Kat Kennedy's Reviews > Storm Front
Storm Front (The Dresden Files, #1)
by
by
The Dresden Files is one of those books that's intimidating to approach. It has a hard-core fan group that will scream its praises from the top of the roof. Usually, I would approach with extreme caution. I rarely read a series when I've been assured that it gets good after six books. When people tell me that, I simply quietly encourage them to read the Fever Series and avert eye contact.
However, after a discussion regarding male readers and writers of the Urban Fantasy genre, I felt I should give this series a go since the UF male demographic tends to be on the small side.
The Dresden Files has an immersive, interesting world. It's magical lore is possibly the only original thing about it. Which doesn't say that much for the book.

It's exactly the same half-assed compliment you'd give to Meyers...
Don't get me wrong. Harry is a solid, interesting character and the mystery and action in this book was great. There were plenty of tense moments, laugh-out-loud moments, and clever, witty escapes.
But that doesn't mean that anything in this book was actually original.
Paranormal private eye? If there ever was a cliche in this genre - there it is. Can't they ever have a different occupation? If you have some magical ability is this your only career choice? Honestly. I think Anita Blake, Rachel Morgan and Harry Dresden would make GREAT pizza deliverers!

Guaranteed they'd still manage to get in a shitload of trouble though...
What's the draw to being private detectives or retainers for police investigations? They're always struggling with money, almost getting killed to solve cases that don't pay, for people who don't like them and never really trust them. Insurance salesmen, guys. If people are going to treat you like dirt, you might as well be fucking them over equally as bad!
Besides, most of the characters in this book could have come out of ANY mystery novel about a rogue private eye solving mysteries and helping the police.
You have:
1) The toughass female cop with a heart of gold.
2) The asshole cop who gets in the way and hates the protagonist for no reason.
3) The surly bartender who knows everything and likes the protagonist. Usually more than he likes most people.
4) The sexy reporter who flirts with the male protagonist in order to get leads for a story.
5) The male protagonist who is awkward with the ladies, self-proclaimed non-lothario but still has at least one woman through themselves at him.
I appreciate characterization that encompasses flaws. Sometimes though, being too nice is a character flaw I get sick of in books. That's like going to a job interview and listing workaholic as a personality flaw.
Listen, Dresden. If someone explicably involves you in a murder case, doesn't give you enough information, doesn't inform you that they're an accomplice to the crimes, knows that your involvement will surely mean your death, and then tells you to go away and die somewhere else because they don't want your heart to burst out of your chest and stain their lovely carpet - YOU'RE OFFICIALLY ALLOWED TO BE A DICK TO THEM.
You know what you're not allowed to do? Feel like an asshole for getting information out of them that will save your life. That is NOT an asshole thing to do!
And maybe you don't have to put your ass on the line to spare every single other person when you're likely to die as a result.

For goodness sake, let the immortal wizard and the warrior ranger take the fucking ring to mordor!
Just sayin' is all...
Over all, I liked this book. I will read more of these books - but I AM still waiting for the magic to hit me and turn me into a crazed Dresden fangirl.
[image error]
Yep, can't wait for the day...
However, after a discussion regarding male readers and writers of the Urban Fantasy genre, I felt I should give this series a go since the UF male demographic tends to be on the small side.
The Dresden Files has an immersive, interesting world. It's magical lore is possibly the only original thing about it. Which doesn't say that much for the book.

It's exactly the same half-assed compliment you'd give to Meyers...
Don't get me wrong. Harry is a solid, interesting character and the mystery and action in this book was great. There were plenty of tense moments, laugh-out-loud moments, and clever, witty escapes.
But that doesn't mean that anything in this book was actually original.
Paranormal private eye? If there ever was a cliche in this genre - there it is. Can't they ever have a different occupation? If you have some magical ability is this your only career choice? Honestly. I think Anita Blake, Rachel Morgan and Harry Dresden would make GREAT pizza deliverers!

