Fionnuala's Reviews > La chute

La chute by Albert Camus
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5498525
's review

bookshelves: read-in-french

Sound is a key element in this book, for the narrator—but especially for the reader.

This short novel is a long monologue on the part of the narrator to an anonymous person he meets in a bar one winter's night in Amsterdam, and with whom he walks the circle of canals close to the docks on succeeding nights, continuing his monologue almost without interruption. We never hear the other person's voice but sometimes we intimate that he might have raised an eyebrow as he listened, or asked a question, because the narrator sometimes responds as if that had been the case. But every time the narrator responded like that, it had happened that I had raised my eyebrows or exclaimed in disbelief at something the narrator had said, so it's clear that the anonymous listener is the reader, enthralled but a little suspicious of the smooth and hypnotic tones of the very loquacious narrator as he walks the ring of canals, and circles the hell of his own existence.

I mentioned sound at the beginning because one of the most hellish aspects of the narrator's existence is the memory of the sound of a body hitting the water on another dark winter's night years before. This 'sound' memory has haunted him since.
The other reason I mentioned 'sound' is because I experienced this book as if it were an audio book. I was reading the words on the page but I was hearing the narrator's voice clearly in my ear. I've never had quite so definite an impression of being a 'listener' as I had while reading the printed words in this book.
And in case I've given the impression that all this might have been a hellish experience, it wasn't. I smiled just as often as I raised my eyebrows because the narrator is a very fine performer—he is a lawyer by trade. A lot of his lines are outright funny but every one of them is entertaining.

And here's another entertaining thing: the title of this book, 'La chute', is translated as 'The Fall' in English, and after I'd added it to my goodreads shelves, I got a notification saying that because I'd read 'La chute', I might also be interested in reading Autumn Nights or Autumn in Paris and several more titles with the word Autumn in them. The narrator would have laughed because his narrative takes him back to a time when he wandered over the bridges of Paris at night—though he never says if it was in the fall...

...........................................
A painting by Jan Van Eyck has a role in the text. It is a panel called 'Les Juges intègres' part of a larger work called 'L'agneau mystique'.


The main figures on horseback are looking at something important in the central panel of the famous polyptique in the cathedral at Gand, but they also seem to be listening very carefully, it seems to me...

…………………………………………
The book I picked up after this one was also about walking along canals and crossing their many bridges, but it was set not in Amsterdam nor in Paris but in Venice, the city so strongly associated in literature with death. However, you'll be relieved to know that it was also quite funny.

……………………………………………
79 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read La chute.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 3, 2024 – Started Reading
May 9, 2024 – Shelved
May 9, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 53 (53 new)


Théo d'Or Also à very camusien book, this one. Your insight too.


message 2: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Thanks, Théo. This very clever book probably deserves a longer and more thorough review but I think what potential readers need to do is to experience it for themselves. No words of mine can explain the power of it. The narrator's voice will stay with me for a long time...


Théo d'Or Now, I guess you discovered why this short novel is " awkward ":)


message 4: by Laysee (new)

Laysee You are obviously a very good listener, Fionnuala. The narrator could not have had better company. Terrific review.


message 5: by Nick (new)

Nick Grammos I agree with you it does have a distinct narrator's voice, that even comes across in English. Though I read this again a few years ago because the narrative device is used often by contemporary writers; and I confess I found it a little dull, or dulled over time, I can't tell which. The narrator speaking to someone directly has the characteristic of a clean narrative form without affectation, though we all know its artifice when we think about it.


message 6: by Ken (new)

Ken Thought I'd read this, but no. Just L'Etranger and some essays and the wonderful short story "The Guest." I like books predicated on imagery OTHER than sight, sight, sight. They can be a sight better, when done right.


message 7: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Théo d'Or wrote: "Now, I guess you discovered why this short novel is " awkward ":)"

Is it thought to be awkward? I didn't find it so—though you may laugh at me for missing that. In fact, I thought the narration was really well done!
Here's a humorous quote I marked which is apt in this case. Speaking about women, the narrator says:
"Nos amies, en effet, ont ceci de commun avec Bonaparte qu'elles pensent toujours réussir là où tout le monde a échoué."


message 8: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Laysee wrote: "You are obviously a very good listener, Fionnuala. The narrator could not have had better company. Terrific review."

Thanks, Laysee. It surprised me how good a listener I was! Especially because the narrator feels kind of smarmy at the beginning, and then the more he talks, the less likable he becomes, and it could all have ended badly. But the more I listened, the more interested I became in what he had to say, even if I didn't always like what he was telling me. So curious.


