Glenn Russell's Reviews > Deliverance
Deliverance
by

Intense, fierce, harsh, profound - anybody who has either read this James Dickey novel or seen the movie knows what I'm talking about.
Deliverance, a tale where the sentences run over white water rapids with jagged rocks sticking up everywhere. Grab a paddle and negotiate a batch of sentences taken from the first sixty pages where narrator Ed recounts the time prior to when he and his three suburban buddies stepped into their canoes and set off down a North Georgia river. I've also sprinkled in my modest comments.
"This whole valley will be under water. But right now it's wild. And I mean wild; it looks like something up in Alaska. We really ought to go up there before the real estate people get hold of it and make it over into one of their heavens.”
These are the words of Ed's best friend Lewis, the man heading up their river adventure. There's a critical dynamic here that shouldn't be underestimated: the rural folk in North Georgia know they're about to be displaced by urban sprawl and they resent it. In many ways, their displacement and the death of their way of life run parallel to Native Americans displaced by white expansion throughout the West under the banner of manifest destiny, a comparison highlighted by Goodreads friend and literary scholar Robert H. Brinkmeyer Jr.
"He was the kind of man who tries by any means – weight lifting, diet, exercise, self-help manuals from taxidermy to modern art – to hold on to his body and mind and improve them, to rise about time. And yet he was also the first to take a chance, as though the burden of his own laborious immortality were too heavy to bear, and he wanted to get out of it by means of an accident, or what would appear to others to be an accident.”
Here Ed describes his friend Lewis. As soon as the four boys hit rural Georgia, Ed gets a taste of the challenges Lewis has taken on for Drew, Bobby and himself. Drew playing music with the banjo boy, their dealings with the brothers they hire to drive their cars back down to town, their tussles with the wild river – everything turns out to be mere prelude to that violent encounter with two hillbillies.
As you read these opening pages, you could ask yourself if you would join Lewis on such a river excursion. Being a city guy myself, I have to tell you that I would not: as an adult, my adventures are taken either through literature and the arts or as an inner spiritual journey by means of meditation and yoga.
"I suddenly felt like George Holley, my old Braque man, must have felt when he worked for us, saying to himself in any way he could, day after day, I am with you but not of you."
Ed is brutally honest with himself: he admits he is very much with the graphic design work he does, that he doesn't have any artistic ambition beyond merely doing the job, that he wants nothing more than to slide through life without undue friction.
But then it happens for Ed: one day at the office he catches sight of the gold in the eye of a young female model his studio is photographing for an ad. All of a sudden Ed realizes his life is one unending sea of inconsequential happenings and he'll never move beyond the colorless borders of his own boredom. Ed flashes on the possibility of another life, a deliverance. How? That thrilling trip up river with Lewis.
"Funny thing about up yonder. The whole thing's different. I mean the whole way of taking life and the terms you take it on."
Again, these are the words of Lewis when Ed asks about what they're getting themselves into. Lewis goes on to explain that not only does Ed not know about the North Georgia rural life but he doesn't want to know anything about it. Ominous, ominous - the life of the hillbillies is not only drastically different but their rural lifestyle is so diametrically opposed to his suburban comfort, fancy house, luxury car, TV and secure company job that he will be seen as the enemy.
"But I believe in survival. All kinds. Every time I come up here, I believe in it more. You know, with all the so-called modern conveniences, a man can still fall down."
Once again, the words of Lewis, this time as he articulates his philosophy of life. According to Lewis, our time on this Earth all boils down to survival - how we're going to save ourselves when all we have to rely on is our bodies and our own inner strength.
Ed retorts that all of what Lewis said here is the making of a fantasy life. Lewis replies in turn: "That's all anybody has got. It depends on how strong your fantasy is, and whether you really - really - in your own mind, fit into your own fantasy, whether you measure up to what you've fantasized. i don't know what yours is, but I'll bet you don't come up to it."
