Miranda Reads's Reviews > Shiver

Shiver by Maggie Stiefvater
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
71848701
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: audiobook

2.5 Stars
description
To summarize: Boy loves girl. Girl loves wolf. Possible bestiality (new edgy YA twist?)

Wolf is actually boy who loves girl.

Wolf turns into boy. Girl loves boy.

Kisses. Many kisses.
I stood on my toes and stole a soft kiss from his lips. "Surprise attack," I said.
Sam leaned down and kissed me back, his mouth lingering on mine, teeth grazing my lower lip, making me shiver. "Surprise attack back."
"Sneaky," I said, my voice breathier than I intended.
This book wasn't bad per se...it was just very, very, very, very, VERY heavy on the insta-love.
His lips tasted cool and sharp, peppermint, winter, but his hands, soft on the back of my neck, promised long days and summer and forever.
It wasn't even the totally terrible lovey-dovey levels...it was just a lot to cram into one book and 25-year-old me did get a little eye-rolly over this:
It is possible to be in love with you just because of who you are.
Yes, believe it or not young teenagers, you can love a person for their personality.

And as someone who prefers SOME sort of plot, I did get a little bored of all the cutesy moments of their relationship.

So much of the page-space was absolutely devoted to Girl protecting Boy from secrets or Boy protecting Girl from secrets.

Sigh.

It's a huge pet peeve of mine whenever the plot of the entire book could disappear merely if the two main characters talk to each other.

And the book did get a little fake-philosophical, which induced further eye-rolling.
I'd found heaven and grabbed it as tightly as I could, but it was unraveling, an insubstantial thread sliding between my fingers, too fine to hold.
It's like...I get that Girl's been pining over Wolf for six years...but jeez louise...that's a lot of kisses.
“Grace,” I said, very softly. “Say something.”
Sam,” she said, and I crushed her to me.
And let's not even get into the reason behind the werewolfism. Suffice to say that there were more holes than a fishnet.

Ultimately, I did enjoy parts of the book but good lawd. These kids need a cold shower.

Though, I did love their love for books!
Books are more real when you read them outside.
YouTube | Blog | Instagram | Twitter | Facebook | Snapchat @miranda_reads
449 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Shiver.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 26, 2019 – Started Reading
June 26, 2019 – Shelved
June 29, 2019 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-40 of 40 (40 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Peter (new)

Peter Martuneac Nice review, very thoughtful! Doesn’t really sound like my kind of book though. Insta-love is a huuuge turn off.


message 2: by Meredith (new)

Meredith Thanks for this. I picked up a 25 cent copy at a used book sale... Think I’ll donate it right back! 😳


message 3: by Julia (new)

Julia Ash Great review, Miranda!!! I can kiss a book goodbye if there's too much lovey-dovey ;) I loved your comment: Suffice to say that there were more holes than a fishnet. LOL!


message 4: by KAS (new)

KAS Terrific review, Miranda ;) Sorry it was a bit to “cutesy” for you. ❤️


Miranda Reads Peter wrote: "Nice review, very thoughtful! Doesn’t really sound like my kind of book though. Insta-love is a huuuge turn off."

Isn't that the truth? Sigh


Miranda Reads Meredith wrote: "Thanks for this. I picked up a 25 cent copy at a used book sale... Think I’ll donate it right back! 😳"

It's worth it for 25 cents. It definitely did have it's merits!


Miranda Reads Julia wrote: "Great review, Miranda!!! I can kiss a book goodbye if there's too much lovey-dovey ;) I loved your comment: Suffice to say that there were more holes than a fishnet. LOL!"

Haha - glad you liked the fishnet comment. Was working on that all day!!


Miranda Reads KAS wrote: "Terrific review, Miranda ;) Sorry it was a bit to “cutesy” for you. ❤️"

Thanks KAS. It was definitely fun, just a little much!


message 9: by Eric (new)

Eric Plume Great review as usual! :D

This sounds like a lot of YA does these days; it 1: needs to be filed under romance and 2: probably doesn't need to be marketed to teenagers.


message 10: by Audrey (new)

Audrey “cold shower” – lol


message 11: by Leeya (new)

Leeya I never considered reading the book but reading your review was a lot fun. Well done!


message 12: by Rich (new)

Rich Well done review, think I may enjoy it more than the book though lol


Rebekah Totally agree with you! 🙄


Amelia Valentine I absolutely agree with you! I gave it 3 stars and didn't continue with the series cause... well, I honestly just didn't give a damn.