Théo d'Or Haha ! It was a référence to your comment from my review of " La Chute ", where you expressed your curiosity to find out why I found this novel " awkward ".
Ah, et l'éternel optimisme
de nos amies et leur ferme conviction que, contrairement à tous les autres mortels, elles réussiront du premier coup...Elle partagent avec Bonaparte non seulement un amour pour les chapeaux imposants, mais aussi cette confiance
inébranlable dans la victoire contre toute attente.


message 10: by Jeroen (new)

Jeroen Vandenbossche A great review Fionnuala! It brought back fond memories of a book I absolutely loved in my late teens. Can I ask which funny book about Venice you are reading now? As for the GR algorithm, it continues to amaze me how poor its recommendations actually are. Aftet I read Sartre little biography on Mallarmé, it was suggested to me that I might also like a book about the Rolling Stones.🤔 Luckily I take my recommendations from friends, colleagues and people like you. Have a nice day!


message 11: by Katia (new)

Katia N It has to be a great experience, Fionnuala! And as usual, you've made me want to drop everything and go and read Camus. I have not read much of him even in my teens. But what I've read has left a great impression on me. I've re-read L'Estranger recently and I gained a lot from being "grown up":-) So I want to come back to him properly. It is interesting this book has got such a distinctive voice you "heard" this man. I do not think I've ever experienced something similar. But sometimes I "hear" the voices of the characters after I've finished reading. And they do not always say what they were saying in the book:-) I am so glad you rely on your own associations instead of the algorithm:-) Though I wonder where it would take me if I follow for some time for a sake of experiment, but i am not sure it worth it:-)


message 12: by Ilse (new) - added it

Ilse Listening to you, I am tempted to listen to that chatty narrator as well, Fionnuala - even if I am already so lucky to be able to listen to loquacious lawyers (is this a tautology :)?) quite often. The bar and the monologue remind me of the book of Kamel Douad already mentioned when you were re-reading L'Etranger, The Meursault Investigation - not that I experienced its narrator as funny or entertaining, Camus seems to strike quite a different tone. As the panel of the just judges by Van Eyck was stolen in 1934 (and still not found, a mystery worth many books) you made me wonder if the missing judges - and so missing integrity - are revealing about the narrator's stance...


message 13: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Nick wrote: "...The narrator speaking to someone directly has the characteristic of a clean narrative form without affectation, though we all know its artifice when we think about it.."

Yes, we can't but be aware of the artifice of this extended monologue, Nick, the narrator picking up exactly where he left off on the previous evening—without the slightest trace of a blush! But there is a lot of art in this particular example of artifice, and it is for that we keep reading! Plus the narrator is such a stylish orator!


message 14: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Ken wrote: "Thought I'd read this, but no. Just L'Etranger and some essays and the wonderful short story "The Guest." I like books predicated on imagery OTHER than sight, sight, sight. They can be a sight better, when done right..."

Ha, yes, Ken, so they can!
I remember that short story you mentioned. Very fine. It was more focused on sight if I remember, as there wasn't much dialogue, I think, just a lot of silence and fabulous descriptions of landscape. There was the crack of gunshot though, and quite as startlingly powerful as in L'Etranger. That book had other key sounds too, didn't it—the drone of voices the narrator felt so removed from, the incessant barking of a dog...


message 15: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Théo d'Or wrote: "Haha ! It was a référence to your comment from my review of " La Chute ", where you expressed your curiosity to find out why I found this novel " awkward "...."

I'd forgotten that conversation completely, Théo. But I re-read your excellent review just now and it was even richer for me having now read the book myself.


David I can’t say that I noticed sound(s) in many books. You are very astute observer, Fionnuala. Thanks for the Van Eck painting too.


message 17: by Nick (new)

Nick Grammos Fionnuala wrote: "Nick wrote: "...The narrator speaking to someone directly has the characteristic of a clean narrative form without affectation, though we all know its artifice when we think about it.."

Yes, we ca..."


Yes, I enjoyed that part of it, too. To forget the narrative construct and go along with the ride.


message 18: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Jeroen wrote: "A great review Fionnuala! It brought back fond memories of a book I absolutely loved in my late teens. Can I ask which funny book about Venice you are reading now?..."

