Hoda's Reviews > Winter Garden

Winter Garden by Kristin Hannah
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
64251493
's review

liked it

“To lose love is a terrible thing,But to turn away from it is unbearable. Will you spend the rest of your life replaying it in your head? Wondering if you walked away too soon or too easily? Or if you’ll ever love anyone that deeply again?”

Honestly i had a hard time rating this. If i could,i would rate the first half 50% 1.5 stars and the second 50% 5 stars.i feel like 3 stars is pretty decent so…The first half was so painfully boring i wanted to dnf it so freaking bad. the only thing that kept me going was that i wanted to know Vera story. And It was worth the suffering 💔

“Every choice changed the road you were on and it was too easy to end up going in the wrong direction.”

Tbh I couldn’t careless about Meredith or Nina lives. Both of them annoyed the hell out of me. They gave me a headache, made me wish I didn’t pick this up. So selfish and self centered. Yes i felt bad for them. Yes their grief broke my heart and made me cry. But that was it. I hated the way they treated their men. I know they’re grieving and in pain but that’s not an excuse to hurt other people feeling!! It was down right cruel the way Meredith treated jiff my heart broke for him 💔 The only thing i loved about them was their relationship with their father 🥹 it was so heartwarming and made my heart so happy 💗

“She will remember how she told them what she hadn’t known before: that war is about fire and fear and bodies lying in ditches by the side of the road.”

vera story 🥹❤️‍🩹 cried so hard I couldn’t see the pages. It’s one of the most heartbreaking. Beautiful stories i’ve ever read. Anya story shows you the results of war and how unfair and inhuman and disgusting these results can be. It also shows you how strong women are and what are they willing to do and to sacrifice for their children and their loved ones.My heart is broken, my soul is destroyed, my eyes are bloodshot. Anya story will live with me forever🥲❤️‍🩹the epilogue was so beautiful i want to cry 😭

“I think maybe love can just . . . dissolve.”
“No, it does not,” her mother said.
“So how do—”
“You hang on,” her mother said. “Until your hands are bleeding, and still you do not let go.”


Vera and Sasha: everything happened so fast for me she fall in love with him the first time they met?which made no sense to me. And then I blinked and they were married. I wanted more interaction between them so i can be invested in their relationship but sadly there wasn’t they only talked like 6 or 7 times in the book i counted them. And i know this is a women fiction not romance but still i wanted more then this.

“it hurts too much to see your own pain reflected in another woman’s eyes.”

I read this because it was said that it’s her best work but for me Nightingale is her best work it was way than this better in my opinion. It’s one of the best books i’ve even read i still can’t stop thinking about it and I don’t think i’ll ever stop 🥲💗

Quotes

“Young has nothing to do with love. A woman can be a girl and still know her own heart.”

“You carried your pain with you in life. There was no outrunning it. ”

“life—and love—can be gone any second. When you had it, you needed to hang on with all your strength and savor every second.”

“Nina knew the power of black and white images. Sometimes a thing was its truest self when the colors were stripped away.”

“she learned something new, something she hadn’t known before: sex could mean many things; one of them was good-bye.”
108 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Winter Garden.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 27, 2023 – Shelved as: to-read
September 27, 2023 – Shelved
October 22, 2023 – Started Reading
October 24, 2023 –
17.0% " “He is my home,” her mother said, shaking her head. “How will I live without him?”

🥲💔😭"
October 24, 2023 –
29.0% "I hate Nina for leaving meredith alone to handle all of this. It’s so selfish"
October 25, 2023 –
53.0% "I’m bored 🥲🥱"
October 25, 2023 –
60.0% " “And when he took her in his arms and made love to her again, she learned something new, something she hadn’t known before: sex could mean many things; one of them was good-bye.”

Ugh both sisters deserves to be single for the rest if their damn lives ✋🏻 i hate the way they treating their men 😔 i’d take them 🫂❤️‍🩹"
October 26, 2023 –
64.0% " “She is trying to be grownup; it is heartbreaking in one so young. At five, she should be playing with dolls, not standing in lines to leave her home.”

