Lonesome Dove, Larry McMurtry
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Classics, Historical fiction, Western | 960 pages | 1985
Lonesome Dove is a Pulitzer Prize-winning novel about retired Texas Rangers Gus McCrae and Woodrow Call who lead a cattle drive from Texas to Montana. The story follows the two friends and their eccentric crew as they face hardship, danger, and the changing landscape of the American West.
“If you want one thing too much it’s likely to be a disappointment. The healthy way is to learn to like the everyday things, like soft beds and buttermilk—and feisty gentlemen.”
I’ve recently finished this book and am feeling so raw over it that I decided to write this rec before reading the rest of the series. Lonesome Dove is an epic western that blurs the line between myth and truth, revealing the American West as a world built on violence, loyalty and the quiet tragedies of people who rarely say what they feel. The plot is grand and devastating but brilliantly told in a fun, lighthearted voice that pulled me in from the very first line up until the last one.
The book’s greatest triumph is its extraordinary storytelling and character work. Despite being a big cast, each character gets enough page time to feel real, nuanced and larger-than-life: from the philosophizing Gus to the taciturn Captain Call, from naive Newt to the countless side characters, everyone has their own quirks and flaws and get a full emotional arc which I deeply appreciate.
Though the narrative revolves around themes of traditional masculinity and focuses on the quiet partnership between two former Texas Rangers, the novel also introduces some strong, complex and propelling female characters. Clara, Lorena and Ellie resist the simplistic “frontier woman” stereotype and retain a lot of agency and depth, becoming the moral backbone of the story.
It’s important to note that although memorable, these women remain confined to roles shaped by the men around them. Their arcs often serve as plot devices for male suffering or growth, or else revolve around the classic marriage-motherhood-domesticity triad. While this doesn’t diminish their power, it certainly obscures a more nuanced representation, as a reminder that Lonesome Dove is a story primarily written for and about men. Which doesn’t mean the emotional triangle between Gus, Call and Clara cannot be brilliantly executed and (in my opinion) one of the most understated dynamics in the book!
For readers drawn to queer-coded dynamics such as myself, Lonesome Dove offers a surprisingly rich subtext beneath all the “dude bro” elements. Characters like Captain Call, with his solitary stoicism and near-total emotional repression are a compelling example of male affection constrained by the sense of duty. Other characters like Newt and July Johnson experience more interiority and don’t shy away from expressing their vulnerability.
Ultimately, Lonesome Dove is a tragedy disguised as a western adventure. Every small moment of tenderness is overshadowed by the oppressive reminder that the West was built on violence. The novel offers a reckoning with that cost, revealing how dreams are paid for in grief, exhaustion, and the quiet ache of people who survive because they have no other choice. And yet, this story has so much heart. It is fun, charming, heroic and heartbreaking, timeless and painfully honest. A story that lingers within long after the last page.