Guaranteed they'd still manage to get in a shitload of trouble though...
What's the draw to being private detectives or retainers for police investigations? They're always struggling with money, almost getting killed to solve cases that don't pay, for people who don't like them and never really trust them. Insurance salesmen, guys. If people are going to treat you like dirt, you might as well be fucking them over equally as bad!
Besides, most of the characters in this book could have come out of ANY mystery novel about a rogue private eye solving mysteries and helping the police.
You have:
1) The toughass female cop with a heart of gold.
2) The asshole cop who gets in the way and hates the protagonist for no reason.
3) The surly bartender who knows everything and likes the protagonist. Usually more than he likes most people.
4) The sexy reporter who flirts with the male protagonist in order to get leads for a story.
5) The male protagonist who is awkward with the ladies, self-proclaimed non-lothario but still has at least one woman through themselves at him.
I appreciate characterization that encompasses flaws. Sometimes though, being too nice is a character flaw I get sick of in books. That's like going to a job interview and listing workaholic as a personality flaw.
Listen, Dresden. If someone explicably involves you in a murder case, doesn't give you enough information, doesn't inform you that they're an accomplice to the crimes, knows that your involvement will surely mean your death, and then tells you to go away and die somewhere else because they don't want your heart to burst out of your chest and stain their lovely carpet - YOU'RE OFFICIALLY ALLOWED TO BE A DICK TO THEM.
You know what you're not allowed to do? Feel like an asshole for getting information out of them that will save your life. That is NOT an asshole thing to do!
And maybe you don't have to put your ass on the line to spare every single other person when you're likely to die as a result.

For goodness sake, let the immortal wizard and the warrior ranger take the fucking ring to mordor!
Just sayin' is all...
Over all, I liked this book. I will read more of these books - but I AM still waiting for the magic to hit me and turn me into a crazed Dresden fangirl.
[image error]
Yep, can't wait for the day...
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Storm Front.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
February 12, 2011
–
Started Reading
February 12, 2011
– Shelved
February 13, 2011
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-39 of 39 (39 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Tatiana
(new)
Feb 13, 2011 05:42AM
Goodness, you are quick!
reply
|
flag
Tatiana - that's NOT what she said!Elizabeth - I did. What made you keep reading, out of interest, since you only gave it 1 star?
Alas, there's no real sexing in this book, Tatiana.Question to those who have read more of this series - WILL there be sexing at any point? I'm kind of thinking I have issues since this is a very important question to me!
Elizabeth - ah! I see. How is the TV series? I hear the audiobook is done by James Marsters so I'm thinking of getting the rest of the books that way.
Kat, you'll have trouble finding any sex throughout the rest of the series. There are a couple of scenes, here and there, but they mostly serve a specific purpose and are described just enough to get what's going on. Nothing like, say, the Fever series.Try to get the audiobooks. Marsters really makes Harry shine. The only reason I made it through the second—which IMO is the worst of the series—and third books was that I had them on audio.
Oh, and don't worry about coming down hard on these books. First, your reviews are funnier when you do. Second, even the hardcore fans recognize that the series started pretty weak.
Kat wrote: "Alas, there's no real sexing in this book, Tatiana.Question to those who have read more of this series - WILL there be sexing at any point? I'm kind of thinking I have issues since this is a ver..."
When I asked that sex question before, I was told there would be some in book 2. There will be some crying involved as well. On Harry's part. Let me know if it's true...
Tatiana - I will, but only if James Marsters cries! I expect him to cry, damnit!Chichipio - damn, that sucks about the sex thing! Oh well! I'm glad I don't have to worry about backlash. I felt bad that I wasn't that into this book, but I'm glad you're understanding about it!
James Marsters did the audio??? ::swoons::
I read this also because of the tv show, which I enjoyed. I didn't really enjoy this, but I didn't hate it either. The show wasn't the best tv show ever, but it was watchable fun. And it toned down a lot of the almost off-handed sexism of the books. I'm not a big series reader, though. No staying power.
