The worst thing about titans is that i really like their jason todd. He feels plausibly like an insecure teen. And he's so open about what makes him tick, he struggles with self- worth believably. And then the story decides he is WRONG. And i really cannot get over that. How do people write this kind of thing. What is their motivation. It's so distressing to watch a story where nobody seems to see what i see and not being able to interfere.
Oh, yeah, absolutely!
Like you said, he really comes across as a traumatized teenager with genuine mental health struggles. And he is open about a lot of stuff, and he has textbook rejection sensitive dysphoria, and he wants to get help for his issues, and it makes me want to chew glass 🙃
And then we ended up in this weird situation where they accidentally wrote an extremely relateable depressed ADHD kid, but they didn't actually want you to like him very much because they knew they were gonna do the Red Hood storyline at some point.
So even when Jason is right it's brushed off or skimmed over or he's demonized for doing stuff the other characters are allowed to do and it is SO FRUSTRATING
And don't even get me started on the hypocrisy of the 'killing makes you irredeemable' stance in a universe where Starfire regularly incinerates people, oh my GOD
Anyway. As you can probably tell, I adore Titans!Jason and I want to wrap him in a weighted blanket
ok the other worst thing about titans is how much they want to manipulate the audience into judging the characters. i don't watch a ton of these things, so i'm not sure how much that is a thing generally, but ... they so blatantly either have characters judge each other, or like let them kill puppies, or whatever the trope is called, so we absolutely know not to interact with them.
i knew they were going to do red hood, but i'm not sure even in the comic red hood is being judged by the other characters or the story? but somehow in the show they decided that we cannot possibly come to a conclusion, we need to be shown how evil jason is and it never works??!! on me anyway.
and then paradoxically they let him invent a drug and crane drug him with it and still he's considered fully liable for everything. even tho he didn't even mastermind this whole thing. like, idk, pls make up your mind about who you are accusing here.
i want to make their jason feel safe and like have adults in his life who give an actual shit. or, have empathy. or something. anything but the incompetent adults he gets to hang with.
Oh yeah, the fundamental problem really is just that the writers aren't very good writers lmao
They tried so hard to go for the edgy, cool, grim superhero theme that almost all the "good" guys end up being deeply unlikable. (Sorry, I'm supposed to be sad that Hank was killed? What?? I would've stuck a bomb in that guy myself, Jesus Christ)
And they're so busy writing all the complicated drama that they forget to write the nice, fun, friendly interactions too, and then you end up having characters say they're like a family when they spent eight solid episodes lying to one another and arguing about it and splitting up.
I don't mind characters having their own opinions and judging the other characters so much, but it does annoy the shit out of me when they flip flop their stances with no good reason - like when you have Dick who didn't bat an eye at Conner killing people while brainwashed but can't fathom that Crane manipulated Jason, or a Starfire that happily takes a murderous Blackfire back to their home but gets mad when Dick arranges to meet Jason at a neutral location. Make it make sense, guys!!