Does this statement, this question, serve as a stand-in for what author James Dickey would like to ask us as we live our own lives? If so, that's one of the ultimate questions - do we really and truly measure up to our own vision of ourselves and our vision of the world? Are we willing to put our vision to the test? If so, how much risk, how much danger are we willing to undergo?
Question to keep in mind as we read this timeless classic.
by

Intense, fierce, harsh, profound - anybody who has either read this James Dickey novel or seen the movie knows what I'm talking about.
Deliverance, a tale where the sentences run over white water rapids with jagged rocks sticking up everywhere. Grab a paddle and negotiate a batch of sentences taken from the first sixty pages where narrator Ed recounts the time prior to when he and his three suburban buddies stepped into their canoes and set off down a North Georgia river. I've also sprinkled in my modest comments.
"This whole valley will be under water. But right now it's wild. And I mean wild; it looks like something up in Alaska. We really ought to go up there before the real estate people get hold of it and make it over into one of their heavens.”
These are the words of Ed's best friend Lewis, the man heading up their river adventure. There's a critical dynamic here that shouldn't be underestimated: the rural folk in North Georgia know they're about to be displaced by urban sprawl and they resent it. In many ways, their displacement and the death of their way of life run parallel to Native Americans displaced by white expansion throughout the West under the banner of manifest destiny, a comparison highlighted by Goodreads friend and literary scholar Robert H. Brinkmeyer Jr.
"He was the kind of man who tries by any means – weight lifting, diet, exercise, self-help manuals from taxidermy to modern art – to hold on to his body and mind and improve them, to rise about time. And yet he was also the first to take a chance, as though the burden of his own laborious immortality were too heavy to bear, and he wanted to get out of it by means of an accident, or what would appear to others to be an accident.”
Here Ed describes his friend Lewis. As soon as the four boys hit rural Georgia, Ed gets a taste of the challenges Lewis has taken on for Drew, Bobby and himself. Drew playing music with the banjo boy, their dealings with the brothers they hire to drive their cars back down to town, their tussles with the wild river – everything turns out to be mere prelude to that violent encounter with two hillbillies.
As you read these opening pages, you could ask yourself if you would join Lewis on such a river excursion. Being a city guy myself, I have to tell you that I would not: as an adult, my adventures are taken either through literature and the arts or as an inner spiritual journey by means of meditation and yoga.
"I suddenly felt like George Holley, my old Braque man, must have felt when he worked for us, saying to himself in any way he could, day after day, I am with you but not of you."
Ed is brutally honest with himself: he admits he is very much with the graphic design work he does, that he doesn't have any artistic ambition beyond merely doing the job, that he wants nothing more than to slide through life without undue friction.
But then it happens for Ed: one day at the office he catches sight of the gold in the eye of a young female model his studio is photographing for an ad. All of a sudden Ed realizes his life is one unending sea of inconsequential happenings and he'll never move beyond the colorless borders of his own boredom. Ed flashes on the possibility of another life, a deliverance. How? That thrilling trip up river with Lewis.
"Funny thing about up yonder. The whole thing's different. I mean the whole way of taking life and the terms you take it on."
Again, these are the words of Lewis when Ed asks about what they're getting themselves into. Lewis goes on to explain that not only does Ed not know about the North Georgia rural life but he doesn't want to know anything about it. Ominous, ominous - the life of the hillbillies is not only drastically different but their rural lifestyle is so diametrically opposed to his suburban comfort, fancy house, luxury car, TV and secure company job that he will be seen as the enemy.
"But I believe in survival. All kinds. Every time I come up here, I believe in it more. You know, with all the so-called modern conveniences, a man can still fall down."
Once again, the words of Lewis, this time as he articulates his philosophy of life. According to Lewis, our time on this Earth all boils down to survival - how we're going to save ourselves when all we have to rely on is our bodies and our own inner strength.
Ed retorts that all of what Lewis said here is the making of a fantasy life. Lewis replies in turn: "That's all anybody has got. It depends on how strong your fantasy is, and whether you really - really - in your own mind, fit into your own fantasy, whether you measure up to what you've fantasized. i don't know what yours is, but I'll bet you don't come up to it."