I read this also because of the tv show, which I enjoyed. I didn't really enjoy this, but I didn't hate it either. The show wasn't the best tv show ever, but it was watchable fun. And it toned down a lot of the almost off-handed sexism of the books. I'm not a big series reader, though. No staying power.
does he do it in his american accent? my girlfriend thinks james marsters should only be allowed to speak with his spike accent.
I agree with the 3-star rating on this book. It's indeed the weakest book in the entire series, but it does get better after about the first 2 to 3 books. I hope you're able to stick it out and continue to read. I've finished all the Dresden books so far and can't wait for the next one to come out in a couple of month's time!! :)
However, after a discussion regarding male readers and writers of the Urban Fantasy genre, I felt I should give this series a go since the UF male demographic tends to be on the small side.You're telling me? I think I may be the only male UF reader on Goodreads. :(
Oh, and the first two Dresden books were really slow, but after Grave Peril they stepped up dramatically.
Not true, Jay, if it makes you feel better!Both my father AND my husband like UF (and PNR though they think I haven't caught them reading it every now and again!)
Take heart, you're not alone!
I guess it just feels like it sometimes. The only testosterone powered ship sailing in a sea of estrogen. hahaOne thing that I can take comfort in regarding the Dresden Files. No matter how powerful Anita Blake gets, Harry would always be able to kick her skanky ass.
In fact, the only fictional character that I know of who could get the drop on Dresden is John Constantine. Because, well, John's just mean and rotten down to his black, shriveled heart.
Certainly though it must give you a leg up.One of my friends is reading the Fever series. Of which, Barrons is the big stud.
Her husband, thinking he'd be sneaky and do something naughty, decided to dress up as a character from the series. Only, he hadn't read the series. Just saw from a quick search that it was about Fae and thought she must be lusting after Fae.
Dressed up as a fae and insisted he'd read the book to "connect" with her. He was so busted!
Kat wrote: "Yes, yes he is! I'm not sure Keanu Reeves really portrayed that as well as it should have been!"Nah, he didn't. He missed it by a mile. Speaking of Marsters, mentioned earlier, I always thought he was the perfect person to play Constantine. He does well portraying vicious bastards.
Kat wrote: "Her husband, thinking he'd be sneaky and do something naughty, decided to dress up as a character from the series. Only, he hadn't read the series. Just saw from a quick search that it was about Fae and thought she must be lusting after Fae."Ouch. I guess he missed the whole part where Mac is raped by them and her mind is turned to goo. That's embarrassing.
Oh shit, I'm actually pretty jealous of you! You get to read Dead Beat for the first time. Damn, now that may be the best UF book ever written.
FAN-FUCKING-TASTIC, review, Kat! Finally! A friend who wasn't completely & utterly obsessed with HD from the first book on! Harry DOES make a bunch of dumbass moves & hated that he constantly felt bad for wanting to keep his ass from dying. Why is he always apologizing to Murphy? Why is always letting her treat him like shit? *sigh* Thank you. And my pizza man will totally kick your pizza man's ass!
Someone recommended the Dresden files and I decided to check the reviews. Yours is too funny and it definitely made me not want to read the book because I don't think it will be as good as your review.
I am now a fan of your reviews. I had read a couple of yours before but hadn't read the book. I love your funny pictures. It is making me want to go to that site where you got happy bug and cool pizza guy.I am a total sucker for sarcastic narrators, (is there any other kind?) and I DID love Harry's skull assistant. I've read better... but I liked well enough to watch the show and keep my eye out for the books.
I was going to write a review, but you've pretty much written it for me ;) I'll probably still have my say, though you've covered how I felt well.
I loved the Fever series. I feel like I'm trying too hard to find a substitution for that series. If you have any suggestions for series that come close to that....let me know.
Yea. I have to say I agree. I like it for all of its small differing details from the other books of its type -- the lore mostly. Like you I was unimpressed with the parts that were very much a part of the over done characterizations and scenes.
