Emily May's Reviews > Pachinko

Pachinko by Min Jin Lee
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4622890
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: historical, 2017

History has failed us, but no matter.

Look, I get it. A lot of people won't be interested in this book because they have no idea what pachinko means and what exactly is going on with that cover, anyway? We are highly susceptible to marketing techniques and the cover and title give us pretty much nothing. But hear me out for a minute because this book is really good.

This is a historical family saga set in Korea and Japan throughout the 20th century. It follows four generations of a Korean family through the political turmoil of Japanese colonization, the hardship of wartimes, seeking a new and better life in Japan, and witnessing the home they left become divided into two countries they hardly recognize.

As someone who knows very little about Korean history, this book was absolutely fascinating. Rich, detailed characterization draws us into the lives of these people and, at least for me, teaches us a chapter of modern history we might not have been aware of.

Many Koreans found themselves forced to move to Japan to find jobs for their families, but they faced discrimination and disgusting living conditions when they arrived. Pachinko, we soon find out, is a kind of Japanese arcade game, and working in a pachinko parlor was considered a typical job for a Korean looking to get ahead. Many Japanese looked down upon pachinko parlor workers, viewing them as shady and dishonest - or just, you know, Korean.
And this is something Solomon must understand. We can be deported. We have no motherland. Life is full of things he cannot control so he must adapt. My boy has to survive.

It was both interesting and deeply saddening to hear about what these people went through, how easy it was for Koreans to be imprisoned indefinitely without trial. And after years of hardship and discrimination, after pushing through and finally earning enough money to have stability, many could never go back. Korean-Japanese (third, fourth, fifth generation even) were refused citizenship in Japan but most came from North Korea, a place they could no longer safely return to.

This is both a fictional and a true story. The fictional characters the author creates come sparking off the page - from the resilient Sunja who once foolishly believed in the love of an older man, to Noa who will never quite recover from the dishonor of his lineage, to Solomon who is still trying to escape the negative stereotypes associated with Koreans many years after his grandmother arrived in Japan. And it is a true story because much of this book was the reality for many Koreans.

A deeply affecting read and a look at an area of history oft-forgotten outside of East Asia.

Blog | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram | Youtube
3074 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Pachinko.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 9, 2017 – Shelved
September 4, 2017 – Started Reading
September 6, 2017 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 98 (98 new)


Sara Interested to see what your comments are about this. I'm trying to read more novels set/based in Korea.


Emily May Sara wrote: "Interested to see what your comments are about this. I'm trying to read more novels set/based in Korea."

I thought it was really good. It's a family saga and they're my favourite :)


message 3: by [deleted user] (new)

Sara, it is really good you should read it!


message 4: by Fuzaila (new)

Fuzaila This sounds like Honolulu by Alen Brennert which I absolutely loved! Your review is all the more reason to pick it up ☺


Heather Aislinn This book was amazing


message 6: by Sadie (new) - added it

Sadie Have this on my shelf but haven't read it. Glad you enjoyed!


message 7: by Kat (new) - added it

Kat I noticed, that it's untypical in Europe (that's where I live ^^) to read or even learn about Asia (I know Asia is big, but it feels like I really know nothing about it at ALL). I want to change it, but I find it hard to find books about "it". Thanks for the recommendation, hopefully I get to read it!


Emily May Kat wrote: "I noticed, that it's untypical in Europe (that's where I live ^^) to read or even learn about Asia (I know Asia is big, but it feels like I really know nothing about it at ALL). I want to change it..."

It is atypical in the UK, at least until high school level. I didn't learn anything about South or East Asia until university, which is really sad.


message 9: by Laura (new) - added it

Laura I love multicultural books, and you are right, I would not have picked it up from the title, or the cover. How cool.


message 10: by Katie (new)

Katie I love your reviews, and how much effort you put into them. I always come away feeling as if I've learned something after them.


