Peter's Reviews > Cold Mountain.

Cold Mountain. by Charles Frazier
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
63168028
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: literary-fiction, historical-fiction, top-10, favorites, buddy-read

Journey
A sweeping and tumultuous story of an injured American civil war soldier who goes AWOL and makes a relentless and dangerous journey back home to Cold Mountain, and to the woman he intends spending the rest of his life with. As poetic as Homer’s Odyssey, Charles Frazier’s Cold Mountain is an outstanding literary masterpiece. He tells the story of Inman and Ada, their past, people they meet on their travels, the challenges they face and the dreams they hold dear. A physical journey home and a journey of personal development, equally captivating, equally precarious and equally drawing the story to a climactic ending. With a magician’s hand, Frazier keeps us spellbound with the central story, while conjuring wisps of literary tales from Greek, Roman and English literature and weaving them into the narrative with the effortless hand of an illusionist.

Frazier is never obvious with the content of his story, even though Odysseus’ journey back from the Trojan War to his wife Penelope in Ithaca, reverberates throughout this novel. This is not about a modern retelling of the Odyssey but rather enticing us to explore how the ancient folklore has been reshaped to provide a unique, clever and agonising alternative. Within the narrative, we catch faded echoes of exotic characters such as Witches, Sirens, Cyclopes, Persephone, Calypso, Cerberus, Narcissus but their behaviour may or may not follow an expected path but it will always be imaginatively realised.

Inman battles elements of nature as he travels through the winter – cold, wet, hungry and at times disorientated. He is an honest man and often reflects “... the wrong a man does flies back at him.” As a soldier he has seen horrors and been part of those horrors, but he approaches every situation with a positive intent that fairness will be done. Sometimes kindness is repaid and sometimes it is manipulated against him. Regardless, Inman must face all his trials as he descends through the levels of hell – who knows maybe there are nine of them and Dante makes an appearance as well?

Ada is joined by Ruby as she now tries to make her farm operational following the death of her father. A lady of leisure, Ada must now face a harsh reality and journey through the challenges of hard work, growing crops, raising livestock, fixing fences and trading for goods. Ruby is accomplished at this type of work and bluntly forces Ada to play her part in this endeavour. Ada now goes to bed tired and physically exhausted and her outward appearance changes to sun-drenched skin, rough-skinned hands and practical work clothes.

Frazier places nature as a constant reference point and uses it with distinguished ardour. Elements of birds and trees add deeper appreciation of the signs nature is constantly presenting to us. Nature with its mythical connections gives Frazier another wand to magically enthral us.

This was a first buddy read with Julie and it was a joy to take our time and discuss the links and decipher the meaning of various scenes. I am full of admiration for Charles Frazier after devouring his epic piece of work and I would highly recommend reading the book. Another addition to my Top 10 books of all time.
204 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Cold Mountain..
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 7, 2020 – Shelved as: to-read
February 7, 2020 – Shelved
March 2, 2020 – Shelved as: literary-fiction
March 22, 2020 – Started Reading
April 13, 2020 – Shelved as: historical-fiction
April 13, 2020 – Shelved as: top-10
April 13, 2020 – Finished Reading
May 31, 2020 – Shelved as: favorites
July 12, 2020 – Shelved as: buddy-read

Comments Showing 1-50 of 80 (80 new)


Julie G Peter,
What an excellent and captivating response you've shared here. I knew we were going to have fun reading this, but I didn't anticipate how deep and introspective this journey would be for either or us, nor did I fully anticipate how much you would enjoy it (though I did suspect it).
I selected this book for my Reading Road Trip last autumn, when this Virus was not a threat to us, and you agreed to join me on this buddy read in January or February of this year, so neither of us chose the book with a pandemic in mind, but it is amazing to me how many sad parallels could be made, to a pandemic and a war. I can not help but view Ada, Inman, Ruby and Stobrod as survivors, clever crows who change with the times. Let us all now summon our inner crows:
[Ruby] noted with disapproval that many a bird would die rather than eat any but food it relishes. Crows will relish what presents itself. She admired their keenness of wit, lack of pridefulness, love of practical jokes, slyness in a fight. All of these she saw as making up the genius of crow, which was a kind of willed mastery over what she assumed was a natural inclination toward bile and melancholy, as evidenced by its drear plumage.


Candi A superb review, Peter! I need to re-read this before long. You and Julie have definitely tempted me to do so!!


Peter Julie wrote: "Peter,
What an excellent and captivating response you've shared here. I knew we were going to have fun reading this, but I didn't anticipate how deep and introspective this journey would be for eit..."


I was delighted to join you on your US reading road trip - what a brilliant idea and I don't think I could have joined you on a better leg. I truly appreciate your insights and your knowledge back to the Odyssey it was all so fulfilling.

You are right about the connection with the current pandemic. How the isolation and viewing each person you encountered with suspicion and threat of harm.