Does this statement, this question, serve as a stand-in for what author James Dickey would like to ask us as we live our own lives? If so, that's one of the ultimate questions - do we really and truly measure up to our own vision of ourselves and our vision of the world? Are we willing to put our vision to the test? If so, how much risk, how much danger are we willing to undergo?
Question to keep in mind as we read this timeless classic.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Deliverance.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
January 26, 2022
–
Started Reading
January 26, 2022
– Shelved
January 29, 2022
–
Finished Reading
January 9, 2025
– Shelved as:
favorite-books
Comments Showing 1-48 of 48 (48 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Gary
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jan 29, 2022 01:00PM
Excellent!
reply
|
flag
Very thoughtful review of this great novel. The whole issue of fantasy you raise I think is crucial, and particularly concerning the ending--what fantasies do Ed and Lewis now hold, now that they each have killed a man and have reentered "civilized" life as killers if not murderers? I think the ending is deeply complex and ironic. I'd also add that I think Drew is crucial in all this, the voice of reason and sanity and the only one who is able bond with the backwoods people. He brings a guitar into the wilderness while Ed and Lewis bring weapons. Drew has to die if Ed and Lewis will be able to live their fantasy that they bear no responsibility for their actions on the river.
Bob wrote: "Very thoughtful review of this great novel. The whole issue of fantasy you raise I think is crucial, and particularly concerning the ending--what fantasies do Ed and Lewis now hold, now that they e..."Wow! Those are surely key questions.
I suspect Lewis anticipated such a conflict with the rural Georgia folk. I also sense that not only did Lewis shoot that guy in the back but he enjoyed doing it. How different is his killing from all the killing of Native Americans (both directly and indirectly by killing their food supply - Buffalo) in the name of manifest destiny?
Recall Lewis asking the boys if they thought the two hillbillies would kill them after having their way sexually with them. If I recall, Ed answers 'yes.' So, in this way, in the minds of Lewis, Bobby and Ed, Lewis' killing is justified. However, Drew objects but is overruled.
And when Drew dies, they immediately think it is murder - predictable when killing is seen as THE answer to problems.
Great question - what will Lewis and Bobby and Ed think and how will they live their lives in the years to come. One thing's for sure - no time with lawyers, no time in court, no time in jail. Very important for people who want to continue their comfortable suburban lifestyle.
Terrific review and contemplations on that book, Glenn. Yes, a book with a severe impact and a movie you never forget. Saw it perhaps 5 times over the years and you can still feel your blood running cold. As Bob notes in his message above, the ending gives you a very creepy feeling, those survivors sitting there at a table with a simple rural family who are chatting away about nothing at all.
Hanneke wrote: "Terrific review and contemplations on that book, Glenn. Yes, a book with a severe impact and a movie you never forget. Saw it perhaps 5 times over the years and you can still feel your blood runnin..."Thanks, Hanneke. Bullseye - a tale with an eerie, unforgettable ending.
Note: Back when I was 38 and working in the commercial reinsurance industry, I was asked if I wanted to join a bunch of guys to go duck hunting. Of course, I told them 'no.' I told the manager of the department he must be nuts if he thinks he could get me out duck hunting with a bunch of company men armed with real bullets and real guns. I can just imagine the message to my wife - so sorry, Mrs. Russell but Glenn was killed in a hunting accident. Meanwhile, the guys think my death was no great loss - just a goofball, an oddball who loves books and the arts. No a REAL company guy. One of the happiest days of my life when I made a career switch to publishing. A career change that worked out so well, worked out far beyond my fondest dreams.
I certainly love ya'll's discussion here. Everyone has brought in some nice insight on this terrific novel. I agree with Glenn that Lewis probably came into the wilderness wanting such a confrontation, and that he did enjoy it. He needed it to happen so he could feel like a "real man". Same with the killing of Indians connection. Probably not much different. If you've read anything about Dickey's personal life, I believe you can see Lewis there, and Dickey fulfilled that part of himself through his writing and archery.
