Dana's Reviews > The Salt Grows Heavy
The Salt Grows Heavy
by
by
Dana's review
bookshelves: 2023-reads, from-the-library, pride-readathon-2023, genre-fantasy, genre-horror, queer-lit, novella, ebook-digital
Jun 18, 2023
bookshelves: 2023-reads, from-the-library, pride-readathon-2023, genre-fantasy, genre-horror, queer-lit, novella, ebook-digital
In lieu of a review, I'll just put up some quotes.
"The foundation, at a careless look, could pass for bones, the door for a mouth, the chimney a finger crooked at the sky, or at a wife who would not be a savior." - what does that mean?
"The plague doctor tasks themself with everything else: defenses, the replenishment of our rations, the ablutions of my mount." - the what of your what?
"They laugh, the sound refracted by keratin." - huh
"The two of us move in simpatico, keeping time with each other, always parallel, dark and light and the smell of plasma from my clandestine repast cooling on my fingertips." - if this is romance, I don't want it
"His mask is a drowned man’s blue, and his gaze, restored somehow, whole again, is the color of medusae washed to shore, all turgid transparence and shuddering villi." - WHAT COLOR IS IT CASSANDRA I DON'T KNOW WHAT THAT MEANS
"...and they laugh like they’re proletariat-raised, full of brashness." - idk I just found that funny af lol, only the working class knows how to have proper fun
"The door is slammed open. The children barge in. I join the mass of bodies, craning a look around their shoulders. The antumbra reveals little: ..." - I had to Google antumbra and even then, it didn't make sense. The light you're describing is NOT an antumbra
"To my surprise, no one has come to investigate the wailing, not even at its inchoate apex." - just say incomplete or beginning, wtf is with inchoate
"It piles higher as I walk, ankle-length first, then rising to the height of my thighs." - serious question, the main character is a mermaid - does she have ankles??
We get it, Cassandra, you use thesaurus.com. I'm not bothered by more flowery writing, but come on, it's a touch too much. I also don't know how the plot felt like it meandered even though the novella was so short. The premise sounds dope, but this is the second time Khaw's execution failed for me. The chapter about the mermaid's captivity was by far the coolest and most interesting - why couldn't the novella have been about this instead of a random village of three guys killing children? If you include a cool mermaid, why not REALLY write about her?? I think the decision to instead let the story be about this largely unrelated incident was bizarre.
Since I did like Khaw's take on mermaids and the plague doctor, I'm giving it two stars. I wanna end with the one quote I found really beautiful to mourn what could've been: (view spoiler)
"The foundation, at a careless look, could pass for bones, the door for a mouth, the chimney a finger crooked at the sky, or at a wife who would not be a savior." - what does that mean?
"The plague doctor tasks themself with everything else: defenses, the replenishment of our rations, the ablutions of my mount." - the what of your what?
"They laugh, the sound refracted by keratin." - huh
"The two of us move in simpatico, keeping time with each other, always parallel, dark and light and the smell of plasma from my clandestine repast cooling on my fingertips." - if this is romance, I don't want it
"His mask is a drowned man’s blue, and his gaze, restored somehow, whole again, is the color of medusae washed to shore, all turgid transparence and shuddering villi." - WHAT COLOR IS IT CASSANDRA I DON'T KNOW WHAT THAT MEANS
"...and they laugh like they’re proletariat-raised, full of brashness." - idk I just found that funny af lol, only the working class knows how to have proper fun
"The door is slammed open. The children barge in. I join the mass of bodies, craning a look around their shoulders. The antumbra reveals little: ..." - I had to Google antumbra and even then, it didn't make sense. The light you're describing is NOT an antumbra
"To my surprise, no one has come to investigate the wailing, not even at its inchoate apex." - just say incomplete or beginning, wtf is with inchoate
"It piles higher as I walk, ankle-length first, then rising to the height of my thighs." - serious question, the main character is a mermaid - does she have ankles??