Kim N. Le Thanks for the review! I've been on the fence about this one for a while and will definitely give it a try. Xx -Kim


message 12: by Silver Faerie (new)

Silver Faerie Oohh, I'll have to look into this one! I recently moved to Japan, and it would be interesting to learn about the Pachinko places. They're kind of everywhere in my area.


message 13: by M. (new) - rated it 4 stars

M. I'm so glad you liked this book because I absolutely loved it!


message 14: by Susan (new) - added it

Susan We lived in Japan when I was little and brought a Pachinko machine home with us. Complicated vertical pinball. I never knew there was a whole cultural history to the game.


message 15: by (new)

Lé Instead of just almost angrily assuming that we don't know what "pachinko" means, couldn't you explain it to us so we get more informed and interested?


Emily May Katie wrote: "I love your reviews, and how much effort you put into them. I always come away feeling as if I've learned something after them."

Thank you so much ^_^


Emily May Lé wrote: "Instead of just almost angrily assuming that we don't know what "pachinko" means, couldn't you explain it to us so we get more informed and interested?"

Why don't you come back after reading the full review? And there was nothing angry about my comment, lol. I was saying I understood it ¯\_(ツ)_/¯


message 18: by Mermaid (new)

Mermaid I always try to be as detailed in my reviews as you are in your reviews and every time I finish reading another one of your reviews I feel as if I have yet to get anywhere near your status! 😭


Emily May Mermaid wrote: "I always try to be as detailed in my reviews as you are in your reviews and every time I finish reading another one of your reviews I feel as if I have yet to get anywhere near your status! 😭"

Thank you! Though I'm sure it's not true. You should see how terrible my early reviews were (actually no, don't go looking for them, lol).


message 20: by Imogen (new) - added it

Imogen I was reading this review on my timeline and didn't notice who had written it, all the way through I was thinking 'this is the kind of book Emily May would love' lol


Kurien It's a first time read of this author for me,and I found the book moving and one of the best on Korea I have read,...


Polly-Alida I had exactly the same reaction to the cover and title. But I had a netgalley copy, so i did know what it was about. Nice review!


message 23: by Shaila (new) - added it

Shaila I am a voracious reader of all Japonica, fiction, non fiction, however this is the first I've come across of the Korean experience in Japan. Excited to read in light of the 21 century where Korea's economy and influence is on the rise as Japan's is more in a twilight.


message 24: by Jeho Jay (new) - added it

Jeho Jay Yoo I tentatively claim that for last 100 years, Korea may have the most brutal, disgusting, bizzare and heartbreaking history in the world. Even those countless world war stories cannot match the level of brutalness and misery. Thank you for your review, I really enjoyed reading it. :)


message 25: by Louise (new)

Louise Grey I didn't really have an issue with the title, the subject matter alone was what interested me. It's a subject matter that is very relevant today as tensions are still fraught between these two East Asian nations, especially around certain topics. I'm eager to see the author's historical interpretation in her book.


Jrmiracle I always enjoy your reviews!


message 27: by Sherril (new) - added it

Sherril I have had this book on my to read list for a while. After reading your review, I will be closer to getting to it. Thanks.


message 28: by Rae (new) - rated it 4 stars

Rae Great review, Emily. Just began reading this book mainly due to your review. I'm glad you clarified the meaning of Pachinko. Since I know very little about this area of history, you've convinced me that it should be a fascinating read. Thanks for the nudge in this direction.


message 29: by Sam (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sam toer Thank you Emily for an enlightening review. I will definitely get the book.


message 30: by Chris (new)

Chris I was interested in your review since I recently completed "A River in Darkness" by Masaji Ishikawa. It also talked of the difficulties of the Koreans in Japan and how the were lured back to North Korea and the difficulties they found there.


Emily May Chris wrote: "I was interested in your review since I recently completed "A River in Darkness" by Masaji Ishikawa. It also talked of the difficulties of the Koreans in Japan and how the were lured back to North ..."

I recently finished Ishikawa's memoir, too, and I said in my review that I thought it complemented what I'd already learned in Pachinko, as well as in Nothing to Envy: Ordinary Lives in North Korea. All great books.


Margaret McLaughlin What a condescending comment to make that many people wouldn’t like the book because they don’t understand what pachinko means. I know what pachinko means and I didn’t like the book.