Good to hear you loved it this book too, Jeroen. My edition is pretty old, and the pages are a bit yellow but the cover image is just so good! The juge-penitent falling from his pedestal—and losing his mask in the process!
The mask is another little link with my Venice trip when I think about it. The book I read after this was Jan Morris's Venice. It's not intended to be a funny book but Jan Morris has such an entertaining way of writing that whether she's talking about the carnival or Saint Mark's basilica, her descriptions make me smile. I like writers who make me smile:-)


message 19: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Katia wrote: "….It is interesting this book has got such a distinctive voice you "heard" this man. I do not think I've ever experienced something similar. But sometimes I "hear" the voices of the characters after I've finished reading. And they do not always say what they were saying in the book…"

I wanted to go on and on listening to the sound of this man's speech in my ear. How strange is that! I don't think I ever experienced it before either, or not quite as powerfully. It may be partly because he was speaking in gorgeous, old-fashioned, French:-(

I love that characters speak to you after you've closed a book—and say new and interesting things too! Reading is so inspiring that our minds can go on creating the story after we've finished reading the text. I sometimes read on in my dreams. I remember having such an experience after finishing a Henry James book. In my dream, it finished in a radically different way!


message 20: by Fionnuala (last edited Jun 07, 2024 02:33PM) (new) - added it

Fionnuala Ilse wrote: "As the panel of the just judges by Van Eyck was stolen in 1934 (and still not found, a mystery worth many books) you made me wonder if the missing judges - and so missing integrity - are revealing about the narrator's stance...."

That's a pretty good surmise, Ilse, but there might be a few surprises in here for you all the same—if you can bear to listen to one more loquacious lawyer!
As for the Just Judges, when I found that image online and noticed their listening stance, I had the thought that they might be listening out for the footsteps of the thief who's about to whisk them away;-)


message 21: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala David wrote: "I can’t say that I noticed sound(s) in many books. You are very astute observer, Fionnuala. Thanks for the Van Eck painting too."

I can't say I notice 'sound' in texts much either, David, but this book was an exception. It's an exception in many ways!


Ulysse Algorithms are such dimwits, and have a terrible taste in books. I doubt if an algorithm has ever even read a book for pleasure. What do algorithms do on a day off? Linear algebra? Quadratic equations? Crossword puzzles?
You have a very good eye for ears, Fionnuala, and a very good ear for eyes. Those Van Eyck characters really do look like they're listening!


message 23: by Nick (new)

Nick Grammos Ulysse wrote: "Algorithms are such dimwits, and have a terrible taste in books. I doubt if an algorithm has ever even read a book for pleasure. What do algorithms do on a day off? Linear algebra? Quadratic equati..."

You are very funny here, Ulysse. But spare a thought. One day, I found GR by chance and joined. An algorithm brought us together. But, I find the algorithm may be jealous. before that I thought it silly and lacking in anything human, so I dismissed it, cast it aside, spurned it, didnt call back when it left many messages. Now something has happened, and it's trying to keep us apart. Has it evolved; or have I devolved to its level?


Ulysse Ah so you know Al too, Nick? I thought Mr Gorithm a capital fellow at first, but he turned out to be a narcissist. By the way, ever notice how with certain fonts lower-case l’s and upper case i’s are indistinguishable from each other? That really puzzles me sometimes.


message 25: by Fionnuala (last edited Jun 08, 2024 12:41AM) (new) - added it

Fionnuala Ulysse wrote: "...You have a very good eye for ears, Fionnuala, and a very good ear for eyes. Those Van Eyck characters really do look like they're listening!"

I'm laughing here, Ulysse, but you've reminded me of another sound that haunted the narrator—who was called Jean-Baptiste by the way. The other sound that he also heard one night on a bridge was a cynical laugh. A big turning point for him.

Those Van Eyck judges are very interesting. But so are the horses—I think the third one up is watching us with a very beady eye! I wonder if his name is Jean-Baptiste—because J-B has his eye very much on us the listeners.
The first horse, the white one, has a weird back leg it seems to me. As if there's an extra joint?


message 26: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Nick, I'm glad you stuck with Goodreads!


message 27: by Katia (new)

Katia N Fionnuala wrote: "Katia wrote: "….It is interesting this book has got such a distinctive voice you "heard" this man. I do not think I've ever experienced something similar. But sometimes I "hear" the voices of the c..."

It is so fascinating, Fionnuala, that you’ve finished Henry James story! Do you remember which one? It is interesting you were reading and not writing. I sometimes dream of the pages with the texts but rarely i remember more than a phrase or so and normally it is not very interesting. But i dream some music occasionally, it could be frustrating as I do not know the notation and even if I remember the melody, I cannot record it properly:-). The images are much better - easier to remember:-)


Ulysse Fionnuala wrote: "But so are the horses—I think the third one up is watching us with a very beady eye! I wonder if his name is Jean-Baptiste—because J-B has his eye very much on us the listeners."