Thank you so much, Julie, for your comment and the buddy read, you are a real treasure. :):)


Peter Candi wrote: "A superb review, Peter! I need to re-read this before long. You and Julie have definitely tempted me to do so!!"

It does seem like a book that will give even more if you read it a second and third time. Thank you very much, Candi, for your kind comment. :):)


message 5: by Robin (new)

Robin Lovely review, Peter. You and Julie make a compelling case!


message 6: by Richard (new)

Richard A wonderful review Peter ....... this novel sounds so tempting. Yours and Julie’s reviews have put it on to my radar and on to my wish list.


Julie G Peter,
What a kind comment!
xoxo


Julie G To Richard, from Cold Mountain:

One thing he discovered with a great deal of astonishment was that music held more for him than just pleasure. There was meat to it. The grouping of sounds, their forms in the air as they rang out and faded, said something comforting to him about the rule of creation. What the music said was that there is a right way for things to be ordered so that life might not always be just tangle and drift but have a shape, an aim.


message 9: by Ceecee (new)

Ceecee Fantastic review Peter. Confession time - saw the movie, loved the movie, bought the book. That’s as far as it got. Languishing on the bookshelf 😳😊


message 10: by Shruti (new)

Shruti What a terrific review, Peter! Adding it to my TBR. Wonderful.


message 11: by Kelli (new)

Kelli W Excellent review! I probably should have read the book instead of watching the movie. I didn't really love the movie:(


message 12: by Paromjit (new)

Paromjit Fabulous review as ever, Peter.:):)


Maureen That’s a compelling review Peter!


message 14: by Kimber (last edited Apr 13, 2020 11:09AM) (new)

Kimber Silver What a wonderful write-up, Peter! This sounds like a beautiful read. I like your descriptions of how the author used nature "to magically enthral us." :-)


message 15: by Beata (new)

Beata Beautiful review, Peter :)) And such a high praise :)) Hope you & Julie have loads of buddy reads, My Friend :)


message 16: by J.C. (new) - rated it 5 stars

J.C. I loved this book when I read it some years back and keep meaning to re-read it, for the sheer, sensual pleasure of it. Your review was most interesting and insightful! Thank you for encouraging me to put it higher on the TBR list. (The film also is superb).


Paula K Outstanding review, Peter! A wonderful book as well as the movie. So glad to see it made your Top 10!


message 18: by Carol (new)

Carol Both Julie and you wrote outstanding reviews for this novel, Peter!


Allison (universewithinpages) Great review, Peter!


message 20: by Mike (new)

Mike Fabulous review, Peter. You've exposed facets of this story that I was unaware of although I've only watched the movie several times. The excerpts that Julie included in the comments here have me eager to explore this one for myself.


Julie G To Carol: xoxo


Julie G To Mike: I almost can't recommend it more. My entire book is filled with post-it notes, highlighting my favorite passages. . . which is handy, given that I keep quoting them! First on my review, now on Peter's comments. Sorry, Peter, I can't seem to stop and I have the most tremendous book hangover, too!


message 23: by JanB (new)

JanB Fabulous review Peter! So glad this was a successful buddy read :)


message 24: by Mary Beth (new)

Mary Beth Awesome review, Peter!


message 25: by Lyn (new)

Lyn I always love your reviews, Peter, but this one, most especially! I truly loved this book, too and you have reminded me that it’s definitely time for a re-read. 👍😊


Kevin Ansbro Though I had a few issues with this book, Frazier's beautiful prose won me over (I love good writing, and I love an epic).
And this was a magnificent review, Peter. Bravo!

We each face our own Odyssey right now. Stay safe, everyone!


Peter Robin wrote: "Lovely review, Peter. You and Julie make a compelling case!"

Thank you very much Robin. We both really loved this book and between us, it comes highly recommended. :):)


Peter Richard wrote: "A wonderful review Peter ....... this novel sounds so tempting. Yours and Julie’s reviews have put it on to my radar and on to my wish list."

I couldn't recommend it highly enough, especially if you consider ancient Greek stories and other references. Thank you very much for your kind words, Richard. :):)


Peter Ceecee wrote: "Fantastic review Peter. Confession time - saw the movie, loved the movie, bought the book. That’s as far as it got. Languishing on the bookshelf 😳😊"

Ceecee you will love this book but if you haven't read the Odyssey I would suggest reading a summary of Odysseus' journey and the encounters he had. It was great spotting the links. Thanks for your kind words. :):)


Peter Shruti wrote: "What a terrific review, Peter! Adding it to my TBR. Wonderful."

