Glenn Russell's Reviews > Austerlitz
Austerlitz
by

“No one can explain exactly what happens within us when the doors behind which our childhood terrors lurk are flung open.”
― W.G. Sebald, Austerlitz
Turning the pages of the novel Austerlitz makes for one powerful, emotionally wrenching experience. Here's what esteemed critic Michiko Kakutani wrote as part of her New York Times review: "We are transported to a memoryscape - a twilight, fogbound world of half-remembered images and ghosts that is reminiscent at once of Ingmar Bergman's Wild Strawberries, Kafka's troubling fables of guilt and apprehension and, of course, Proust's Remembrance of Things Past.''
With his lyrical, poetic language, German born W. G. Sebald reminds me of the Nobel prize winning French author Patrick Modiano. Mr. Sebald blends fact and fiction in his tale of an unnamed narrator meeting and befriending a historian of European architecture by the name of Jacques Austerlitz. Also included are more than six dozen photographs along with a number of illustrations and charts.
The more we come to know Austerlitz in his recounting of his past, how he arrived in Britain in 1939 as a refugee, age four, from Nazi infested Czechoslovakia, how he was adopted and raised by an older Welsh minister and his wife, how, as an adult, he returned to Prague and located a close friend of his vanished mother and father, how he then further traced the fate of his parents, the more our hearts open not only to Austerlitz and his family but all the many men and women and children who suffered the brutality and madness of the Nazis.
I suspect one reason Mr. Sebald included the many black and white photographs as part of his novel goes back to what art critic Robert Hughes noted about the Holocaust: photography captured the ghastliness of the atrocities in a way other forms of art could not. In an attempt to retain the tone of this deeply moving literary work, I have included black and white photographs of my own choosing to accompany direct quotes from the novel.

"It was only by following the course time prescribed that we could hasten through the gigantic spaces separating us from each other. And indeed, said Austerlitz after a while, to this day there is something illusionistic and illusory about the relationship of time and space as we experience it in traveling, which is why whenever we come home from elsewhere we never feel quite sure if we have really been abroad."

"As it was, I recognized him by the rucksack of his, and for the first time in as far back as I can remember I recollected myself as a small child, at the moment when I realized that it must have been to this same waiting room I had come on my arrival in England over half a century ago."

"After ninety seconds in which to defend yourself to a judge you could be condemned to death for a trifle, some offense barely worth mentioning, the merest contravention of the regulations in force, and then you would be hanged immediately in the execution room next to the law court, where there was an iron rail running along the ceiling down where the lifeless bodies where pushed a little further as required."

"Most of them were silent, some wept quietly, but outbursts of despair, loud shouting and fits of frenzied rage were not uncommon."

“The darkness does not lift but becomes yet heavier as I think how little we can hold in mind, how everything is constantly lapsing into oblivion with every extinguished life, how the world is, as it were, draining itself, in that the history of countless places and objects which themselves have no power or memory is never heard, never described or passed on.”

"The longer I think about it the more it seems to me that we who are still alive are unreal in the eyes of the dead, that only occasionally, in certain lights and atmospheric conditions, do we appear in their field of vision.”
by

“No one can explain exactly what happens within us when the doors behind which our childhood terrors lurk are flung open.”
― W.G. Sebald, Austerlitz
Turning the pages of the novel Austerlitz makes for one powerful, emotionally wrenching experience. Here's what esteemed critic Michiko Kakutani wrote as part of her New York Times review: "We are transported to a memoryscape - a twilight, fogbound world of half-remembered images and ghosts that is reminiscent at once of Ingmar Bergman's Wild Strawberries, Kafka's troubling fables of guilt and apprehension and, of course, Proust's Remembrance of Things Past.''
With his lyrical, poetic language, German born W. G. Sebald reminds me of the Nobel prize winning French author Patrick Modiano. Mr. Sebald blends fact and fiction in his tale of an unnamed narrator meeting and befriending a historian of European architecture by the name of Jacques Austerlitz. Also included are more than six dozen photographs along with a number of illustrations and charts.
The more we come to know Austerlitz in his recounting of his past, how he arrived in Britain in 1939 as a refugee, age four, from Nazi infested Czechoslovakia, how he was adopted and raised by an older Welsh minister and his wife, how, as an adult, he returned to Prague and located a close friend of his vanished mother and father, how he then further traced the fate of his parents, the more our hearts open not only to Austerlitz and his family but all the many men and women and children who suffered the brutality and madness of the Nazis.
I suspect one reason Mr. Sebald included the many black and white photographs as part of his novel goes back to what art critic Robert Hughes noted about the Holocaust: photography captured the ghastliness of the atrocities in a way other forms of art could not. In an attempt to retain the tone of this deeply moving literary work, I have included black and white photographs of my own choosing to accompany direct quotes from the novel.