I find that comment on the connection between the displacement of those north Georgia locals and the shifting of the Indian population in the quest for manifest destiny very interesting Glenn. The problem is always the unfettered use (abuse) of power. A universal problem, if we'd all band together. The whole notion of civilisation here is also a fascinating one, we are one step away from our primal emotions, fears and fight or flight instincts.
Nick wrote: "I find that comment on the connection between the displacement of those north Georgia locals and the shifting of the Indian population in the quest for manifest destiny very interesting Glenn. The ..."What you note about power, civilization and closeness to our primal nature has the undeniable ring of truth.
This past year I listened to a number of Great Course lectures about the Middle Ages. One thing the historians emphasized: 'civilization' is entirely a mental construct. To keep it going the way it goes, so much depends on the rule of the those in power. An ongoing struggle at that time: the power of the secular rulers versus the power of the church.
The world of 12th and 13 century Europe appeared so solid but when famine hit in the early 14th century followed by plague around 1348, the whole structure of society came apart and had to be formed anew. One key element: the shifting of power, especially the increased power of those who still lived and could work the land.
HBalikov wrote: "Nicely captured, Glenn. Thanks!"Thanks, H. And to think, this was James Dickey's first novel. Remarkable.
Glenn wrote: "HBalikov wrote: "Nicely captured, Glenn. Thanks!"Thanks, H. And to think, this was James Dickey's first novel. Remarkable."
And he ways no "one book wonder!"
Glenn wrote: "Nick wrote: "I find that comment on the connection between the displacement of those north Georgia locals and the shifting of the Indian population in the quest for manifest destiny very interestin..."I'd say from my recent reading we are in a power battle between those who want to uphold liberal democratic values and those who don't, with a looming climate crisis on the horizon. Sound familiar?
Interesting where open discussions on books lead us sometimes. Thanks for being on the open team, Glenn.
Nick wrote: "I find that comment on the connection between the displacement of those north Georgia locals and the shifting of the Indian population in the quest for manifest destiny very interesting Glenn. The ..."Nick, you just summed up a big chunk of Dickey's poetry. "...we are one step away from our primal emotions,...instincts". That theme runs all through his poetry and other novels.
Nick wrote: "Glenn wrote: "Nick wrote: "I find that comment on the connection between the displacement of those north Georgia locals and the shifting of the Indian population in the quest for manifest destiny v..."It does sound familiar! We'll see fairly quickly how long liberal democratic values can hold up again the concentration of wealth and power, especially corporate power and influence.
Lewis's mentality sounds like a dangerous reflection of an attitude that has taken deep hold - or at least been manifest more openly - in recent years. It's frankly scary how many (usually) men have embraced a mythos that enshrines the justification of violence as a way to resolve issues. It's always been with us, but the voices seem more ubiquitous and louder as of late.
Gary wrote: "Nick wrote: "I find that comment on the connection between the displacement of those north Georgia locals and the shifting of the Indian population in the quest for manifest destiny very interestin..."Cheers, Gary, it's a very interesting theme, and as I grow older, I realise more and more how so much of what we hold onto is a veneer. Yet we still need to hold onto it.
Forrest wrote: "Lewis's mentality sounds like a dangerous reflection of an attitude that has taken deep hold - or at least been manifest more openly - in recent years. It's frankly scary how many (usually) men hav..."Lewis' mentality is dangerous. As I understand, the gun sales in the country is growing exponentially by the week.
Glenn wrote: "Nick wrote: "Glenn wrote: "Nick wrote: "I find that comment on the connection between the displacement of those north Georgia locals and the shifting of the Indian population in the quest for manif..."I finished a book last week called How to be a Liberal by Ian Dunt. I don't normally read books like that. But liberalism is the philosophical and political milieu I was born into. Given the shifts in power as you say, it's a subject that's unwittingly been on my mind for a few years.
