Jayme C (Brunetteslikebookstoo)'s Reviews > Both Things Are True
Both Things Are True
by
by
Jayme C (Brunetteslikebookstoo)'s review
bookshelves: contemporary-fiction, netgalley, romance
Aug 05, 2025
bookshelves: contemporary-fiction, netgalley, romance
I haven’t seen the Apple TV+ series-Truth Be Told, but I remember reading and enjoying the book years ago, so I was excited to get the opportunity to read an early copy of the author’s latest-Both Things Are True.
Vanessa is a yoga influencer engaged to Jack, a crypto entrepreneur who is perfect on paper. But, she would trade their opulent lifestyle for another chance with Sam-the one who got away.
When Jack is accused of fraud and flees the country, Vanessa’s only option is to fly home to Chicago and move in with her younger sister, Faith. Fortunately, Serendipity will put Sam in her path, almost as soon as she arrives.
They weren’t any good at communicating years ago, when they impulsively got married in Las Vegas, and just as quickly annulled the marriage, 72 hours later when they sobered up-and they aren’t any better at communicating now.
In fact at 44%, Faith advises her sister to JUST TALK to Sam, but then we would not have a story. This entire “second chance” romance revolves around MISCOMMUNICATION.
I think that your enjoyment (or lack thereof) will depend on whether or not you sympathize with Vanessa. Unfortunately, I found her self pity, and self sabotaging behavior, and her excuses for her chronic tardiness to be annoying. She seemed to be CRYING on every other page.
For a romance to work-you need to root for the characters to get together, and I wasn’t doing that, so the book failed for me. If you find yourself rooting for Vanessa-you will have a different experience with this story, and I hope that you do!
Did MarilynW and DeAnn have better luck with this one? Be sure to watch for their reviews!
NOW AVAILABLE
Thank You to Lake Union Publishing for the gifted ARC provided through NetGalley. As always, these are my candid thoughts.
Vanessa is a yoga influencer engaged to Jack, a crypto entrepreneur who is perfect on paper. But, she would trade their opulent lifestyle for another chance with Sam-the one who got away.
When Jack is accused of fraud and flees the country, Vanessa’s only option is to fly home to Chicago and move in with her younger sister, Faith. Fortunately, Serendipity will put Sam in her path, almost as soon as she arrives.
They weren’t any good at communicating years ago, when they impulsively got married in Las Vegas, and just as quickly annulled the marriage, 72 hours later when they sobered up-and they aren’t any better at communicating now.
In fact at 44%, Faith advises her sister to JUST TALK to Sam, but then we would not have a story. This entire “second chance” romance revolves around MISCOMMUNICATION.
I think that your enjoyment (or lack thereof) will depend on whether or not you sympathize with Vanessa. Unfortunately, I found her self pity, and self sabotaging behavior, and her excuses for her chronic tardiness to be annoying. She seemed to be CRYING on every other page.
For a romance to work-you need to root for the characters to get together, and I wasn’t doing that, so the book failed for me. If you find yourself rooting for Vanessa-you will have a different experience with this story, and I hope that you do!
Did MarilynW and DeAnn have better luck with this one? Be sure to watch for their reviews!
NOW AVAILABLE
Thank You to Lake Union Publishing for the gifted ARC provided through NetGalley. As always, these are my candid thoughts.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Both Things Are True.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
December 19, 2024
– Shelved
December 19, 2024
– Shelved as:
to-read
February 8, 2025
– Shelved as:
contemporary-fiction
February 8, 2025
– Shelved as:
netgalley
February 8, 2025
– Shelved as:
romance
August 3, 2025
–
Started Reading
August 4, 2025
–
50.0%
August 5, 2025
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 78 (78 new)
message 1:
by
Cara
(new)
Aug 04, 2025 07:34AM
Happy reading, sweet Jayme💘!!!!!!!!!
reply
|
flag
Sounds quite uninteresting. You are so right, if you don't root for one of the mc(s), you cannot enjoy a romance genre. Thank for such a stellar review Jayme 💕 Going to stay away from this one
Wonderful review, Jayme! 💖 I'll be sure to skip this one. If there is one thing I dislike in my books it is a constantly weeping and whining FMC. No thank you!
Suja wrote: "Sounds quite uninteresting. You are so right, if you don't root for one of the mc(s), you cannot enjoy a romance genre. Thank for such a stellar review Jayme 💕 Going to stay away from this one"Good plan!
Michelle wrote: "Wonderful review, Jayme! 💖 I'll be sure to skip this one. If there is one thing I dislike in my books it is a constantly weeping and whining FMC. No thank you!"I wish I had said “no thank you”! ☺️
Oh, god! Can't stand miscommunication anymore! Too bad, though. The cover is rather cute. Great review, Jayme. 💗
Suzy wrote: "Terrific review Jayme! The constant crying would bug me too! Hope you love your next book. ❤️"Thanks Suzy! It can’t be any worse! ☺️
Cara wrote: "Great review, sweet Jayme💞😘!!!!!!!! I agree, I don't like whiny characters either😭!!!!!!!!!"Thank You sweet Cara! 💞💞💞
Krystal wrote: "Yikes! I almost picked this one this month. Sorry it was a disappointing read. Excellent review!!🖤"Thanks Krystal! ❤️🐈⬛
Srivalli wrote: "Oh, god! Can't stand miscommunication anymore! Too bad, though. The cover is rather cute. Great review, Jayme. 💗"The cover is cute! ☺️
Marialyce wrote: "Does not sound appealing at all! Great review, Jayme!"3 stars is probably too generous! 🫤
Great review, Jayme! Sorry this one didn't quite work for you. Constantly crying main characters are one of my huge pet peeves in books, lol.
Oof. Glad I didn't pick this one! Sorry it was a stinker, Jayme, but a wonderful review as always! 💗
Jamie wrote: "Great review, Jayme! Sorry this one didn't quite work for you. Constantly crying main characters are one of my huge pet peeves in books, lol."Definitely skip this one! ☺️
Mary Beth wrote: "Fantastic review! 🧡 Hope you are loving your current read. Since we are reading it together! 😂"🤣 I am!
Kat wrote: "Oof. Glad I didn't pick this one! Sorry it was a stinker, Jayme, but a wonderful review as always! 💗"Thanks Kat! 💞
Darla wrote: "A fair and balanced review, Jayme. Looks like this one had a fatal flaw. 🤔"Unfortunately, it did! 🫤
Rosh ~catching up slowly~ wrote: "Fair review, Jayme! ♡ That's way too much miscommunication! Hate that trope!"Definitely skip this one!
So much crying would be annoying. I don’t think I’d be able to relate to Vanessa any more than you did. Fair and balanced review, Jayme. ❤️
My least favorite trope. I appreciate it when characters can have an adult conversation rather than dragging out the drama. Always love reading your thoughts, Jayme! ❤️
NZLisaM wrote: "So much crying would be annoying. I don’t think I’d be able to relate to Vanessa any more than you did. Fair and balanced review, Jayme. ❤️"Thanks Lisa! I don’t think you would either! ❤️


















