I have some thoughts on this if you don’t mind me sharing what bugs me (at least) about the memetic hold it’s had on the fandom. to be clear, I’m talking about “he/him princess” as a memetic interpretation of Wick and not as an issue with the original post. I completely understand what it’s like to make a hasty shitpost for a quick laugh that takes off and then takes on a life of its own in the fandom. so before anyone fucking @’s me about how “it’s just a joke, bro. it’s not that deep” like I haven’t been in the feminist killjoy trenches since the pre-gamergate “no girls on the internet” era and thus have never heard that one before, I don’t think the OP meant anything malicious by it nor do I think Whitney Bad for boosting something she thought was funny. I even gave it a chuckle the first time I saw it like “yeah, Wick’s a spoiled rich kid. he’s the little princess, the same way i call the kids in my toddler class little drama queens regardless of gender.” but at the end of the day, even my light-hearted jokes about toddler drama queens does not exist in a vacuum because that language like that is gendered for a reason. there is no widely used male equivalent of a drama queen for a reason. comedy is an extremely powerful rhetorical tool to reinforce social mores, and when a joke becomes popular to this degree, it’s always worth examining exactly what it is that we’re laughing at.
one last disclaimer before I begin, anything I’m about to say does not apply to my “he/him princesses” out there. if that’s how you see yourself, you’re gold. I’m more of a she/they dirtbag boyfriend, myself, but I get it. you and I are real living human beings with our own interiority and unique relationship to our performance of gender. Wicander Halovar, however, does not have any of this because he’s a fictional character. his gender can only be ascribed to him by his creator, Sam Riegel, and his performance of it can only be interpreted by the audience. therefore, examining why people are so keen to throw this label onto him that he cannot give himself is fair game.
to answer the question of “what exactly are we laughing at?”, we must first answer “why princess?” as I said earlier, I didn’t pay much mind to this joke the first time I saw it, because princess conveys a personality type, often someone who is rich, spoiled, conceited, and entitled. that being said, if we’re laughing at Wick being a snooty little rich kid, it’s worth mentioning that although it’s not his official title, Wick is already functionally a prince. if that’s the intent, there’s no reason not to just joke that he’s our special little prince, our little Lord Fauntleroy, etc, etc. so why princess, if not to say Wick is “the girl?” what do we mean by Wick is “the girl?”
the kneejerk answer is “hey, we’re just headcanoning Wick as queer/trans,” to which I respond a scrunch-nosed “are we?” I’ve seen debates in the tags about how it’s a little on the nose to headcanon Occtis as trans and while I have little to add to that discussion as I do not consider myself transmasc, I will say I don’t doubt that the majority of those headcanoning Occtis that way are transmasc themselves and see their own presentation of gender in Occtis. I can understand wanting more variety and diversity in what kind of characters are considered trans (particularly since Tumblr skews heavily white), but I fully believe this is coming from a sincere place. meanwhile, I really haven’t seen many people really interacting with Wick as a trans or nonbinary character outside of the “he/him princess” jokes, and I greatly suspect any of those who are interested in exploring that interpretation of his character are largely not the same people making these jokes. even if it were a trans headcanon, I can’t imagine many transmasc people would even be comfortable with so many people who aren’t transmasc calling a character they see as a transmasc “basically a girl,” and I can’t imagine many transfemmes would be comfortable with the joke hinging on the he/him part. obviously there’s a whole spectrum of nonbinary identities in the middle (I myself am neither transmasc nor transfemme), but again, I see very little sincere interpretations of Wick as nonbinary.
there are only two possible answers to my question of “why princess?” the first is the extremely cynical answer that these people are just using the veneer of queer language to justify their favorite character being a cis man and their favorite ship being a man and woman. to keep things as civil as possible, I have very little patience for this “the things I like are radical and woke because I’m radical and woke and I like them” circular logic bullshit. it’s the mentality of vapid cowards too preoccupied with aesthetics and preserving their own egos to do any real self-examination required to actually challenge systemic issues. they ask no questions and until they do, they will never truly understand anything they claim to value.
the second answer, which is not mutually exclusive with the first, is that this is about Wick’s gender presentation, sexuality, and general incompetence being interpreted as “feminine.” there’s no real way around this that does not rely on a certain level of repackaged misogyny and homophobia. enough dancing around, Wick is “the girl” because he is a slight and squishy support caster. Wick is “the girl” because he is nice, unworldly, and a virgin. Wick is “the girl” because he needs to be protected and taken care of, because he’s bisexual and not “butch” like Teor, because he’s hesitant to hurt others and values forgiveness. and instead of interrogating how absolutely none of these things are nor should be consider being at odds with being a man, he is “the girl.” he is a “woman to me.” he’s just a “he/him princess.” lol, isn’t that funny? isn’t that radical? Tyranny’s the boy in this relationship even though a good chunk of those things are also true about her!! but like, someone has to be the boy!!! she’s gonna dom and peg him!!! that’s so funny!!! he’s the submissive because only women get penetrated and he’s a failure of a man!!! feminism has won!!!! straight marriage is illegal!!!! I can’t publicly date women anymore or even be out at my job where i make less than $14/hr and work over forty hours a week because I’m scared I’ll be labeled a sexual predator by bigoted fascists!!!!!
ahem, crushing realities and bleak futures aside, this is nothing new to the Critical Role fandom. the jokes about resident special girl Imogen being a bit of a loser were funny when she was falling down stairs and thumb wrestling against herself while Fearne and Chetney ran off to have a threesome, but they quickly got stale when they became more attached to her being a woman than Imogen as an individual just kinda being an awkward dork. similarly, the beauyasha disaster lesbians jokes were kinda funny at first, but then this idea that they were “useless lesbians” “too gay to function” became an inescapable meme about their characters even during more serious moments, which simply wasn’t true and irritating for fans of Beau and Yasha as individuals as well as the shippers to deal with over and over. it ran its course and the joke wasn’t funny anymore because it relied too much on misogyny and homophobia and those who latched onto it were all too eager to double down on that aspect. you can have the best intentions, but jokes that play to common biases will always catch on for a reason.
I opened by saying I found the joke relatively harmless at first and admitting that I, too, call my toddlers drama queens when they’re throwing an obviously fake fit because I gently redirected them from throwing their shoes in the dirty diaper trash. I’m probably still going to slip up and call them little drama queens again at some point in the future. but that doesn’t mean that the term drama queen isn’t gendered, and it doesn’t make it not sexist just because I would much rather think of myself as a feminist. it doesnt mean I’m not, on some level, telling a small child who’s just starting to learn the very basic fundamentals of concepts like language and identity to cut it out because he’s acting like a girl and that’s bad. it just means I’m not above having to check myself, and neither is anyone else. but after writing this, I’ll probably go into work tomorrow and try not to say it for a good while. and that’s a step, at least, and it’s a step only possible by thinking about what jokes we tell and questioning what we’re laughing at. I say all this because the language of social justice is not a cudgel to wield against people and things I don’t like, nor is it a tool to rationalize the things I already like as Ethically Good, Actually. if i want to affect change, I have to be willing to put my ego aside and interrogate myself because nothing exists in a vacuum. or to put it terms the people who need to hear this the most will understand: everybody get more woke right now.