Julie G's Reviews > The Night Guest

The Night Guest by Hildur Knútsdóttir
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5211606
's review

really liked it

By the time I was 14, I had so many babysitting jobs, I was practically like a drug dealer, with an 80s style pager at my hip.

I had a solid reputation, several regular jobs, and I was constantly being farmed out to work all-day events on the weekend, like weddings, for strangers who had gotten my number from people who already knew me.

As long as I was navigating the women and children, everything was fine, but almost as soon as I turned 14, I learned quickly that I was going to need to be very careful with any of the fathers, uncles, and male friends of any of these families.

I was a young 14, street smart, but innocent, and my introduction to the world of men with unchecked behavior and high levels of testosterone was a 30-year-old man who was the brother to a woman I was babysitting for, for the first time.

It's amazing how many details of this evening I still remember. . . it was a rented townhouse, dark and cramped inside, and there were two kids, already asleep, upstairs, and three young adults in the equation: the woman who had called me to babysit, her husband, and her adult brother. They were all in their early 30s.

I was on the couch, waiting for them all to leave, reading a book (of course), and as the husband and wife were still upstairs, getting ready, the adult brother popped open a bottle of beer and planted himself on the couch next to me, his leg touching mine. He was wearing hospital scrubs and a stethoscope. It was Halloween and he was dressed as a doctor for a costume party.

I smiled politely, and moved farther to the left on the couch, away from his leg, but he moved in on me and reinserted his leg against mine, and started rubbing my leg with his leg. He was chit-chatting with me, who knows what in the hell he was saying; all I could see was that leg continuing to rub against mine. I remember looking up the half-flight of stairs and staring at the carpeted landing, willing the damned couple to come down and free me from this mess. Just when I thought the rubbing leg was bad enough, he leaned in close to me and said something like, "I sure am glad I've got these baggy scrubs on, because you should see how hard I am, looking at your legs in that skirt. How about I stay behind from this party, and you and I have a little party of our own??"

I think I must have stopped breathing in sheer terror at this point. I don't know how many minutes passed before this couple came down the freaking stairs. I'm going to calculate that it was an eternity, but they finally did, and lo and behold, he announced to them both that he wasn't feeling great and he was going to stay behind with the sitter. My God, what was I going to do, if he stayed??

I saw the woman glance over quickly at me and then she looked at her brother and said, "If you stay home, we don't need a sitter, so tell me if you really want to stay and I'll take her home." I don't remember all of the details after that, I only remember that THANK GOD he went to the party with them and the woman took me home, promptly, when they returned later that evening.

I want to be clear: this was one of the more innocent things (of the bad things, involving men) that happened to me, while babysitting, but it was my introduction to the possibility of what could go wrong, particularly if the woman involved wasn't paying attention or refused any role in my personal safety. The patriarchy speaks with my mother's voice.

You may be wondering why I'm blathering on about this, here in my review of an Icelandic horror novel, but there is a reason, and the protagonist of this short novel, Iðunn, explains it here:

Centuries of socialization have conditioned us into believing that it's our responsibility to create a cozy atmosphere and ensure that no one is embarrassed about anything. That's why we laugh at jokes that offend us. That's why we smile at people who pat us on the butt. That's why we pretend that it's just a coincidence when the boss repeatedly brushes against our breasts at work. Because anything else would be just so embarrassing. For everybody.
I have been trained to smooth out all the imperfections, the same way other women have
.

We women, especially women my age or older, were taught not to say anything about the oral surgeon who would massage our thighs as he worked on our teeth or the employer's husbands who always insist on driving us home at night and ask for "goodnight kisses," or the male family members who would comment on our "cheerleader's legs" or "playfully" spank our butts as we walked out of the room. Naughty girls!

And. . . resentment grows. Has grown. Turns into a seething anger, an anger that too many men like to overlook, or make fun of. We are sometimes labeled "Femi-Nazis," if we speak openly about our rights, as human beings, or the old standby: crazy bitches.

Some women, like Iðunn, in Reykjavik, have clenched their jaws for so many years, after being beaten by ex-boyfriends, invalidated by their own parents, overlooked and underappreciated by employers, living on their own, doing it all. . .

They start doing weird shit in their sleep. . .

And they wake up with blood on their hands.

In my opinion, this little novel didn't quite, quite maximize its full potential, but it still left me wondering. . . what if. . . what if. . . what if?

And Hildur Knútsdóttir's style (which, to me, felt a lot like American writer, Paula Fox's, style, but was also uniquely her own) is certainly effective in giving the reader the serious creeps.

3.5, rounded up
99 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Night Guest.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 6, 2024 – Started Reading
December 6, 2024 – Shelved
December 8, 2024 –
page 128
65.98% "The patriarchy speaks with my mother's voice."
December 9, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-17 of 17 (17 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Vegan I love your personal reviews, Julie.

