Felicia's Reviews > The Farm
The Farm
by
by
The Farm is a place where women (especially immigrants) go to serve as surrogates for wealthy families while living in spa-like surroundings. These women are handsomely paid for their services making it a win-win for both parties.
Oh man this could have been such a great book.
If you dive into this book thinking you're getting a nightmarish Handmaid's Tale-ish take on a baby harvesting farm then you're going to be disappointed.
This is a story about class and privilege and the disparity between the high and low ends of the spectrum. The wealthy achieving their goals on the back of those less fortunate has always been the way in America and this story gives a unique take on that truth.
"....in America you only need to know how to make money. Money buys everything else."
After reading this book I feel like the author promised more than she delivered.
The entire book hints at some underlying evil going on at the farm yet nothing ever happens on that front. The Farm itself is pretty straightforward leaving the story to rest solely on the characters, namely the surrogates.
Aside from Jane, the main character, we don't learn a whole lot about the other surrogates, the wealthy parents-to-be or the people running the farm.
Although Joanne Ramos has written a book featuring a timely subject matter, her telling of the story falls flat on all fronts.
I received an ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Oh man this could have been such a great book.
If you dive into this book thinking you're getting a nightmarish Handmaid's Tale-ish take on a baby harvesting farm then you're going to be disappointed.
This is a story about class and privilege and the disparity between the high and low ends of the spectrum. The wealthy achieving their goals on the back of those less fortunate has always been the way in America and this story gives a unique take on that truth.
"....in America you only need to know how to make money. Money buys everything else."
After reading this book I feel like the author promised more than she delivered.
The entire book hints at some underlying evil going on at the farm yet nothing ever happens on that front. The Farm itself is pretty straightforward leaving the story to rest solely on the characters, namely the surrogates.
Aside from Jane, the main character, we don't learn a whole lot about the other surrogates, the wealthy parents-to-be or the people running the farm.
Although Joanne Ramos has written a book featuring a timely subject matter, her telling of the story falls flat on all fronts.
I received an ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Farm.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
January 27, 2019
– Shelved as:
digital-arcs-to-review
January 27, 2019
– Shelved
February 13, 2019
–
Started Reading
February 18, 2019
–
43.12%
"It has taken me 3 days just to get this far 😫
The flu has hijacked my life. 🥵"
page
141
The flu has hijacked my life. 🥵"
February 18, 2019
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 90 (90 new)
message 1:
by
Amanda
(new)
Feb 15, 2019 10:21AM
I've been on the fence about reading this one, can't wait to see what you think!
reply
|
flag
I've been down with the flu, first time in my life, now I get what the big deal is 😫 so I've been slow going on this book.
That's a shame...I had very high hopes for this one. Still might give it a chance...thanks for your review, hope you are feeling better!
I appreciate your thoughts on this one, Felicia. It sounds like it held promise but didn’t deliver. I hope you love your next read. ♥️
Too bad! I had skipped this on NG, but recently saw a review that floored me. It stinks when we go in expecting one thing and it's totally not that at all. Hope your next one is better!
Well darn it...of course I downloaded it when I received the widget. Thanks for the head's up. I see a DNF in my future 😉
Oh no! I was totally thinking/hoping this one would take that nightmarish Handmaid's Tale-ish take on a baby harvesting farm turn - definitely disappointed. 😉
@Jan I think you'll get through it. In fact, I hope you do because the ending and the epilogue are... Just... Idk. You gotta read it though so at least skip to the end. You won't miss anything 😂
Felicia wrote: "@Jan I think you'll get through it. In fact, I hope you do because the ending and the epilogue are... Just... Idk. You gotta read it though so at least skip to the end. You won't miss anything 😂"haha...great advice and one way to get it off my shelf 😂
Felicia wrote: "@Michelle dang now I want to see that review"I don't remember where I read it, but it talked about how most of the women on the farm were immigrants and I thought it was an interesting thought. I guess I sort of related it to how there are many immigrants who work on our farms or other low wage jobs and here again we find immigrant women doing something that I white person wouldn't most likely need to consider. White women being able to avoid this because they had opportunities afforded to them through education and social standing where these women didn't. This was their way to make a living and to be frank, do something that most white women wouldn't do. I could be way off base in that being how the story is (since I haven't read it), but those thoughts gave me pause and made me think "what if" for the future.
@Michelle that sums up what the story hoped to convey, at least from my point of view. And if that is the case then that's what the author should have concentrated on instead of wandering the off on the imaginary evil of the company and the possibility of child abuse involving one of the women. These two subplots have nothing to do with advancing the story and are a total distraction. I kept waiting for something to develop from those two storylines and they never did. Also, the story concentrates on 3 particular women at the Farm, two of which are white ?? I'm not sure the author knew exactly what she wanted to convey in this story.bIs a human interest story? A mystery? A thriller? Dystopian? It's kinda everywhere and nowhere at the same time.
Felicia wrote: "@Michelle that sums up what the story hoped to convey, at least from my point of view. And if that is the case then that's what the author should have concentrated on instead of wandering the off o..."Those points make perfect sense. It's a shame when you are reading something and it has the bones of something amazing and it doesn't come to fruition.
Excellent review Felicia! Sorry this one fell short for you! I have this one on my shelf! Hope I have better luck with it!💕💕
Ugh oh Felicia! I have this one to read.. now I’m kinda dreading it.. Thanks girl... LOL. Hope you find a good one soon!
Like Susanne, I have this one to read, and this is the third, maybe, 2 star review I've read for this, so I can only hope that I will enjoy it more than you did, but am not exactly hopeful.... Terrific review, though, Felicia!
I agree that the book could have been much more in depth about the subject of surrogacy. I was disappointed that the implied danger was really nothing.
Felicia, you're absolutely right - it's not unbearable, or really even bad. I just felt like it had no real direction, never seemed to have any one (or even two or three) message(s) - it was just disappointing.
@Cheri this could have been sooooo good, too. A heavy-handed editor could have worked wonders with this book.
I thought book was really thought provoking and well-written. It's a complex book that I think is meant to question not to answer. Is it dystopian or not? Some think so but this sort of inequality is our current reality. It's not meant to be a thriller - it struck me the author was trying to create the tension but graph that into the everyday struggles many feel living day to day in the society/world we current inhabit. I think it was really well done. If someone is looking for a black and white handmaid's tale type book this isn't it for sure





















