We know from the same passage that details Gwindor’s escape from Angband that other prisoners in the mines did sometimes escape through the tunnels. According to The Children of Húrin, these were mostly Noldorin elves captured during battles and kept alive for their skills locating and mining ores, gems and other resources
I always wonder what happened to the unnamed others who escaped in this manner.
We know that for much of the First Age, and in some communities even before this, former prisoners were looked upon with suspicion and even hostility. This is only heightened when Morgoth begins consistently releasing prisoners who have been traumatized or cursed, (ever a blurry boundary between the two in these stories!)into remaining in his power. Interestingly enough, we are told of few wrongdoings committed by these prisoners, but the fear of their presence is pervasive by the end of the First Age*.
I’m just thinking about the others who escaped through the mines after years or decades of imprisonment. Who burst out into cold air and felt foliage upon their injured bodies, who wandered senseless for weeks like Gwindor did
Who perhaps wanted to return home even despite the stigma but in the aftermath of the Bragollach and then the Nírnaeth, might have found no home to return to. Homesteads abandoned and villages destroyed. No news would have come to them in the mines of Angband. If they hailed from Hithlum, they would find the enemy occupying much of the inhabited areas, the others simply empty.
The shock and exhilaration of freedom and the gnawing loneliness and desolation of Beleriand after the Bragollach and Nírnaeth, even for those who hadn’t escaped the Hells of Iron
I wonder where they went, who if anyone they saw or sought, if anyone heard from them again.
Anyways, stigma against former prisoners in Beleriand is one of my favorite topics to write about and I’m planning to make another post specifically about those sent from Angband who returned to their communities.