Cheers to you, Nick. To live in civilization, it seems we have to suppress our deeper instincts, whatever they may be. The curse of sin? I guess that's my definition of primal emotions. There's a thin layer separating us from those instincts. How we keep them from destroying ourselves and others is a fascinating subject.
I finished a book last week called How to be a Liberal by Ian Dunt. I don't normally read books like that.One huge issue we face currently in this country: a smaller and smaller percent of the population read books. As Goodreads friend Ian noted in his years of teaching adult reading: the failure of education is teaching students the mechanics of reading without teaching them the LOVE of reading. Without the experience of reading after one leaves school, one loses the ability to read and one becomes semi-illiterate.
Glenn wrote: "I finished a book last week called How to be a Liberal by Ian Dunt. I don't normally read books like that.One huge issue we face currently in this country: a smaller and smaller percent of the po..."
Yes, my observation over a couple of decades and yes watching the teaching of reading while my kids were at school would suggest something similar. There are more educated people, professionals in all sorts of new areas where skills are needed. But most are technical. Reading is now a technical function. Yet, interestingly novel publishing grows exponentially. But few are challenging or interesting. I would suggest that the close reading of texts and the ability to read deeply (I know that sounds like a value judgement but it was what I was taught as an undergraduate studying literature et al) is disappearing. IF love of reading can produce good thinking then I'm all for it, but it also needs some educational input and at least wider appreciation by society. So I see a decline whenever I go into bookshop and look at all the newbie novels and read a page or two. I can already tell how little reading informs most of the books I pick up and browse. Ach, I feel depressed.
Glenn wrote: "I finished a book last week called How to be a Liberal by Ian Dunt. I don't normally read books like that.One huge issue we face currently in this country: a smaller and smaller percent of the po..."
I can't even imagine not reading books. Really, the love of books has been my whole life. My grandfather and great grandfather couldn't read at all, yet they were two of the finest men I've ever known. Strange to me how they could function and provide so well for their families. My uncle quit school in the 10th grade. He once told me that he'd never read an entire book. That just blew my mind. Can't relate to it at all. Now, with all the dumbing down of our education system, and lack of people with a love of reading and learning, I think we're seeing the results of that in our present leaders, and teachers, and doctors, and...
Well, our civilization seems to be crumbling around us.
Gary wrote: "Cheers to you, Nick. To live in civilization, it seems we have to suppress our deeper instincts, whatever they may be. The curse of sin? I guess that's my definition of primal emotions. There's a ..."
Funny, though, we still need all those social protocols and niceties to keep us all from complete mayhem. Its usually not based on much, but we keep trying and pulling it together as well as we can.
IF love of reading can produce good thinking then I'm all for it, but it also needs some educational input and at least wider appreciation by society.Agreed! Unfortunately for many in power the caliber of education you're alluding to is the dreaded enemy.
You can still go into an actual bookstore? Lucky you! I haven't seen one in some time.
Gary said I can't even imagine not reading books. Really, the love of books has been my whole life.A glimmer of light: My 14-year-old grandson Dylan enjoyed reading The Count of Monte Cristo this past summer. I jumped for joy - another avid reader!
You can still go into an actual bookstore? Lucky you! I haven't seen one in some time. Still in covid restrictions or self isolating?
I have braved it recently, but I run out quickly. My experiences refer to a few years ago when I would go in often. But pre-covid bookshops became tedious places full of bright covers and instant success print runs for shiny happy people and bright young things reading mirror images of themselves in print.
I am lucky to have the one little literature focused second hand bookshop left in the western world nearby. Though I haven't been in for a year.
Unfortunately for many in power the caliber of education you're alluding to is the dreaded enemy. Our government recently reviewed its academic grants away from liberal arts areas and also charged a higher fee for arts undergraduate courses. Ach, depressed evermore
Fabulous review Glenn. This one stuck with me in a haunting type way, both film and book. You capture the essence of this experience.
Still in covid restrictions or self isolating? ------ Somewhat but the important point is there aren't any bookstores on the edge of Philly where I live. Even in pre-COVID days nearly all the Philly bookstores closed. Borders and B&N had huge bookstores here. No more.