We get it, Cassandra, you use thesaurus.com. I'm not bothered by more flowery writing, but come on, it's a touch too much. I also don't know how the plot felt like it meandered even though the novella was so short. The premise sounds dope, but this is the second time Khaw's execution failed for me. The chapter about the mermaid's captivity was by far the coolest and most interesting - why couldn't the novella have been about this instead of a random village of three guys killing children? If you include a cool mermaid, why not REALLY write about her?? I think the decision to instead let the story be about this largely unrelated incident was bizarre.
Since I did like Khaw's take on mermaids and the plague doctor, I'm giving it two stars. I wanna end with the one quote I found really beautiful to mourn what could've been: (view spoiler)
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Salt Grows Heavy.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
June 16, 2023
–
Started Reading
June 16, 2023
– Shelved
June 16, 2023
– Shelved as:
2023-reads
June 16, 2023
– Shelved as:
from-the-library
June 18, 2023
–
Finished Reading
June 23, 2023
– Shelved as:
pride-readathon-2023
July 9, 2023
– Shelved as:
genre-fantasy
July 9, 2023
– Shelved as:
genre-horror
January 8, 2024
– Shelved as:
queer-lit
August 12, 2025
– Shelved as:
novella
September 26, 2025
– Shelved as:
ebook-digital
Comments Showing 1-18 of 18 (18 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Frackie
(new)
-
added it
Jun 18, 2023 12:33PM
This review had NO right being this funny
reply
|
flag
Frackie wrote: "This review had NO right being this funny"Hahaha glad you liked it, it was very fun to write!
J wrote: "LMAO i love this, tragic it’s not a better book cuz the cover slaps so hard 😔"Right?! I LOVE the cover art, it's stunning. I previously read another book by Khaw and it feels like they value prose over plot and are afraid to go simpler with the wording, even though their writing can be beautiful when they restrain themselves a little bit. I think their style would work much better for poetry than for novellas.
(no idea how to reply to comments, whoops) Oooof, that's a shame! Perhaps they'll change in the future 🤞🏼
I'm only half way through so far, but I think I would have finished the book already if I hadn't needed to pause twice per page to look at the definition of a word I have never seen in my entire life.
At one point she used the word “victuals”. Do you know what that means? It means food. Fucking food.
Maddie Reads Thrills & Chills wrote: "Thank you for this review. It's hilarious and made my day "Oh thank you, so happy to hear that!
Shawn wrote: "At one point she used the word “victuals”. Do you know what that means? It means food. Fucking food."
Gonna start asking for "the tome of the victuals" instead of the menu
Natalie wrote: "I'm only half way through so far, but I think I would have finished the book already if I hadn't needed to pause twice per page to look at the definition of a word I have never seen in my entire life."
Yeah, English isn't my first language but I can usually get by easily without having to look up words. This was a literal vocab test
Book Dragon wrote: "Sigh, I totally agree. I was so excited for this book and it fell really flat for me."
You and me both. At least we're together in our suffering 🤝
(sorry for the late reply, hadn't looked at the comments in a while)
i saw several reviews talking about the thesaurus vocabulary and i was skeptical that it could be THAT bad, so i kept scrolling until someone included examples… wow… that’s bad. some might even say its pejorative.
the way they kept using words in a sense that was JUST SLIGHTLY wrong or otherwise inappropriate for the context and made it clear they weren't familiar with the word itself was so annoying. its potent sapidity?? oh my god it was really tasty?? it was really so tasty it made you think of being a baby in the womb? please! how!
Thank you for this review. I didn’t highlight some of the odd uses of language in this like I should have. I wanted to talk to my partner about it and now I can show him this review. To to Nore’s point, there was something slightly off about how she used some of those words.
This review makes me want to read the book because it seems to have actually good writing. Learn to read a dictionary if you don’t get it.
No wrote: "This review makes me want to read the book because it seems to have actually good writing. Learn to read a dictionary if you don’t get it."You made a throwaway account just to comment THIS? Cassandra, is it you?