Thank you so much for your very kind comment, Shruti. I hope you enjoy this wonderful book. :):)


Peter Kelli wrote: "Excellent review! I probably should have read the book instead of watching the movie. I didn't really love the movie:("

Thank you very much, Kelli. I know Julie has a few criticisms of the movie in terms of its casting of Ada and Ruby but I've never watched it. I'm glad I didn't but I imagine there will be so many different elements to enjoy in the book. :):)


Peter Paromjit wrote: "Fabulous review as ever, Peter.:):)"

Thank you very much, my dear friend. Keep safe. :):)


Peter Maureen wrote: "That’s a compelling review Peter!"

I really appreciate that Maureen, thanks very much. Keep safe. :):)


Margaret Mary I want to read this book so much now. I enjoyed the film but you have opened up so many more possibilities to enjoy. Fantastic review, Peter. 💖


message 35: by Grace A. (new)

Grace A. I love it when a book connects deeply with the reality I can feel and touch, especially nature. Great review, Peter.


Peter Kimber wrote: "What a wonderful write-up, Peter! This sounds like a beautiful read. I like your descriptions of how the author used nature "to magically enthral us." :-)"

I think you would really like this one Kimber there are many lovely descriptions in the book. Thanks for your kind comments. :):)


Peter Beata wrote: "Beautiful review, Peter :)) And such a high praise :)) Hope you & Julie have loads of buddy reads, My Friend :)"

I'm very lucky with my reading buddies, they're all fantastic ;)

Thank you very much for your kind words, Beata. :):)


Peter J.C. wrote: "I loved this book when I read it some years back and keep meaning to re-read it, for the sheer, sensual pleasure of it. Your review was most interesting and insightful! Thank you for encouraging me..."

Thank you for very much, J.C. It certainly is one of those books that you can imagine rereading and expecting to get something else from it. It's also a great book to read in a book club so you can discuss many of the scenes. :):)


Peter Paula wrote: "Outstanding review, Peter! A wonderful book as well as the movie. So glad to see it made your Top 10!"

It was tough to kick a top 10 book out but this one did belong on that shelf. Thank you for your lovely comment, Paula. I haven't seen the movie yet so I'm looking forward to seeing how well they told the story. :):)


Peter Carol wrote: "Both Julie and you wrote outstanding reviews for this novel, Peter!"

Thank you very much, Carol and Julie's review totally inspired me. She wrote a brilliant and heartfelt review. :):)


Peter Allison wrote: "Great review, Peter!"

Thank you very much, Allison, really appreciated. :):)


Peter Mike wrote: "Fabulous review, Peter. You've exposed facets of this story that I was unaware of although I've only watched the movie several times. The excerpts that Julie included in the comments here have me e..."

Thank you so much, Mike. I haven't watched the film but I would wonder how the film would convey the intricate backstories and the links to classic and mythical stories. I think you will really enjoy reading this one. :):)


Peter Julie wrote: "To Mike: I almost can't recommend it more. My entire book is filled with post-it notes, highlighting my favorite passages. . . which is handy, given that I keep quoting them! First on my review, no..."

LOL. In a moment of madness, I removed the post-its and put the book back but on a more hallowed place in my bookcase. You just keep working away, posting wherever you like, I love your passion for this book, Julie. I have to say I've been very very fortunate that the books I'm reading now are great so I probably don't have the hangover you have but I still feel a bit empty. :):)


message 44: by Karina (new) - added it

Karina I finished reading Julie's review, then yours Peter and I have to say WOW! Two fabulous writers enjoying a wonderful book together. Heavenly! I need to read this. So happy 2 of the kindest people on here got to debate and enjoy a long distancing novel. Great review, Peter! :D


Peter JanB wrote: "Fabulous review Peter! So glad this was a successful buddy read :)"

Thank you very much, Jan, it was a pleasure doing the buddy read with Julie. Plus it was a great book to discuss. This is a brilliant choice for a book club. :):)


Peter Mary Beth wrote: "Awesome review, Peter!"

Thank you very much, Mary Beth, really appreciated. :):)


Peter Lyn wrote: "I always love your reviews, Peter, but this one, most especially! I truly loved this book, too and you have reminded me that it’s definitely time for a re-read. 👍😊"

That is extremely kind of you, Lyn and I'm delighted we share the love of a great book. I think every time you'd read this book you would discover something different. Enjoy your re-read. :):)


Peter Kevin wrote: "Though I had a few issues with this book, Frazier's beautiful prose won me over (I love good writing, and I love an epic).
And this was a magnificent review, Peter. Bravo!

We each face our own Ody..."


I read your fantastic review, Kevin and I totally agree with your comment on quotation marks etc. so I went into this read trying to put that out of my mind. I then just became so immersed in the novel and seeking the links to other classic stories and legends, that I forgot about it. I did also pick it up that you appreciated his prose and storytelling.

I also think that reading this book as a buddy read or book club read will bring much more value.

Thank you for your kind comments. Take care and stay safe. :):)


Amanda B Fab review...I loved this book Peter, a definite 5 star read for me!


The Dusty Jacket Fantastic review! I loved this one as well.


« previous 1
back to top