That beady eye seems to be saying: "Here I've been in this traffic jam since 1432 and I can't even honk my horn."


message 29: by Nick (last edited Jun 08, 2024 10:25AM) (new)

Nick Grammos Fionnuala wrote: "Nick, I'm glad you stuck with Goodreads!"

Thank you , Fi. I'd be lost without you all.


message 30: by Vesna (new) - added it

Vesna I love your double-entendre for a listener while reading this novel, Fionnuala. And now that you mention it, the Van Eyck figures do look like as if they are listening attentively. Thanks for a laugh about the GR algorithm. I remember once it recommended me a German architecture book (quite technical) because I liked Calvino's Invisible Cities. :-)


message 31: by Gaurav (new) - added it

Gaurav Sagar I read it a few years ago, your nuanced write-up brings back some of the memories associated with it. Your take on this slim beauty further affirms the fact that you are a keen observer and a thoughful reader. Thanks for sharing it, Fionnuala :)


message 32: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Katia wrote: "...Do you remember which one? It is interesting you were reading and not writing. I sometimes dream of the pages with the texts but rarely i remember more than a phrase or so and normally it is not very interesting.."

I was actually writing a review of the book in the dream, Katia—but the book in the dream had a different ending to the one Henry James created for his Princess Casamassima. Of course I didn't manage to remember much about the review I was writing, and I wouldn't remember anything at all about that weird dream if I hadn't written about it in the real review!
Interesting that you dream of music sometimes—and images of course!


message 33: by Candi (new) - added it

Candi I think I'd like to spend some time as the anonymous listener and get to know this narrator rather intimately. You've written yet another very fine and supremely tempting review, Fionnuala!


Left Coast Justin I have never read Camus and never considered him a funny writer, Fionnuala. I come away from this review enlightened. I hope the humor wasn't lost in the translation into English.


message 35: by Fionnuala (last edited Jun 09, 2024 11:57AM) (new) - added it

Fionnuala Ulysse wrote: "That beady eye seems to be saying: "Here I've been in this traffic jam since 1432 and I can't even honk my horn."..."

I'm always fascinated with eyes looking out from paintings, Ulysses.
Here's a detail from a Titian I saw recently in Venice. The little person is only a tiny part of the massive painting but he/she caught my eye:



Here's the whole painting. It's still on display centuries later above the altar of the Frari church.



message 36: by Nick (last edited Jun 09, 2024 11:46AM) (new)

Nick Grammos Lovely painting, Fi. I love the exaggerated dominance of the robe. And the haircuts are a hoot, too.


message 37: by Antigone (new)

Antigone This review and discussion leave me wondering if your narrator's judges have been stolen, too. If this isn't why he is speaking, this unlikeable but interesting lawyer who is haunted by the sound a body made when it hit the water? Is he looking for a judge? Or his own judgment? Alas I've wandered so far afield. Camus will do this, though, if I recall correctly. Just lead one on and on and on. All the way to Autumn in Paris, which, while I cannot hear him laughing, I can imagine well enough would have made him smile!


message 38: by Ulysse (last edited Jun 10, 2024 08:13AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ulysse Fionnuala wrote: "I'm always fascinated with eyes looking out from paintings, Uly..."

Oh I know this painting. I'd never noticed the little person's eyes before. For some reason my gaze was always directed upwards, only to be met with another little person's idea of a joke.


message 39: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Vesna wrote: "...Thanks for a laugh about the GR algorithm. I remember once it recommended me a German architecture book (quite technical) because I liked Calvino's Invisible Cities. :-).."

It would be worth keeping a list of such amusing recommendations, wouldn't it, Vesna? I just checked the latest one on my homepage: it says because I've read Houellebecq's Sérotonine, I should read Bernhard's Woodcutters.
I do want to read Woodcutters but I can't see the connection—unless it's that there were protestors in Houellebecq's book who blocked the motorway, possibly with tree trunks?
No, I know that's not how it works:-))


Left Coast Justin My favorite:

"Because you read 'Green Eggs and Ham' (picture of ham and eggs on the cover) you might enjoy 'Penis Genius' (picture of a lipstick-covered banana on the cover.)