Bahaha, I enjoyed the book but I loved this review. The only characters you left out were the bombshell call girls - in every way the entire cast could have stepped right out of a Marlowe or Bosch pulp. Dresden in particular is heavily patterned after Marlowe, wisecracking and full of himself. I love genre fiction, but this one is really leaning on its roots to drive the story.I did think that the disconnect between his macho self-centered internal monologue and the neurotic idiot too certain of his own righteousness to see how he's going to hurt others while feeling guilty over interrogating women (but not a man!) is pretty well handled. He's flawed and rather chauvinistic, but as this is a first-person tale, the rationalizations everyone tells themselves sound right, with the truth occasionally admitted.
Looking forward to more, especially if it gets deeper as time goes on. (Really, really hoping so.)
I agree with review at all points except one: I know that others books in serie I will not read so I never be a hardcore fan :-).
I love the series, but this is one of the weaker books. The characters are very cliche, but I personally like them. The characters definitely deepen by orders of magnitude as the series progresses, but you have seen them before. Read these books for the interactions and the world. The world is by far the strongest point, and the plot is fun, with villains being introduced, and dresden's arsenal increasing as time goes by. My favorite part of this book would probably be the naked demon chase in the rain. If Jim Butcher can do one thing right, it's an action scene.
I am nearly finished with this book. I actually put it aside for a long time. Thinking I had wasted money buying it. But after some time away I have been flying through it. I really enjoyed reading your review though :)
To open, I realise that this comment is in reference to a review posted quite a few years ago now. Firstly I'd like to state my opinion and say that I did enjoy the books but would not classify myself a "hard-core fan," yet still found myself at odds at with your review. You start off by saying that the book offered an interesting and immersive world/plot and character background (something even you couldn't deny) but then go on to criticise the originality of the story, which in the end seems to be your only argument against it. These points in themselves seem to contradictory because surely something so unoriginal would not prove so enveloping. I personally find the origins of this plot scaffold irrelevant because from this Jim has created a world and subsequently a storyline unique only to his books, with a fair share of dry humour and bloodshed for gore-lovers (a specific writing taste that fans have come to recognise as distinctly Jim) . In my opinion his book is "spot on", as it was obviously aimed to reach out to a wide range of audience and demographic types. I also quite liked his explanation and reasoning on the subject of magic (thermodynamics etc.), which seems to have been lost on you as you seem to think it comparable to vampires playing baseball. While I no doubt could go on and provide further counter-arguments and arguments proving the books ingenuity, I am quickly growing bored of explaining the higher complexities of a book whose workings have sadly but surely flown straight over your head. Now I must admit I barely skimmed over your review after I realised that the critic in question obviously hadn't cared enough about the article to proof read. Misspelling "throw" (a five letter word) is quite an achievement. May I suggest next time, sounding it out? My suspicions about you being a below average writer yourself, were later confirmed when in one of your comment replies you used the word "sexing"...Anyway, cheers for reading. Thats my dose of sass for the day.
Love the review! This is exactly how I feel about this book. It was enjoyable enough and I'll probably read at least a couple more but I'm not in love with Harry. He seems kind "meh". For a better book in this genre try The Iron Druid Chronicles. Love me some Atticus. Sadly not much sexing in this series either. But Oberon, the badass talking dog, has it all over Mr., the somewhat lame large cat. I've heard these books start getting better so I will persist but kinda not super jazzed about having to read 3 ok books to get to the good stuff.
The plots can be Summerized[pun intended] as one God damned thing after another. Very entertaining so far, I think the late Spencer author, Robert Parker, is the hard boiled style Butcher is trying for. I wonder if he has read John D. Macdonald?
Anita Blake does not fit the little list of cliche characterization list put together in this review.......just my humble opinion.
For anyone on the Dresden Files fence, do the audiobook! James Marsters brings Harry to life (pun intended!).