Franky wrote: "Fabulous review Glenn. This one stuck with me in a haunting type way, both film and book. You capture the essence of this experience."Thanks, Franky. Yes, I recall reading your fine review of this classic.
Glenn wrote: "Gary said I can't even imagine not reading books. Really, the love of books has been my whole life.A glimmer of light: My 14-year-old grandson Dylan enjoyed reading The Count of Monte Cristo this..."
Yay!!!!!
Nick wrote: "Gary wrote: "Cheers to you, Nick. To live in civilization, it seems we have to suppress our deeper instincts, whatever they may be. The curse of sin? I guess that's my definition of primal emotion..."
Yep, it's a fine balance, and a thin veil between peace and chaos, and we must do the best we can.
Excellent review, Glenn. I've never read this, or seen the movie - but it is easily brings to mind the beginning notes to 'Dueling Banjos' whenever I see or hear Deliverance mentioned. As for reading, I learned to read years before beginning school, and learned to appreciate the joys of reading from my grandfather.
Cheri wrote: "Excellent review, Glenn. I've never read this, or seen the movie - but it is easily brings to mind the beginning notes to 'Dueling Banjos' whenever I see or hear Deliverance mentioned.Thanks, Cheri. I can't include a link to that scene where one of the suburban guys, Drew, gets out his guitar and starts playing and is soon joined by the hillbilly banjo boy but it's one of the most powerful scenes in all of film. I've watched it many times (generally, I'm not a moviegoer and never have been).
You are very fortunately to have been introduced to the joys of reading at any early age by a loving Grandmother.
My dad was a factory worker and we lived in a small New Jersey shore town. We had some books in the house but I spent most of my boyhood outside, swimming, diving, surfing and playing team sports. When I took my first philosophy course as a freshman in college, it was as if my world expanded tenfold, as if I escaped the chains in Plato's cave and finally experienced the fullness of what life could be. Right then I began my journey as a voracious reader.
Outstanding review as usual Glenn. I saw this movie many years ago. Being young, I was horrified by some of the content. I have now, in my later years find that I want to read it and have this moment added it. BTW, I really enjoyed the YouTube interview you did with Josh. Very informative.
Glenda wrote: "Outstanding review as usual Glenn. I saw this movie many years ago. Being young, I was horrified by some of the content. I have now, in my later years find that I want to read it and have this mome..."Thanks, Glenda. Glad my review has prompted you to read this classic novel. I listened to the audio book before writing my review - every single chapter heightened drama. Intense, intense - and the ending held a special power this time around. Perhaps because I'm a bit older.
And thanks so much for watching the YouTube video. So few interviews of reviewers talking about their book reviews. I wanted to hit several points I judged important.
Michael wrote: "Fantastic review of a fantastic book! I absolutely loved this novel."Thanks, Michael. Reading Deliverance is like taking a trip down white water rapids - never a dull moment no matter how many times you do it. Goodreads friend/literary scholar Robert H. Brinkmeyer Jr told me he's read the novel dozens and dozens of time and each time he discovers something new. For me, listening to the audiobook adds yet again another dimension.
Great review got so much more out of your review than the movie I mostly remember the horrendous scene and to avoid red neck country.
John wrote: "Great review got so much more out of your review than the movie I mostly remember the horrendous scene and to avoid red neck country."Thanks, John! So glad my review was helpful.
Fantastic review Glenn. I haven’t read this book but did see the movie. Absolutely scared the life out of me. I was very young. Maybe it wouldn’t have that effect now but reading your review, it probably would.
Glenda wrote: "Fantastic review Glenn. I haven’t read this book but did see the movie. Absolutely scared the life out of me. I was very young. Maybe it wouldn’t have that effect now but reading your review, it pr..."Thanks, Glenda. I agree - watching the movie again or reading the novel will surely be a powerful, almost overwhelming, experience. James Dickey's tale is as intense as it can get.