I feel like Amazon's AI might actually need to go to jail.


message 41: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Gaurav wrote: "I read it a few years ago, your nuanced write-up brings back some of the memories associated with it. Your take on this slim beauty further affirms the fact that you are a keen observer and a thoughtful reader..."

Ah, thanks, Gaurav, but actually the book deserves a more thorough review than I've written. It's just that I read it several weeks before I got time to review it and the thing that dominated my memory was the hypnotic quality of the narrator's voice and the sounds that haunted him. Maybe that's all a potential reader needs to know?


message 42: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Candi wrote: "I think I'd like to spend some time as the anonymous listener and get to know this narrator rather intimately. You've written yet another very fine and supremely tempting review, Fionnuala!"

Oh, you will get to know him very intimately. In fact, you'll eventually end up in his bedroom—though only standing by his bed;-)
All the same, Candi, I hesitate to say do read it absolutely because I don't know how the narrator will sound in English. Maybe he won't sound so mesmerizing:-(


message 43: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Left Coast Justin wrote: "I have never read Camus and never considered him a funny writer, Fionnuala. I come away from this review enlightened. I hope the humor wasn't lost in the translation into English."

Other readers might not find it as funny as I did, Justin, and there is a suicide theme after all. And you might be right that the humour might get lost in translation. We need to hear from someone who has read it in English!


message 44: by Fionnuala (last edited Jun 10, 2024 12:52PM) (new) - added it

Fionnuala Nick wrote: "Lovely painting, Fi. I love the exaggerated dominance of the robe. And the haircuts are a hoot, too."

That first photo is one I took myself, Nick, because I spotted that face and wanted to remember it. The robe is a beautiful red, isn't it? The second photo is from wikipaedia, and the red is a lot duller somehow.


message 45: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Antigone wrote: "This review and discussion leave me wondering if your narrator's judges have been stolen, too. If this isn't why he is speaking, this unlikeable but interesting lawyer who is haunted by the sound a body made when it hit the water? Is he looking for a judge? Or his own judgment? Alas I've wandered so far afield. Camus will do this, though, if I recall correctly. Just lead one on and on and on. All the way to Autumn in Paris, which, while I cannot hear him laughing, I can imagine well enough would have made him smile..."

Oh, how right you are, Antigone. This judge is indeed looking to be judged. The two sounds he heard, the body falling and the cynical laughter, have shaken his belief in himself and the way he has lived his life. He experiences a huge guilt from then on and that's what he's confessing to the anonymous man in the bar—and to us readers. And that painting of the Just Judges has in fact been stolen (it was really stolen), and he is not unimplicated....


message 46: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Ulysse wrote: "Oh I know this painting. I'd never noticed the little person's eyes before. For some reason my gaze was always directed upwards, only to be met with another little person's idea of a joke..."

How about that! I didn't notice that playful duo until you mentioned them!


message 47: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Left Coast Justin wrote: "My favorite:
"Because you read 'Green Eggs and Ham' (picture of ham and eggs on the cover) you might enjoy 'Penis Genius' (picture of a lipstick-covered banana on the cover.)
I feel like Amazon's AI might...."


Well, it gave me a laugh this morning anyway, Justin!


message 48: by Nick (last edited Jun 11, 2024 02:45AM) (new)

Nick Grammos Fionnuala wrote: "Nick wrote: "Lovely painting, Fi. I love the exaggerated dominance of the robe. And the haircuts are a hoot, too."

That first photo is one I took myself, Nick, because I spotted that face and want..."


What I like about the robe is that it dominates and sends a message. In a sense, the wearer is the position the robe defines. And a nice contrast with the cheeky individualism of a child-like - as you say boy or girl because it doest matter - look back at the artist examining the work.

It seems common in paintings of the time, from my little knowledge, to have a figure off-centre somehow, whether the artist makes a cameo appearance or someone that disrupts the focus, creating a new point of view.


message 49: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Thanks for helping me to see new things in that painting, Nick. Yes, the virgin and child are off-centre which must have been unusual at the time. And that child looking out upsets the expected balance further. So interesting.
You could say the same about La Chute. The reader thinks he knows how it's going to play out but then the balance of the scales of justice get upset...


Mark  Porton Left Coast Justin wrote: "My favorite:

"Because you read 'Green Eggs and Ham' (picture of ham and eggs on the cover) you might enjoy 'Penis Genius' (picture of a lipstick-covered banana on the cover.)

I feel like Amazon's..."


Bahahahahaha - brilliant Justin!


« previous 1
back to top