Luke's Reviews > Native Son
Native Son
by
by
Luke's review
bookshelves: books-are-the-best-invention, 5-star, reviewed, cross-my-heart-and-hope-to-die, person-of-everything, r-2013, r-goodreads, antidote-think-twice-read, antidote-think-twice-all, best-update
May 18, 2013
bookshelves: books-are-the-best-invention, 5-star, reviewed, cross-my-heart-and-hope-to-die, person-of-everything, r-2013, r-goodreads, antidote-think-twice-read, antidote-think-twice-all, best-update
Have you heard the name Trayvon Martin? If you have, good. If you haven’t, look him up. Open a tab, search up the name, T-R-A-Y-V-O-N etc, and read. Familiarize yourself with the exact definitions of the atrocity, the scope of the repercussions throughout the US, the up and currently running process of rectification that in a fair and just world would not be as excruciatingly slow and painful as it’s turning out to be. In a fair and just world, he would not be one of countless mown down for everything but a valid reason.
This is not a fair and just world.
No, this is a world where we have those who profess to be not only good writers deserving of literary rewards, but good teachers of writing to boot, despite bigoting their scope of literature down to the basic principle of whom they identify with based on parameters such as gender, sexuality, and color of skin.
Do you know what that sort of mentality would leave me, reading this book? Do you know which character I was expected to perfectly align with, the one most feasible for the goal of sewing myself up in the skin and riding around in perfect harmony? The young white girl, so filled with highflown aspirations of social justice, so loaded with easy income, so filthy with white privilege, who is suffocated and mutilated and burned up into a few fragments of bone and a single earring.
Tell me, then, oh wise teacher, keeper of books and innate sense of good literature, white, middle-aged, heterosexual, the banality of character, the default of personalization, the one archetype for whom nearly the whole of literature has been customized for and has never known what it means to eke out an empathetic terrain on the basis of understanding, not physicality. Even here, in this book written by a black man, you have an overwhelming majority in terms of representation, what with your Buckley, your Max, your multitudes of Klu Klux Klan and crowds and judges all in a big fat white male world. While I have a single soul, a Mary Dalton.
What the fuck am I supposed to do with her, this small, pretty, idiot girl who knows nothing of the agony she is sustained by, and thinks herself kind and generous by reaching out to those her very skin tone persecutes and compromising their existence with a single moment of stupidly inane trust? What am I supposed to do with this pompously fulfilled imbecile, this suicidally naïve prat who innocently frames her words out of what she perceives as an intention of kindness, treating the other as an animal when she notices their plight and accessory ensuring her comfortable existence when she returns to her natural state of self-righteous ignorance?
For you know, teacher, in spite of all that deficiencies on her part, there is a case to be made when it comes to the casual abuse and even more casual conformation of mind and soul of countless women in the history of both reality and literature. Saintly virgin, blighted whore, girlfriend in a refrigerator, all objects used with unconscious persistence of augmenting the male reality, the male realization, the male point of view. You may not know, teacher, with your blatant refusal to even consider reading literature on the other side of the curtain of your all too male sensibilities, but that is not how woman are. That is not how I am, and as such it would be all too easy to resonate with Bessie and Mary above all others, young women there and gone in a swift spending of their use in the pursuit of a story of a young and violent man.
Tell me, in light of that, should I hate Bigger Thomas? Should I spit on him and his indomitable pride of living, one that will not be blinded to the misery of him and his people no matter how much they beg and plead? Should I ignore his anger, his shame, his fearful panic in the face of living cut and dried at every second, every year, every century that his ancestors were first wrenched away from their homeland and have suffered in inhuman bondage ever since? Should I withhold my empathy for someone who looks the reality of his existence in the face, dregging out his life in a country that rapes him into a corner and sees that as the way it ought to be? Should I refuse to recognize the effects of a neverending amputation of the self’s expression onto the wider plane of life and living, the horrible consequences that can and will result so long as oppression stamps its broken and bloody way across ethics and humanity?
Should I close my ears to the integrity of Max, the manipulation of Buckley, not chase the slightest bit of critical analysis of the two and their diatribes, all because I cannot relate in terms of simple physicality? Above all, should I have not even embarked on this book written by Richard Wright, because somehow I ‘knew’ that I wouldn’t relate because of the differences the author and I have in terms of skin and gender?