Yes, I think all of us have stories.

Great review about the book too. Very helpful.


Julie G Lisa,
Thank you. One thing that might interest you, in particular, about this story. . . the protagonist, Iðunn, is a vegetarian, but her parents can't accept it, or even acknowledge it. Every time they have her over for dinner, they serve meat, and when she reminds them, yet again, that she doesn't eat it, they say, "But you eat chicken, right?" Or, "Turkey isn't really meat," etc. It's another part of her life that is completely invalidated.

You are right about our stories, unfortunately. It wasn't until I was in college, working at a woman's clothing store, that my eyes were TRULY opened to the extent of sexual abuse, incest and rape in the average woman's life, in this country. In our one store alone, which didn't have a very large staff, THREE of the women had been raped by a male family member. Though I have my own stories, I consider myself, overall, very fortunate, particularly that I had a trustworthy father and brother. It breaks my heart, and disgusts me, whenever I learn of any woman who was sexually abused by a member of her own household.


message 3: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Vegan Julie, Ha re the turkey and chicken. Yes, I'm always interested to see vegetarian, and particularly vegan, characters since they're not commonly included in fictional books.

I was in grave danger too many times to count as a preteen and teen but i also consider myself fortunate.


message 4: by Kimberly (new)

Kimberly Julie, as you know I'm a big fan of your reviews. They always pack a punch, so to speak, and this one rings true for many of us. I especially appreciated your comments about resentment. One doesn't really hear much about the long-term impact, and I thank you for that truth.


Persephone's Pomegranate Julie, it appears that we have connected on a mental level, as I have just released a review addressing similar themes. In my review, I reference a girl who was also 14, and I delve into inappropriate experiences I encountered during my youth. I am taken aback by the number of women who share comparable narratives, which is disheartening. It seems that girls and women are fated to endure harassment and assault, regardless of the decade in which they were born. It feels akin to a curse. Thank you for sharing your story.


message 6: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer nyc Wow, this is the first piece of writing I’ve been able to absorb for a while! It’s great to come up for air and see something so relatable and well-articulated 🌷


Julie G Kim,
Thank you for such a kind comment. I think it makes us, as women, feel better to know that we're not alone. . . and, at the same time, it makes us feel worse, knowing that other soul sisters have weathered similar storms.
It's interesting; I've been re-watching "That 70s Show" with my youngest. It's a favorite of mine, particular because of my love for the 70s. I think the show does a very realistic job of portraying how much "tits and ass" played a role in the 70s. Even though the women's movement was really, finally starting to emerge, it's like that movement was being simultaneously snuffed out by a near-obsession with "chick detectives" in string bikinis or Superhero costumes. Like, women were finally being "permitted" to work, as long as they did it in their bikinis. WTF??


message 8: by Kimberly (new)

Kimberly Julie wrote: "Kim,
Thank you for such a kind comment. I think it makes us, as women, feel better to know that we're not alone. . . and, at the same time, it makes us feel worse, knowing that other soul sisters h..."


I could tell you stories, my friend! But WTF about sums it up.


Julie G Kim,
I would believe all of them!


Julie G PP,
I know there are several fundamental religions that like to proliferate the notion that women are cursed, she ate the apple, not HIM, and whatnot, but that doesn't work for me. We may feel like we're cursed, but I think that's all a bunch of bullshit that others have dreamed up, so they don't need to have accountability. Personally, I think that testosterone, when combined with ignorance, is the root of most of our problems. . . and parents who allow their sons to have reckless behavior and strut the earth as kings create generation after generation of men who think they can do whatever they want, when it comes to women and girls.
I was recently at a women's circle and a very quiet woman there shared with us that once, when she was in her early 20s, she was jogging in sweat pants and an oversized t-shirt and a guy saw her, swerved off the road, parked, and started chasing her. She ran as fast as she could into a neighborhood, and she ended up in someone's yard, hiding in a bush, and held her breath as she watched him hunt for her. This woman has zero penchant for drama, and at the end of her no frills story, she said, "I was wearing sweat pants, for God's sake. Just trying to get my run in." I have too many stories of my own, but this totally enraged me. This totally chill woman was out running in sweatpants and was hunted like an animal. How can we not feel resentful??


message 11: by Persephone's Pomegranate (last edited Dec 17, 2024 06:08AM) (new)

Persephone's Pomegranate Julie wrote: "PP,
I know there are several fundamental religions that like to proliferate the notion that women are cursed, she ate the apple, not HIM, and whatnot, but that doesn't work for me. We may feel like..."