The pain is literally unbearable 💔 rubbing my chest to ease the pain 😭😭"
October 27, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 67 (67 new)


‎‧₊˚✿bri✿˚₊‧ happy reading ml💕


message 2: by len ❀ (new)

len ❀ i’ve been meaning to read her book the nightingale for years now!! 😭 hope you enjoy this! 🤍


message 3: by daniella (new)

daniella happy reading 🩷


message 4: by lulu (new) - added it

lulu omgg i really wanna read this one i cant wait for your thoughts!! hope you love it bestie 💗


message 5: by shanayaa (new)

shanayaa Hope you enjoy it!!


Hoda @bri thank u bbe!!<333


Hoda @elena please read it!! It’s so good one of my favorite 🥹💗 thank u 💗


Hoda @daniella thank u gorgeous 💗


kendyl ʚ♡⃛ɞ (hiatus) happy reading baeeeee<3


message 10: by bruna (new)

bruna happy reading babes 💞


message 11: by Emma (new) - added it

Emma Skapetis Happy reading💕. I remember my mum reading it but I haven't read this book by this author.


message 12: by Sabrina (new)

Sabrina Oh noo 😣 happy reading ml 🫂 you just love pain don’t you lol but I get it. I hope you love this one just as much as the other book <3


message 13: by mara (new) - added it

mara i got this book recently i cant wait to read it 😫 hope you love it babesss💗💗


message 14: by annie (new)

annie Happy reading! 💕💕


tanveer ⋆。✧ happy reading love 💘🫶🏼


message 16: by Hoda (new) - rated it 3 stars

Hoda @mitra thank u sm bestie 💗


message 17: by Hoda (new) - rated it 3 stars

Hoda @shanayaa thank u love🫶🏻🫶🏻


message 18: by mors (new)

mors Aww hope you love it! ❤️


message 19: by buket (new)

buket i agree with not caring about nina&meredith but vera😭 she went through so much💔 glad you enjoyed the second part <33


message 20: by ingrid ₊ (new)

ingrid ₊ im soo glad to see that the other half picked up and u adored it, hoda! u pushed through and it payed off, proud of u. vera sounds lovely, u are lovely, this review is lovely


kendyl ʚ♡⃛ɞ (hiatus) omg omg this sounds so emotional! *immediately adds to tbr* stunning review my pretty angel🥹🫶🏼i’m glad the second half of the book got better<3


message 22: by annie (new)

annie I'm all for HEA but tbh sad quotes hit too hard and I keep replaying them in my head 😭 this first quote is good lol! meredith and Nina's character sounds like NESTA sorry whahs but yeah tbh I don't understand this concept in books of HURTING OTHERS BECAUSE YOU'RE HURT because I don't LIKE this AT all??? well this story feels like yk slow at first and rushed at the other half! 3 is pretty decent rating for what you described! 💕 Hope you get a better read next time!


message 23: by Hoda (new) - rated it 3 stars

Hoda @lulu i did love half of it 🥹💗 thank u bbe🫶🏻


message 24: by Hoda (new) - rated it 3 stars

Hoda @shanayaa thank u love 💗


message 25: by Hoda (new) - rated it 3 stars

Hoda @kendyl thank u bestie 💗


message 26: by Hoda (new) - rated it 3 stars

Hoda @emma ahh it’s was good but not as good as nightingale if you’re going to start reading books by her I highly recommend to start with nightingale 💗


message 27: by Hoda (new) - rated it 3 stars

Hoda @burna thank u love 💗


Imme [trying to crawl out of hiatus] van Gorp Aww this honestly sounds like such a mixed bag! A boring beginning? Two insufferable heroines? One amazing heroine, but with a shallow romance? Well-portrayed grief? Definitely mixed haha


message 29: by SK (new)

