Pennsylvania Dutch sugar cakes
aka giant fluffy sugar cookies. I do not know how old this version of the recipe is but it's probably from the 70s at least.
- 1 Teaspoon of Baking Soda
- 1 Teaspoon of vanilla
- half a teaspoon of Cream of Tartar
- 2 eggs
- 2 cups of sugar
- 3/4ths of a cup of shortening or lard.
- 1 cup of buttermilk
- ___
- 4 and a half cups of flour
For the easiest mixing, add all the other ingredients first and mix them up, then add the flour one cup at a time. Or else just use an electric mixer. The dough will be very hard to mix if you dump in all the flour at once.
For the easiest cookies, just plop out big spoonfulls. For nicer looking ones, roll the big spoonfulls into little balls.
Add sprinkles or colored sugar to the top of each cookie before baking.
Bake in an oven at 350 degrees.
How long they take to bake will depend on your oven and what kind of baking sheet you're using, so maybe start at 10 mins and check on them. They'll be done when the edges start to just barely turn golden brown.
Parchment paper will help them not stick to the pan.
Cool on a cookie rack before storing in an airtight bag or jar.
This is the original recipe a friend of my grandma printed out at some point. Feel free to experiment and share the results.
Idealy, the finished cookies should be bigger than your hand. Or if you're feeling daring, the size of a kid's face lol. They are meant to be showy and big and dramatic.
you can google "Pennsylvania Dutch sugar cakes" or "Amish sugar cakes" to find other versions.
note: you can chill the dough in the fridge if you can't bake them right away for any reason, but if you have to refrigerate it, let the dough come up to room temperature again before you bake them, otherwise the tops will not get cooked fully if the dough is still cold when it goes in.
as an added note, if you oven stops working.... "did you try unplugging it and plugging it back in after two minutes" does indeed work on ovens as well as computers
and don't forget fun sugar sprinkles !




































