankee, Madame Seemita. Hope the work isn't dragging you down but will leave room in your brain to dip into a bit of literature soon; sounds like you deserve it! Since you've got."

Thanks for that tip. I would keep it in mind. But it might still be sometime before she moves into my read shelf. *sigh*


message 16: by Kalliope (new)

Kalliope I was exploring Zadie Smith's books and came up to this wonderful review.. May be this should be my first by her, but since I read Howard's End long ago, may be I should revisit this first and then proceed to Smith.


Helle Kalliope wrote: "I was exploring Zadie Smith's books and came up to this wonderful review.. May be this should be my first by her, but since I read Howard's End long ago, may be I should revisit this first and then..."

Ah, you beat me to it, Kalliope, because (apropos the other ZS thread) I was going to recommend that you begin with this novel. As to Howards End, well, we know how rewarding and satisfying it can be to recognize allusions and intertextual references in a novel, but somehow there aren't that many in On Beauty, only in terms of the overall structure and theme, not in the more minute details. On the other hand, I re-read Howards End a couple of years ago and just loved it still, so I would never discourage someone to go for a re-read of it. But - to get to the point - it's not necessary in order to appreciate this novel. They're so different from each other. I'll certainly be looking forward to your reaction if/when you get you to it!


message 18: by Ioana (new)

Ioana Wonderful review! I keep hearing about Zadie Smith (especially White Teeth) but wasn't yet convinced I should add her to my lists... until now. Definitely always in the mood for something witty, but also full of heart.


Helle Ioana wrote: "Wonderful review! I keep hearing about Zadie Smith (especially White Teeth) but wasn't yet convinced I should add her to my lists... until now. Definitely always in the mood for something witty, bu..."

Thanks a bunch, Iona. Well, it's always a question of taste of course, but I much preferred On Beauty to White Teeth. According to Smith herself, WT is a work from/of her youth; she was all of 23 when it was published, and I got the feeling that she was precisely that, one cocky youth but with lots of talent that she reigned in more in On Beauty. I'll look out for your take on either one!


message 20: by Ioana (new)

Ioana Helle wrote: "I much preferred On Beauty to White Teeth. According to Smith herself, WT is a work from/of her youth..." Ah, thank you for the clarification; and, I did not know she was only 23 when WT was published, wow! It sounds like I will be starting with On Beauty... and with some E. M. Forster. Thank you for the recommendations!


Helle Ioana wrote: "Helle wrote: "I much preferred On Beauty to White Teeth. According to Smith herself, WT is a work from/of her youth..." Ah, thank you for the clarification; and, I did not know she was only 23 when..."

My pleasure, Iona, Glad to hear you'll bring Forster on board too. Looking forward to seeing what you make of them both.


Katie Fabulous review, Helle.


Helle Katie wrote: "Fabulous review, Helle."

Thanks so much, Katie! We are in agreement about Zadie here :-)


message 24: by Will (new) - rated it 5 stars

Will Ansbacher Great Review Helle. It's one of my favourites, along with NW


back to top