Emily May Margaret wrote: "What a condescending comment to make that many people wouldn’t like the book because they don’t understand what pachinko means. I know what pachinko means and I didn’t like the book."

That's literally not what I said at all. Try reading it again. I said that many people wouldn't be interested in reading this because the cover and title are meaningless to them-- as in, they would never pick it up, not that they would like or dislike it. There are many reasons one might dislike a book.

Also, "many" or "a lot of" (what I actually said) does not in any way mean "all". Seeing as I was including myself in those people who had no idea what pachinko meant prior to reading this, I don't know what's condescending about it.


Carol Moyer I had no idea what Pachinco was and only picked it up to read because it was my book club pick. I loved this book and found it hard to put down. So happy I learned something new about a culture I knew little about.


Robin Reilly I’ve read your review post reading the book. Now I need to get my hands on A River in Darkness...


message 36: by Howard (new) - added it

Howard P Excellent review. I don’t usually read Historical Fiction (oxymoron). I’m a history & non-fiction reader. Though I do read some fiction, every now and then. Well, after reading your review I want to read Pachinko. Thanks for your review.


message 37: by Sam (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sam toer Emily, I was one of the people who were not interested in this book because "they have no idea what pachinko means and what exactly is going on with that cover". After reading your insightful and informative review I "heard you out for a minute", got my hands on the book and read it in one sitting. I just loved it. I don't agree with what Margaret called "a condescending comment" and I felt I should say something about it. I did not sense any condescending or snobbish attitude in what you wrote. Besides, I don't like it when people like Margaret distort what other people say. I understand her reaction to a book she didn't like but she should not take it on you. I thought your response to her was too polite. You should be a little more punchy. I follow your reviews and your bookgeek blog and I find them quite interesting and thoughtful. Keep up with the good work and don't let people like Margaret discourage you.


message 38: by Donna (new)

Donna I was familiar with the game/machine. If you want to read a true story of a little girl, abandoned to fend for herself in war torn Korea, you wont beat this:
Check out this book on Goodreads: She Is Mine: A War Orphan's Incredible Journey of Survival https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1...


Virginia Thanks, Erin. I am starting it now.


message 40: by Joyce (new) - added it

Joyce Hi, All! I believe a Pachinko machine is an electronic arcade game where there is a silver ball that is hit by the player, and can then ping and bounce around various areas of the game before finally either resting on the bottom, or going into a specific area or hole in the game surface. Different areas/holes give you different amounts of points. If my recollection is correct, maybe the author is using the idea of a pachinko machine to express how the characters are 'bounced around' between places and fall into holes, and it is not completely dependent on just their skills, but what they bounce around on and where, exactly, they hit on different areas, which would ping them off in different directions. In other words, they (the silver ball) have no choice in where they go, and what the outcome may be as a result....they also never stay in one place, but are constantly moving?
Does any of this make sense to anyone? I sometimes struggle with taking a thought or knowing thought and then putting words to it in such a way that other people might understand what I'm getting at.


Alina I. Morera After reading Emily’s review I now want to read this book! I love historical fiction.


Margaux You convinced me to read this book! Thank you for your post!


message 43: by Leslie (new) - added it

Leslie Thank you for such a wonderful review. I was on the fence of whether to give this book a try. Like “Those Who Save Us” I like a novel that teaches us about a part of society that we would never hear about. I now have added it to my want to read list.


713saintsfan Emily said it best so no need for me to write a review. Very interesting story. Great read.


Deanna Jantzen The cover track a pinball machine, zigging and zagging...


Komal Khanna Interesting


Bonnie Thank you Emily for a very good in depth review. You got to the meat of the book. I totally enjoyed it too and learned so much. You might like the recent book Nothing to Envy.


message 48: by melu428 (new) - added it

melu428 I saw that you gave Pachinko 5 stars and I had to add it to my TBR!


Catherine M. Boling I found the story riveting at first and then I became bored. Dragged. Good news, bad news. Like most (generations of) families.


message 50: by Lara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lara Nice review Emily. I enjoyed this book a lot.


« previous 1
back to top