Emily May's Reviews > A Monster Calls
A Monster Calls
by
I got back to my apartment in Bulgaria and thought I'd read a little bit of this novel before I went to bed. 2 hours later I was still sat in my original position but by this time I was sobbing my heart out. Literally sat there crying like a baby to myself. I doubt this book will be everyone's cup of tea but, whatever it has, it really worked it's magic on me.
I thought A Monster Calls was pretty much amazing in every way; from it's darkly beautiful illustrations (worth buying a paper copy for) to the great big touching metaphor that is the backbone of the story.
Didn't like The Knife of Never Letting Go? Not a problem. Forget it's by the same author whether you liked his previous books or not. Pretend you've never heard of Patrick Ness before because this is nothing like anything he has ever written. It's nothing like anything I've ever read. Where the Chaos Walking trilogy was a fast-paced adventure story, this is a very moving, well-written tale of a boy who's mum has cancer. It's about loss, and that doesn't necessarily mean death, and it's also about learning to let go and forgive yourself and others around you.
Think you've got it? Think you've worked out that the 'monster' is going to be cancer itself? Think again.
Like I said, this is a very different sort of idea (credit to the late Siobhan Dowd) and not the kind of book where you can guess where it's going. It's odd and unpredictable and very sad. Conor is one of those tragic but believable characters that you feel for all the way through. He faces constant battles in every aspect of his life. There's the obvious problem of his mother's illness, but also the fact that his dad has moved to America to start a new life with his new wife and baby. School offers no escape from Conor's miserable reality either as he finds himself between bullies who pick on him because they can and teachers who make their pity obvious every time they talk to him.
Then one night a monster visits Conor. A dream? An ancient creature that appears to those in need? Anything is possible, none of which is important. This monster is here for one purpose... to tell Conor three stories in exchange for the truth. Conor begins to learn that things aren't always as they seem and right and wrong are not so easily defined.
I loved it. It was nothing that I expected but I hope Siobhan Dowd's idea will inspire Patrick Ness to write more like this.
by
I got back to my apartment in Bulgaria and thought I'd read a little bit of this novel before I went to bed. 2 hours later I was still sat in my original position but by this time I was sobbing my heart out. Literally sat there crying like a baby to myself. I doubt this book will be everyone's cup of tea but, whatever it has, it really worked it's magic on me.
I thought A Monster Calls was pretty much amazing in every way; from it's darkly beautiful illustrations (worth buying a paper copy for) to the great big touching metaphor that is the backbone of the story.
Didn't like The Knife of Never Letting Go? Not a problem. Forget it's by the same author whether you liked his previous books or not. Pretend you've never heard of Patrick Ness before because this is nothing like anything he has ever written. It's nothing like anything I've ever read. Where the Chaos Walking trilogy was a fast-paced adventure story, this is a very moving, well-written tale of a boy who's mum has cancer. It's about loss, and that doesn't necessarily mean death, and it's also about learning to let go and forgive yourself and others around you.
Think you've got it? Think you've worked out that the 'monster' is going to be cancer itself? Think again.
Like I said, this is a very different sort of idea (credit to the late Siobhan Dowd) and not the kind of book where you can guess where it's going. It's odd and unpredictable and very sad. Conor is one of those tragic but believable characters that you feel for all the way through. He faces constant battles in every aspect of his life. There's the obvious problem of his mother's illness, but also the fact that his dad has moved to America to start a new life with his new wife and baby. School offers no escape from Conor's miserable reality either as he finds himself between bullies who pick on him because they can and teachers who make their pity obvious every time they talk to him.
Then one night a monster visits Conor. A dream? An ancient creature that appears to those in need? Anything is possible, none of which is important. This monster is here for one purpose... to tell Conor three stories in exchange for the truth. Conor begins to learn that things aren't always as they seem and right and wrong are not so easily defined.
I loved it. It was nothing that I expected but I hope Siobhan Dowd's idea will inspire Patrick Ness to write more like this.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
A Monster Calls.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
May 22, 2011
– Shelved
July 21, 2011
–
Started Reading
July 31, 2011
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-44 of 44 (44 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
K.D.
(new)
-
added it
Aug 01, 2011 05:33PM
I liked the Knife of Letting Go. I gave it a 4-star rating. I have no plan yet of reading the other two books but this review of yours just convinced me to read more books by him. Thanks!
reply
|
flag
Personally, I really liked the Knife of Never Letting Go and the others in the series but I know a lot of people who didn't enjoy it. This though, just wow... really hope you like it!!
Great review. I agree, this is a beautiful book, and not just because of the amazing, haunting illustrations. I, too, spent a while sobbing like a baby. I was glad to be home alone so I couldn't freak out my partner.
Thank you :) I'm just glad I chose to read it at night, not while sunbathing at the beach or something, hehe.