"It was only by following the course time prescribed that we could hasten through the gigantic spaces separating us from each other. And indeed, said Austerlitz after a while, to this day there is something illusionistic and illusory about the relationship of time and space as we experience it in traveling, which is why whenever we come home from elsewhere we never feel quite sure if we have really been abroad."

"As it was, I recognized him by the rucksack of his, and for the first time in as far back as I can remember I recollected myself as a small child, at the moment when I realized that it must have been to this same waiting room I had come on my arrival in England over half a century ago."

"After ninety seconds in which to defend yourself to a judge you could be condemned to death for a trifle, some offense barely worth mentioning, the merest contravention of the regulations in force, and then you would be hanged immediately in the execution room next to the law court, where there was an iron rail running along the ceiling down where the lifeless bodies where pushed a little further as required."

"Most of them were silent, some wept quietly, but outbursts of despair, loud shouting and fits of frenzied rage were not uncommon."

“The darkness does not lift but becomes yet heavier as I think how little we can hold in mind, how everything is constantly lapsing into oblivion with every extinguished life, how the world is, as it were, draining itself, in that the history of countless places and objects which themselves have no power or memory is never heard, never described or passed on.”

"The longer I think about it the more it seems to me that we who are still alive are unreal in the eyes of the dead, that only occasionally, in certain lights and atmospheric conditions, do we appear in their field of vision.”
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Austerlitz.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
November 14, 2017
–
Started Reading
November 14, 2017
– Shelved
November 20, 2017
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-37 of 37 (37 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Ilse
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Nov 20, 2017 03:54PM
One of my favourite books ever Glenn, looking forward to your fully fleshed out review!
reply
|
flag
Ilse wrote: "One of my favourite books ever Glenn, looking forward to your fully fleshed out review!"Thank you so much, dear Ilse. Even reading only the first pages, I can appreciate how you and many other sensitive readers hold a special place in their heart for this modern classic. I also recall a moving review written by James Wood - I read his essay over two years ago and a number of Wood's turn of phrase and imagines still remain with me.
i read only the Emigrants and was dissapointed, although the first part was very interesting and sad. Maybe I should have read some other book by Sebald?
L wrote: "i read only the Emigrants and was dissapointed, although the first part was very interesting and sad. Maybe I should have read some other book by Sebald?"This is the only Sebald novel I've read so I can't compare to his other work. If my review is appealing to you at all, it might be worth checking this novel. And it is not that long - can be read in a few days.
Extraordinary review, Glenn. Thank you.I would say:
The gigantic spaces separating us arise only from our damaged hearts.
William wrote: "Extraordinary review, Glenn. Thank you.I would say:
The gigantic spaces separating us arise only from our damaged hearts."
Thank you, in turn, William.
Completely agree with your words about huge spaces created by our damaged hearts. We can be super-smart or super-strong but how much does that amount to really if our emotions are twisted and deadened and our hearts are closed down.
"He looked at his hands. Big hands. How useless a man’s hands were, he thought, when it came to fixing the important things."― William Kent Krueger, Iron Lake
oh I see, but yes your review is inviting, especially because of the quotes. So I hope I'll Like austerlitz more :)
Trish wrote: "Powerful stuff, Glenn. Thanks for putting the effort in."Thanks, in turn, Trish. Yes, this novel is very powerful, thus I judged my choosing photography was more appropriate than offering comments.
Utterly telling juxtaposition of thoughts, quotes and chilling photography, Glenn - an apt choice, as the same brings a poignant atmosphere to Sebald's novels. This gripped me from the start with referring to the Antwerp station and the camp in Breendonk ( a friend of mine guides group visits there) - I just couldn't stop noting down quotes, to me Sebald is a brilliant writer.
