Interview with the Vampire HEA backlash in the Heated Rivalry Fandom (Pt2)
It’s no shocker that IWTV is hella niche, even in the LGBTQ+ community. As a gory gothic horror vampire show, ofc there’s folks who just refuse to watch it on principle. I’m not talking to them–RUN, here there be monsters. 💀 (Although I DO wonder how many of the same folks tuned in for Hannibal, but i digress…. 🙄😒) And ofc there’s the racist book purists who vowed to never watch the show cuz AMC raceswapped Louis & and made him Black. 🤢 Heavens forbid vampires have interracial relationships. 🤮
Likewise, ofc there’s people in the LGBTQ+ community who never saw Moonlight. As a Black film full of dark-skinned melanated Black gay men in the ‘hood, no duh predominately white queer folks ain’t checking in. 🙄 I was shocked the first time I heard Hudson Williams even mention using Moonlight as his inspo for Shane, like what’s going on in Canada?! And he talked about ML over & over again, too–that made me like Hudson 10x more NGL. ✊😅
But in this viral tweet that pmo & made me fire off this series of responses/rants, certain HR fans showed their whole arses about what they think about queer media like IWTV & Moonlight, etc. They didn’t mention race thank god (at least not in THIS thread 😬), but what they DID say to compare IWTV to HR wasn’t surprising either.
domestic violence, violence, toxic, gothic story with gore, dragged out, “I don’t see them having a happy ending”
I’ve already addressed the IWTV side of the HEA discourse. IWTV’s own fandom is full of misinformation & fearmongering, cuz most of the fandom hasn’t read the TVC source material. 🤦♂️ The dragged out nature of these long AF hiatuses between seasons allow the BS to spread, where everyone thinks Louis & Lestat will never get back together & this isn’t The Loustat Show cuz Lestat takes other lovers & monogamy isn’t real to vampires, etc. So when uneducated folk start going: Oh, IWTV isn’t as good/popular as HR cuz it’s not HEA~!, the IWTV show-onlies have nothing to say & get gotcha’d. 😒
The more interesting bit relates to toxicity & domestic violence. Plenty of the HR fans’ critiques & insults about Queer Struggle & Queer Trauma were how no one’s interested in shows with pain & violence & depression toxic couples & tragedy & blahblah. Again: HUDSON WILLIAMS repeatedly said his characterization of Shane was partially inspired by Moonlight’s main character CHIRON, ffs.
(Calm down, guys, it’s probably just a coincidence that Rachel Reid named the Centaurs’ therapy dog Chiron from Greek mythology.)
On the surface, ofc it looks like Canadian Golden Boy of Hockey Shane with his nice parents & nice upper middle class upbringing has nothing in common with Chiron, a drug dealer from the hood, other than being closeted gay Bipocs. And by extension, it might seem like Shane has even less in common with bloodthirsty vampires prowling the night killing people.
Moonlight is a story about how toxic masculinity can negatively affect fatherless sons in desperate need of support & shelter & community; who find outlets for all of their fear & loneliness & anger in all the wrong places. They do the best with what they have, even if that forces them to totally redefine themselves on the outside to overcompensate for what society told them they lack on the inside.
And there’s SO many times I’ve thought about Moonlight not just wrt Louis DPDL’s overcompensation as a gay Black man who becomes a rough & tough pimp in NOLA, but ALSO Lestat’s upbringing in Auvergne, and WHY he felt kinship & connection with Louis, cuz he SEES himself IN Louis.
There is SO much overlap with Heated Rivalry, Moonlight, & IWTV, both on the surface level and if we did a little deeper.
SURFACE
- Adapted from books (IWTV → ML → HR)
- Repressed shy closeted man (Louis/Nicki → Chiron → Shane) falls in love with a far more outgoing & radical/brave man who wants to live/laugh/love out of the closet (Lestat → Kevin → Ilya)
- Christianity & religious themes aren’t as in your face in Moonlight
(not unless we dismantle the Black experience with religion & sexuality in America, but I think that’s going deeper than necessary for Chiron), and book!Shane was raised an atheist (“You don’t believe in God, but you believe if you put right skate on before left you will play a terrible game.”). Lestat swears he’s atheist but he’s still grappling with his lost Catholic faith; and ofc Louis’ a lapsed Catholic who thinks he can buy his way into redemption by torturing & starving himself. - Each couple struggles to be honest about their feelings, with a lot of angst-ridden counterproductive denialism & avoidance & self-sabotage
- Each couple spends more time APART and NOT together than they do WITH each other (Loustat for at least 77+yrs → Keviron for 10yrs → Hollanov for 10yrs)
- IWTV & HR frontload nudity & sex scenes cuz SEX SELLS. With ML its far more subtle, and the least explicit–it’s just one (1) handjob as teens–but a lot of the times a queer story isn’t some uber-passionate sexcapade. Sometimes all it takes is ONE soft touch, esp. in touch-starved environments where the only physical contact IS violent, and the only kindness is from found/foster families when your own ain’t ish.
DEEPER
This took me forever, so I decided to do a venn diagram instead.
I see the closest similarities with ALL these characters dealing with:
- $$$ (financial independence from their family)
- issues with their equally distant yet overbearing mothers
- absentee/hands-off fathers
- touch-starved loneliness & emotional codependence on their sole friend who’s also their male gay crush who give them affectionate nicknames (Jonah/Lestat “Saint Louis” | Kevin “Black” | Ilya “random AF Russian words” | Nicki/Louis “Wolfkiller/Les”)
- bullying by their peers (white racists | classmates | hockey players | brothers) who give them names/titles that are more like burdens (“exceptional/discrete Negro/N-word” | “Little” | “Wolfkiller” | “Golden Boy”)
- being provoked to violence till they finally snap (Racists | Classmate bully | Rink fight | 8 wolves/Rhosh)
- overcompensation for their insecurities through acting tough & macho catering to society’s toxic masculinity
This was only about SHANE, but I could’ve easily thrown Ilya into the venn diagram to turn this into the frikkin Olympic rings of LGBTQ+ angst. Esp. cuz there’s SO MUCH chatter about the more “toxic” sides of Hollanov sometimes resembling Loustat, with the more emotionally distant/cold/withholding Shane/Louis and the more manipulative/pushy/callous Ilya/Lestat; which could ofc be extended to include Shane/Louis/Chiron vs Ilya/Lestat/Kevin. 👀
The BIGGEST difference with HR & the others is that unlike Kevin & Lestat, Ilya never put his hands on Shane in violence–despite the one (1) scene in TLG where Ilya’s having a mental breakdown & punches the wall next to Shane’s head during an argument, that people try to overblow as if Ilya’s abusive.
So MISS ME with the bullcrap talk about how Heated Rivalry has nothing in common with Queer Struggle & Queer Trauma, just cuz it’s fluffy & HEA. 🙄 Cuz first off, IWTV is HEA, too–it’s only its 2nd of who knows how many seasons; but it’s based on books where Loustat DOES get an HEA married & living together in a Disney castle, which anyone who actually read the effing books would know. And with Moonlight, for all the angst & heavy topics about poverty, drugs & crime; the ending is left openly ambiguous, but with Chiron & Kevin sharing an affectionate embrace that could mean anything.
I REALLY don’t know where all this nonsense is coming from on either side of the conversation for/against Queer Joy or Queer Struggle. 😒






