Tell me, teacher, although it’s unlikely you would ever deserve the title no matter how much writing you did. Would you have me stuff myself into a box that will cradle me with familiar blindness forevermore? Would you have me tie myself down to the identity of someone like poor Mary Dalton, the little fool, and rightfully suffer for it? For I will never know what it means on a visceral level to be black, male, and in the United States, pushed past the farthest boundaries of humanity by centuries of systematic oppression of an entire people into a barren void where right and wrong squeak along with the voices of ghosts. But I do know how to read, as well as listen. I do know how to write, as well as think. I do know, in the fundamental ache of my self, what it means to be a human being.
Do you know that last one, teacher? I doubt it.
This is not a fair and just world.
No, this is a world where we have those who profess to be not only good writers deserving of literary rewards, but good teachers of writing to boot, despite bigoting their scope of literature down to the basic principle of whom they identify with based on parameters such as gender, sexuality, and color of skin.
Do you know what that sort of mentality would leave me, reading this book? Do you know which character I was expected to perfectly align with, the one most feasible for the goal of sewing myself up in the skin and riding around in perfect harmony? The young white girl, so filled with highflown aspirations of social justice, so loaded with easy income, so filthy with white privilege, who is suffocated and mutilated and burned up into a few fragments of bone and a single earring.
Tell me, then, oh wise teacher, keeper of books and innate sense of good literature, white, middle-aged, heterosexual, the banality of character, the default of personalization, the one archetype for whom nearly the whole of literature has been customized for and has never known what it means to eke out an empathetic terrain on the basis of understanding, not physicality. Even here, in this book written by a black man, you have an overwhelming majority in terms of representation, what with your Buckley, your Max, your multitudes of Klu Klux Klan and crowds and judges all in a big fat white male world. While I have a single soul, a Mary Dalton.
What the fuck am I supposed to do with her, this small, pretty, idiot girl who knows nothing of the agony she is sustained by, and thinks herself kind and generous by reaching out to those her very skin tone persecutes and compromising their existence with a single moment of stupidly inane trust? What am I supposed to do with this pompously fulfilled imbecile, this suicidally naïve prat who innocently frames her words out of what she perceives as an intention of kindness, treating the other as an animal when she notices their plight and accessory ensuring her comfortable existence when she returns to her natural state of self-righteous ignorance?
For you know, teacher, in spite of all that deficiencies on her part, there is a case to be made when it comes to the casual abuse and even more casual conformation of mind and soul of countless women in the history of both reality and literature. Saintly virgin, blighted whore, girlfriend in a refrigerator, all objects used with unconscious persistence of augmenting the male reality, the male realization, the male point of view. You may not know, teacher, with your blatant refusal to even consider reading literature on the other side of the curtain of your all too male sensibilities, but that is not how woman are. That is not how I am, and as such it would be all too easy to resonate with Bessie and Mary above all others, young women there and gone in a swift spending of their use in the pursuit of a story of a young and violent man.
Tell me, in light of that, should I hate Bigger Thomas? Should I spit on him and his indomitable pride of living, one that will not be blinded to the misery of him and his people no matter how much they beg and plead? Should I ignore his anger, his shame, his fearful panic in the face of living cut and dried at every second, every year, every century that his ancestors were first wrenched away from their homeland and have suffered in inhuman bondage ever since? Should I withhold my empathy for someone who looks the reality of his existence in the face, dregging out his life in a country that rapes him into a corner and sees that as the way it ought to be? Should I refuse to recognize the effects of a neverending amputation of the self’s expression onto the wider plane of life and living, the horrible consequences that can and will result so long as oppression stamps its broken and bloody way across ethics and humanity?
Should I close my ears to the integrity of Max, the manipulation of Buckley, not chase the slightest bit of critical analysis of the two and their diatribes, all because I cannot relate in terms of simple physicality? Above all, should I have not even embarked on this book written by Richard Wright, because somehow I ‘knew’ that I wouldn’t relate because of the differences the author and I have in terms of skin and gender?
Tell me, teacher, although it’s unlikely you would ever deserve the title no matter how much writing you did. Would you have me stuff myself into a box that will cradle me with familiar blindness forevermore? Would you have me tie myself down to the identity of someone like poor Mary Dalton, the little fool, and rightfully suffer for it? For I will never know what it means on a visceral level to be black, male, and in the United States, pushed past the farthest boundaries of humanity by centuries of systematic oppression of an entire people into a barren void where right and wrong squeak along with the voices of ghosts. But I do know how to read, as well as listen. I do know how to write, as well as think. I do know, in the fundamental ache of my self, what it means to be a human being.
Do you know that last one, teacher? I doubt it.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Native Son.
