jessica's Reviews > The Alchemist
The Alchemist
by
by
tl;dr - important message, disappointing execution.
for this to have been described as a story that changes lives, im a little let down. whilst this certainly had the potential to be ‘life changing,’ i felt there were many aspects which kept the story from delivering what could have been a meaningful experience.
firstly, this is told like a parable. i would consider this story to fall more along the lines of religious allegory than philosophical text. that, in itself, is neither here nor there. however, i read somewhere that effective parables should comfort the afflicted and afflict the comfortable. unfortunately, this book does neither of those things - it pampers to the egos of the self-righteous and chastises those who dont adhere to certain values. which is a shame, because this was supposed to be a story about following ones heart by chasing dreams and passions. too bad that message got lost somewhere along the way.
secondly, i didnt connect with the any of characters, as i found them to be very two-dimensional. for a story that was meant to be about personal growth, i did not get any sense of emotion in the writing. a boy sells his entire livelihood, sets sail for distant continent, and crosses an entire desert in search of something he desperately desires - and yet, i couldnt care less about his journey. also, the portrayal of women in this is frustratingly poor.
anyways, i liked the idea. i personally try to live my life by many of the lessons and teachings in this book - i believe it is important for one to follow their dreams, to always listen to their heart, and to never give up on something they are passionate about (as much as realistically possible). but i think the effectiveness of those messages was lost in this story.
↠ 2.5 stars
for this to have been described as a story that changes lives, im a little let down. whilst this certainly had the potential to be ‘life changing,’ i felt there were many aspects which kept the story from delivering what could have been a meaningful experience.
firstly, this is told like a parable. i would consider this story to fall more along the lines of religious allegory than philosophical text. that, in itself, is neither here nor there. however, i read somewhere that effective parables should comfort the afflicted and afflict the comfortable. unfortunately, this book does neither of those things - it pampers to the egos of the self-righteous and chastises those who dont adhere to certain values. which is a shame, because this was supposed to be a story about following ones heart by chasing dreams and passions. too bad that message got lost somewhere along the way.
secondly, i didnt connect with the any of characters, as i found them to be very two-dimensional. for a story that was meant to be about personal growth, i did not get any sense of emotion in the writing. a boy sells his entire livelihood, sets sail for distant continent, and crosses an entire desert in search of something he desperately desires - and yet, i couldnt care less about his journey. also, the portrayal of women in this is frustratingly poor.
anyways, i liked the idea. i personally try to live my life by many of the lessons and teachings in this book - i believe it is important for one to follow their dreams, to always listen to their heart, and to never give up on something they are passionate about (as much as realistically possible). but i think the effectiveness of those messages was lost in this story.
↠ 2.5 stars
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Alchemist.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
June 12, 2012
– Shelved
Started Reading
November 26, 2018
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-16 of 16 (16 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Deepthi
(new)
Nov 27, 2018 06:00AM
I love your reviews... they're so long and brief! :)
reply
|
flag
my reviews used to be so much shorter!! i dont know what happened. lol. i try to keep them concise, but sometimes i just have too much to say. 🙈
That's no problem, actually :)It's more helpful to people looking for reviews of whether to read the book or not (me xD)
Personally, I think this book is overhyped. However, I agree that the lessons/teaching are important but the characters lack detail for me and the storyline is more or less all over the place. I’m glad i’m not the only one who didn’t fancy this book..
nope, youre not the only one! and although im glad you feel similarly, i am sorry this didnt work out for you. :(
jessica wrote: "not only is that a relief, but its also a great compliment. thanks so much, deepthi!! <3"Sorry for the delay, just saw it...
Anytime! :)
jessica wrote: "i didnt connect with the any of characters, as i found them to be very two-dimensional."Lolol. You didn't connect with Fatima? Her sole purpose is to act as a sexual distraction—another kind of treasure ;)—for Santiago. Then, when Santiago decides he will pursue his dream instead of her, she decides she will patiently await his return...
How can you not relate to such a high quality character /s
Probably the worst character in the history of characters.
Great review. I thought the simplistic writing added to the charm and the story. Also knowing that it was his first novel and how much he put into the story based upon his own life experience of rejection, hard times, etc. But I can totally see how off-putting the style of the book, pacing, plot, and characters can be to some. Overall, it’s the message that I think resonated so well with so many people.
John wrote: " Lolol. You didn't connect with Fatima? Her sole purpose is to act as a sexual distraction—..."hmm. you know, the more i think about it, if a guy came up to me, looked me in the eyes and his first words to me were ‘i love you,’ i would probably wait for him, too. im not getting any younger, you know. cant afford to be too picky these days when it comes to my purpose in life. :P
yeah, it seems like its either a hit or miss with people - no real in between. sorry this wasnt as great of a story as you might have hoped, sean! :(
Good review, I had a similar view, I loved what he was trying to do but his implementation was just woeful to me. This certainly is a hate it or love it type of book. Lmao at your reply to John.