SK I thought it will be a two star read based on your initial updates lmao but am glad you pushed through and it ended up being okayish. Hope your next read is a definite 5 star 🥰🥰


message 30: by brooke (hiatus) (new)

brooke (hiatus) this sounds like an unbearably tragic and moving story. i’m so glad the story picked up in the second half and got good! amazing review bb 🩷


message 31: by Hoda (new) - rated it 3 stars

Hoda @sabrina sad books >>>>> thank u bbe 💗


message 32: by Hoda (new) - rated it 3 stars

Hoda @emara I didn’t love it but I enjoyed it thank u bbe💗


message 33: by Hoda (new) - rated it 3 stars

Hoda @anum thank u love💗


message 34: by Hoda (new) - rated it 3 stars

Hoda @tanveer thank u ml💗


message 35: by Hoda (new) - rated it 3 stars

Hoda @morsal i did enjoy it thank u beautiful 💗


message 36: by len ❀ (new)

len ❀ i think the 3 stars is fine. first half wasn’t good, second half was a winner, and a rating of 3-stars in my eyes evens it out lol. i’m glad vera’s story was worth it for you at least. lovely review, hoda! 💖


message 37: by aeryn (new)

aeryn rose hoda i could cry i love this review 🥹 this sounds like a heart warmer and a heartbreaker at the same time 🩷


message 38: by Hoda (new) - rated it 3 stars

Hoda @buket yess vera story literally carried the book. Yes omg she went through a-lot i feel like crying again 😭 thank u love💗


message 39: by Hoda (new) - rated it 3 stars

Hoda @rowan aww stop you’re so cute ily 💗 omg yes try to push through the first half till you get to Vera story because it’s so worth reading 🥹💗 thank u love🫶🏻🫶🏻


message 40: by youssra (new)

youssra This sounds so emotional🥹 wonderful review bb, I’m glad you still got to enjoy the second half💗


message 41: by mors (new)

mors Omgg this books sounds so heart warming and emotional. Amazing review as always, my beautiful girl! 💕


message 42: by tanya (new)

tanya ok but why haven't i seen any of your reviews in ages???
anyway, the quotes!!! i can practically feel the heartbreak 😭 love the review, gorgeous girl <33


message 43: by Sabrina (new)

Sabrina it’s so disappointing when you enjoy the last half and not the first and vice versa. Vera and Anya sound like this is worth reading for 🥺 so heartfelt and heartbreaking. those quotes tho 🤌🏼 I’m glad you mostly enjoyed this even though it wasn’t nearly as good as the nightingale and I know you loved that 🥲 beautiful review ml 🩷


message 44: by mara (new) - added it

mara i skimmed thru the first few chapters of it and it sounded boring so ima listen to ur review and push this low in my tbr 😭 ugh so sorry you didnt enjoy most of it 😖 such a disappointment but very happy you loveddd vera’s story 💖 the quotes are cute tho, beautiful review babes 😚🤍


message 45: by Gillian (new)

Gillian Lovely review Hoda! 💗 I’m sorry that the first half was disappointing, but I’m glad you loved the second half of the book. Also I love the quotes you chose!


message 46: by Hoda (new) - rated it 3 stars

Hoda @ingrid thank u gorgeous 💗 you’re so sweet 🥹🫂


message 47: by Hoda (new) - rated it 3 stars

Hoda @kendyl ahh yess but try to push through the first 50% because literally nothing important happens and you will get bored 🥱 thank u love 💗


message 48: by Hoda (new) - rated it 3 stars

Hoda @anum will the ending on this book was kind of a happy ending 🥹omg not nesta 😭😭😭they were annoying but not that level of annoying 😭 yess exactly i mean why hurt other and why justify it because you’re in pain. Why make other feel pain because you feel pain ?? I hate that. Yeah i feel like 3 stars is pretty decent too 🫶🏻 thank u my love💗


message 49: by siff ♡ (new)

siff ♡ THE QUOTES ?!💔❤️‍🩹 stopp because this book sounds so beautiful <3 i’m soso happy you ended up enjoying this, despite the first half ! this review made my vision a little blurry ngl 🥹


message 50: by Hoda (new) - rated it 3 stars

Hoda @imme exactly!! But umm it wasn’t bad u know like i would still bang it


« previous 1
back to top