Many points you raised in your response struck a chord with me. I completely agree that both mothers and fathers should teach their sons to respect women. Many families tend to spoil their sons, and many mothers coddle their boys, leading them to think they can do no wrong. Have you noticed the recent trend of toxic 'boy moms'? I've seen several YouTube videos by women critiquing these mothers, and the comments have been revealing. Many girls and women shared experiences of feeling less valued than their brothers, receiving little affection while their brothers were treated like royalty. I’m an only child, but I like to believe that if I had a brother, my parents would have shown me the same love.

That part about the woman you met was frightening, but sadly, it’s not surprising. The reason it’s not surprising is that it happens so frequently. I used to be really into true crime and watched a lot of related podcasts and videos. Many girls and women have experienced this, and very few make it out alive. If that woman hadn't gotten away, she would have faced assault and likely murder as well. Police officers always say that girls and women should fight back as much as they can, as being taken to a secondary location significantly decreases their chances of survival. They say that even if the attacker harms or kills you for resisting, it’s still better than what could happen to you behind closed doors. Not only will you be assaulted, but your chances of survival are very low. But that's a whole lot easier said than done, particularly for a petite woman without any self-defense training when facing a large, powerful man.

It’s likely that you, like me, have encountered numerous comments that arise whenever a woman is assaulted. The focus often shifts to her clothing. This is infuriating. People must realize that rape is not influenced by what a woman wears or how she acts. Men who commit these crimes are indifferent to a woman’s attire. Do some people really believe that dressing modestly will deter rapists? A well-known case from a few years back comes to mind—though I can’t recall the victim's name—where a woman was raped and murdered while jogging. Instead of addressing the horrific nature of the crime, discussions centered around her outfit and whether it contributed to her assault. What was she expected to wear while exercising, a snowsuit? Women can be in sweatpants, as you pointed out, and still face the threat of assault.


Julie G PP,
The veins in my neck must be BULGING, at the moment. THIS IS ALL SO INFURIATING!!

I know a woman who was sexually assaulted by a stranger after a long night shift at a restaurant, and the first question she was asked, after the horrible attack was, "Why are you working so late? What do you think happens after midnight?" Seriously. . . not WHAT DID HE LOOK LIKE? or WHICH DIRECTION DID HE RUN? No--"Why are you working so late?" This is just like the clothing issue--it's a red herring, a way for people to avoid the real issue.

You are so right; the woman in the story I shared with you was at great risk of being assaulted. I can't think of too many people who would just "casually" hunt down a woman just to say "hello" to her. She must have been absolutely terrified.

Ugh. I feel so badly for my daughters--it seems as though we just keep handing the next generation the incredible burdens that we've already carried on our shoulders. And now girls and women get to have micro plastics in their lady parts, too! I just had the most disturbing conversation about this, with a woman who's been researching this topic for months.


Julie G Jennifer,
What a great compliment. Thank you! I am so heartened by your artistic focus, and I'm also missing our pow-wows!
xoxo


message 14: by Robin (new)

Robin A powerful review, Julie. Don't be discouraged by stupid GRs, please keep writing these.

It's amazing, and so, so sad, how the world hasn't changed all that much for women, in the years since our babysitting days.


Persephone's Pomegranate Julie wrote: "PP,
The veins in my neck must be BULGING, at the moment. THIS IS ALL SO INFURIATING!!

I know a woman who was sexually assaulted by a stranger after a long night shift at a restaurant, and the firs..."


There is a noticeable pattern in the way girls and women are treated after they report an assault. The questions are always the same: "What were you doing out so late?" "What were you wearing?" "Were you drinking?" "Did you provoke him in any way?" Regardless of the horrific actions of a man, the focus shifts to the woman's behavior. It seems that no matter the severity of the crime, the narrative often implies that she must have done something to warrant such treatment. This is a significant reason why many assaults remain unreported; women and girls fear the humiliation of being questioned and devalued.

Indeed, I've come across reports indicating that microplastics have been found in female reproductive organs. Additionally, there's been a rise in the variety of microplastics, which is contributing to a notable decline in sperm count. It's quite alarming. How can anyone maintain their health in today's world?


Julie G PP: Sigh. It's getting harder and harder for me to act positive about the future of this planet, in front of my kids. I don't want to lie to them, but I don't want to scare them, either.


Julie G Robin,
I am feeling VERY discouraged by GRs, both by the sharp decline in interaction here and the robotic management of the site, but I appreciate your positivity and validation. I'm starting to feel like I'm one of those musicians on the Titanic, the ones who played, even as the ship succumbed to the force of the Arctic waters!

And, yes, discouraged for women, too, especially now, in a country where women perceive that this new "leader" of ours is a better option for women than an actual WOMAN. It feels like we may never elect a female president, nor truly believe in the efficacy of female leadership.


back to top