I have to be in exactly the right mood to read a book like this. Nonetheless, excellent review, i'll add it to my list awaiting just such a mood.
This has been on my TBR list for a while now... might have to move it up a couple of places. Great review, Emily!
I loved this, too, Emily. I was in the same position--read it before bedtime and was sobbing at 3:30 in the morning. :(
Why is this a young adult book? It's a book for all ages? And if anything, it's a childrensbook if any. But it's not even that. Like I said, age has nothing to do with this book :)
I have a copy... it's been sitting quietly on my kindle. I have had intentions, really i have of picking it up. I have heard that it has brought many adults to tears..... ugh a children's book (and i know the age argument abound) but my gosh, if a children book can bring adult women and men to tears, well im a bit resistant. fantastic review! and thanks for keeping us all up on everything patrick ness.... im also going to get a copy of the knife never letting go...
I was so happy to see this review! I flipped through this today at work - it seems it won a bunch of awards so now we have it in stock, and was blown away by the art and idea. You instantly came to mind, I wondered if you had read it (I would have sent you a recommendation if not ha) and if so, what you thought. Your 5 stars convinced me, I'm picking this up tomorrow! Wonderful review!
hmm I started to read it and didn't get far. I had no idea what if anything the book was about. I am going to go back and try again.
I hope it works out for you the second time around, Elizabeth, but you're definitely not alone. Despite the overwhelming number of positive reviews, I know several people who felt the same way.
I just noticed in the paper today that they are going to turn this into a feature film with Liam Neeson as the voice of the yew tree. I hope they can do the book justice.
Wow, thanks for letting me know! That has the potential to be really good so I hope they get it right.
You're most welcome Emily. A good friend of mine, who is now on the national board of Cancercare and a cancer survivor himself, has already signed up to go with me when it comes out. I loaned the book to him after I finished it and he was so impressed he wanted to reread it after he finished. I bought another copy for myself 8)My only concern comes from a passage I just recently read in "Coptown" by Karin Slaughter:
"She didn't trust herself to speak. This was the problem with letting yourself cry: once you gave in, you lost your ability to fight it back the next time".
This book broke me open completely, twice. It was one of the few times I was glad not to be reading at my Tavern. If they do this movie correctly I don't know that I'll be able to reign in that emotion in a public setting.
I hope they do it right regardless.
I expect a lot of wet faces afterwards.
I'm bringing Kleenex anyways. 8)
Great review.......I loved the book also.......I couldn't put it down....next thing I knew, it's 2:45 A.M......I have never read a book like this but it definitely inspired me......it's now one of my faves......keep up with the good reviews...... :)
I just finished this one and wept like a wee baby. Such a beautifully written, haunting tale of grief.
I also really love this book for every aspect just like you! Conor was alone and did not have any escape from the dark situation. His mom's illness, friendship, his father's new life, his grandmother.. These made Conor suffer a lot. But at the last part of this story, Conor could be truthful for himself that he wanted the situation that his mom is sick and will gonna die to be over. That truth was really hard for Conor to tell to monster because it meant that he wanted his mom to go away. However, through Conor finding and telling his truth in the deep heart, I believe that he could be real Conor. As you, I felt really sad:( while I read this book. I am a highschool student but I had a lot of things to think about through reading it. I believe this book is really awesome for every age and everyone in this world^^
Wow, I think I just thought about only myself while I read this book! But I see you felt so sad about Conor's situation. And I also loved it too :) You know, I thought maybe other people might have their monsters inside their mind after reading this book. I hope that other people would find their monsters and solve their problems. I like your reviews about the three stories. I also learned through the stories that things aren't always as they seem right or wrong. I think other friends of mine would like this book too!
Yes, I like the illustrations, too. I think the illustrations are showing the mood of this book well.Also I agree with your thoughts, especially on this sentence, 'Conor begins to learn that things aren't always as they seem and right and wrong are not so easily defined.' While reading this book, I thought Conor is hoping an impossible thing and he had a kind of 'good boy complex'. Things happened differently from his expectaiton and at last he realizes that his expectations were not his real thought. This book taught me that the thought is not an unright thing. Just like you, I think this book is amazing.
Your reviews are very insightful and passionate, yet very much full of spoilers. I'd leave a little less plot out of your reviews. Just a piece of advice. Take from it what you will.Definitely a great book. Dark at times, and inspirational at others. I loved it.
Just saw a preview for the movie, which is being released January 6th (in North America at least).A pleasure to come back and re-read your review, Emily. Hope you get a chance to see the movie.
Thank you so much for this review - wow what a book! Just finished, and it has me sobbing too. Thank you 💕
Just finished reading it and almost and I repeat almost got it together again. Beautifully written loved it from beginning to end.













