Three on Three
Recent posts have focused on Horace Biddle, acclaimed poet and famous hermit (yes, you read that correctly, a famous hermit) from the late 1800s. Today, I have three poems by Biddle, and three by Dickinson which Biddle’s poems have called to mind.
First, in Biddle’s poem “Autumn,” the second stanza recounts the seasons of a life, from “young Spring, the sweetest of the year,” to that “hoary age” when “Death’s unwelcome frost soon lays us in the tomb.” The lines reminded me of Death’s carriage ride through the scenes of life in Dickinson’s “Because I could not stop for Death”; the third stanza from Dickinson’s reads thusly:
We passed the School, where Children strove
At Recess – in the Ring –
We passed the Fields of Gazing Grain –
We passed the Setting Sun –
Dickinson’s brief scene is much more concise and is certainly more evocative of that age-old notion of a lifetime flashing before one’s eyes.
Next, Dickinson’s take on “hope” is also more succinct than Biddle’s – and more positive; dare I say… more hopeful? Biddle’s vision of hope comes in a “pleasing mask” with “sweet promise” aimed to deceive. Dickinson’s is an endearing little bird that sings sweetly a tune of comfort.
Finally, I’ve paired Biddle’s “The Absent One” with Dickinson’s “Wild nights – Wild nights!” Which, in your opinion expresses a more intense, passionate yearning?