Permanently_Booked Ohhh we have the same pet peeve. Crap, this series is sitting on my bookshelf waiting to be read too. I may not be so excited I own them all now.


Simply Sam I started Shiver after loving Scorpio Races. Man, I just couldn't with this book. It's funny how an author can write what's easily one of my 5-star favorites while also being the author of one of my few 1-star books. Your review was infinitely more enjoyable than the book for me :)


Miranda Reads Eric wrote: "Great review as usual! :D

This sounds like a lot of YA does these days; it 1: needs to be filed under romance and 2: probably doesn't need to be marketed to teenagers."


Mmmm... it didn't have enough steamy bits for a romance, it was more of a cutesy-cute sorta thing.

That being said, i definitely see what you are saying!


Miranda Reads Audrey wrote: "“cold shower” – lol"

Ha :)


Miranda Reads Leeya wrote: "I never considered reading the book but reading your review was a lot fun. Well done!"

Haha, thank you :)


Miranda Reads Rich wrote: "Well done review, think I may enjoy it more than the book though lol"

Lollll! Glad you liked it then!!


Miranda Reads Rebekah,the Hufflepuff book girl wrote: "Totally agree with you! 🙄"

Awesome!


Miranda Reads Amelia wrote: "I absolutely agree with you! I gave it 3 stars and didn't continue with the series cause... well, I honestly just didn't give a damn."

I did that in high school. Going in for round II - bound and determined to finish!


Miranda Reads C. wrote: "Ohhh we have the same pet peeve. Crap, this series is sitting on my bookshelf waiting to be read too. I may not be so excited I own them all now."

... at least the covers are gorgeous?? Right??


Miranda Reads Simply Sam ツ wrote: "I started Shiver after loving Scorpio Races. Man, I just couldn't with this book. It's funny how an author can write what's easily one of my 5-star favorites while also being the author of one of m..."

I also LOVED the Scorpio Races and felt similarly disappointed :(


message 25: by [deleted user] (new)

I'm getting tired of reading anything by Maggie Stiefvater beside The Raven Cycle. That was a perfect masterpiece, but her other books are seems meh :/


Kat valentine ( Katsbookcornerreads) Excellent review Miranda!!💋😉💗💖


message 27: by Laurene (new)

Laurene Loved your review!


Miranda Reads Feral goblin child 🍃 wrote: "I'm getting tired of reading anything by Maggie Stiefvater beside The Raven Cycle. That was a perfect masterpiece, but her other books are seems meh :/"

It was a horrible realization. I LOVED the raven boys..
And nothing seems to hold


Miranda Reads Kat wrote: "Excellent review Miranda!!💋😉💗💖"

Thank you!!


Miranda Reads Laurene wrote: "Loved your review!"

Thanks :)


message 31: by [deleted user] (new)

At least we can wait for Call down the hawk 😍


Miranda Reads I cannot WAIT for that!


message 33: by [deleted user] (new)

YEAAAH, I WANT 😍😍😍


message 34: by Tonya Gordon (new) - added it

Tonya Gordon This Alicia I love your book you ready


maté “Yes, believe it or not young teenagers, you can love a person for their personality.”

I am CRYING laughing 😂 great review and I agree 100%


Miranda Reads Hannah wrote: "“Yes, believe it or not young teenagers, you can love a person for their personality.”

I am CRYING laughing 😂 great review and I agree 100%"


Thanks :D:D


Serenity Pennington What age group do you think this would be good for? Nice review by the way.


Miranda Reads Serenity Pennington wrote: "What age group do you think this would be good for? Nice review by the way."

Early teens would work best


Tabitha  Tomala Love this series, but I can understand the review xD


Clare L This book series is in my top 10 of favorite books.
I hate to see you crap talk it (no offense) but I can understand why you didn't like it.
One of your reasons, you said was the "insta love". I can see why some people might not like that- but sorry, that is one of best things about this book- the insta love and all. Those. Kisses!
I like the fast-paced books, like this one, sorry you didn't like it


back to top