Ilse wrote: "Utterly telling juxtaposition of thoughts, quotes and chilling photography, Glenn - an apt choice, as the same brings a poignant atmosphere to Sebald's novels. This gripped me from the start with r..."Thank you, dear Ilse. I can imagine how your personal associations with various locations and events in the novel would add much to the book's dramatic and tragic dimensions and also raise your overall appreciation for Sebald's stunning prose.
I need to re-read this wonderful book. What a great idea to choose your own black and white photographs to go with the extracts. I find the second one, with the child on the station platform, most telling.
Sylvie wrote: "I need to re-read this wonderful book. What a great idea to choose your own black and white photographs to go with the extracts. I find the second one, with the child on the station platform, most ..."Thanks, Sylvia. Yes, yes - I judged B&W photos would be the best way by far to capture the flavor of W. B. Sebald's novel. You are right - there is so much emotion and felling and beauty in that photo of the child with suitcase.
Carol wrote: "Brilliant review, Glenn. Haunting and heartbreaking photos."Thanks so much, Carol! I don't think anybody would question how photography captured much of the heart of drama and tragedy in Europe during those terrible years.
What a wonderful review, Glenn! Sebald is one of those writers I'm just waiting to dive into, knowing that once I do, I'll want to read everything he ever wrote. You've just raised the urgency to do this!!
Michael wrote: "What a wonderful review, Glenn! Sebald is one of those writers I'm just waiting to dive into, knowing that once I do, I'll want to read everything he ever wrote. You've just raised the urgency to d..."Thank you, Michael. Certainly a dive into the drama of a very tragic time. Sebald's lush, poetic prose will remind you of writers like Nabokov.
Glenn wrote: "Michael wrote: "What a wonderful review, Glenn! Sebald is one of those writers I'm just waiting to dive into, knowing that once I do, I'll want to read everything he ever wrote. You've just raised ..."Thanks, Glenn. I have The Emigrants, Austerlitz, and On the Natural History of Destruction on my bookshelf, just waiting to be taken up. I've dipped into that prose enough to know it will resonate with me like Nabokov's does, and that I'll want to stay in it for a while.
Robin wrote: "What an extraordinary review of an extraordinarily tragic, heartbreaking, dark time in history."Thanks, Robin. So true. One of the darkest time in all of history. Let's hope and pray all of the arts capturing those years, arts like photography and literature, will serve to open people's hearts and minds so such atrocities will not be repeated.
This is a wonderful review, Glenn, enhanced by the photographs you’ve chosen. I’ve just finished reading Austerlitz and will take some time to write my review, as I’m sure you did.
Lyn wrote: "This is a wonderful review, Glenn, enhanced by the photographs you’ve chosen. I’ve just finished reading Austerlitz and will take some time to write my review, as I’m sure you did."Thanks, Lyn. As you well know, this is an intense novel. I can appreciate you taking your time before writing a review.
A great review of a great book, Glenn. I loved your photographic selections, harrowing though some of them were. Those grainy, B&W photographs were something Sebald inserted into all of his fictional texts. I suspect they may be related to his interest in the imperfect nature of memory. I'd certainly agree that Sebald was exploring similar territory here to Modiano, a writer whose work I've only recently begun investigating.
Paul wrote: "A great review of a great book, Glenn. I loved your photographic selections, harrowing though some of them were. Those grainy, B&W photographs were something Sebald inserted into all of his fiction..."Thanks, Paul. Probably more than any other review I posted, the photographs here speak with such depth. And, yes, I recall those grainy photos inserted into the novel.
I've just reviewed it myself - seventeen years late - but it lacks your photographic adornments, I'm afraid.
Mutasim wrote: "I have been meaning to read Sebald for a while. I think I'll pick this one soon."Great. There's also an audio book available. I listened. Fine narrator.
Usha wrote: "It's about time that I read Winfried Georg Maximilian Sebald . A very inspiring review, Glenn!"Thanks so much, Usha!
Other than this book, I'm unfamiliar with the author's other works so I can't share an informed opinion as to where to start with W. G.. But I suspect Austerlitz would be a good choice.
why sebold? can't think it is a typo knowing you :)
deniz wrote: "why sebold? can't think it is a typo knowing you :)"Thanks so much for letting me know, deniz. When it comes to non-English words, especially non-English names, I have a type of dyslexia. I'll correct now.
Mike wrote: "Fantastic review, Glenn. This is definitely something I'd like to explore."Great, Mike. A modern European classic. If you're a fan of audio books, there's one available.