Sign In »
Quotes Luke Liked
“But rape was not what one did to women. Rape was what one felt when one's back was against the wall and one had to strike out, whether one wanted to or not, to keep the pack from killing one. He committed rape every time he looked into a white face. He was a long, taut piece of rubber which a thousand white hands had stretched to the snapping point, and when he snapped it was rape. But it was rape when he cried out in hate deep in his heart as he felt the strain of living day by day. That, too, was rape.”
― Native Son
― Native Son
Reading Progress
May 18, 2013
– Shelved as:
to-read
May 18, 2013
– Shelved
September 23, 2013
–
Started Reading
September 23, 2013
–
0.0%
"Hey, Goodreads. Instead of banning, how about reading? You know, a gesture of solidarity instead of oppression. It is Banned Books Week, after all."
page
0
September 24, 2013
–
14.32%
"I don't know what pisses me off more: the fact that none of my English teachers had me read this book, or that, if they had, younger self would have completely missed the fucking point.
Making up for major amounts of lost time and past ignorance here."
page
57
Making up for major amounts of lost time and past ignorance here."
September 26, 2013
–
25.63%
"Bigger felt that a lot of people were like Mrs. Dalton, blind..."
page
102
September 28, 2013
–
53.77%
"But rape was not what one did to women. Rape was what one felt when one's back was against the wall and one had to strike out, whether one wanted to or not, to keep the pack from killing one. He committed rape every time he looked into a white face. He was a long, taut piece of rubber which a thousand white hands had stretched to the snapping point, and when he snapped it was rape. But it was rape when he cried..."
page
214
September 28, 2013
–
82.41%
""But still, you wanted to be happy?"
"Yeah; sure. Everybody wants to be happy, I reckon.""
page
328
"Yeah; sure. Everybody wants to be happy, I reckon.""
September 29, 2013
–
90.95%
"And to Mary Dalton, if she can hear me, I say: 'I stand here today trying to make your death mean something!'"
page
362
September 29, 2013
– Shelved as:
books-are-the-best-invention
September 29, 2013
– Shelved as:
5-star
September 29, 2013
– Shelved as:
reviewed
September 29, 2013
–
Finished Reading
September 30, 2013
– Shelved as:
cross-my-heart-and-hope-to-die
December 8, 2013
– Shelved as:
person-of-everything
April 26, 2014
– Shelved as:
r-2013
September 16, 2014
– Shelved as:
r-goodreads
June 24, 2015
– Shelved as:
antidote-think-twice-read
December 17, 2015
– Shelved as:
antidote-think-twice-all
August 24, 2025
– Shelved as:
best-update
Comments Showing 1-17 of 17 (17 new)
date
newest »
newest »
Simply astounding, Aubrey. You have managed to turn your anger into a thing of beauty, and that's an impressive feat!
@Tej: Thank you very much, and don't fret. The US is not the world, no matter how much some like to pretend, and I don't expect everyone 'round the globe to be intimately familiar with a single country's news.@Brain: Awwww. You're too sweet.
@Nick: Indeed. Thank you for that, I hadn't known about the incident previously.
@Lisa: Thank you, I do try.
Thank you for this, Aubrey. I too was deprived this during my formative years. Thank you for making the Trayvon connection—the entire incident and verdict caused much unrest & is a lingering pain. Angela Corey, the state attorney assigned to that case, was also involved in another controversial case dealing with the same "Stand Your Ground" law, fortunately Marissa Alexander is getting a retrial. Check out Gil Scott-Heron's novels for more stylistically experimental explorations of racial tensions in 20th century America. I read his memoir earlier this year and it was good.
I dashed off a response which escaped to the ether. The crux of which said that certainly misdeeds from Fred Hampton to Rodney King have affected our readings of Native Son, yet I find Wright's exercise to be an appropiation of Crime and Punishment to his own political and naturalistic agenda: I find this closer to Dreiser and Norris than Ralph Ellison.I will elaborate if needed. I should admit that I've been tippling this afternoon.
ha! of course that is true but as the things are, the bag is full and much more vicious (only limitedly reported) as regards similar incidents of religious, caste, sexual, ethnic, and several other imaginable and unimaginable bigotries. It is like we are yoked over here and obliged to look straight ahead, with lateral vision utterly blocked.... if we divert our vision too much, wonder the forward motion is ever possible.... without a semblance of numbness!!!
Excellent review , Aubrey! It was quite brave of you to mention 'Travyon Martin'. He deserved a fair trial.The whole incident just didn't make sense at all.I'm not aware of the detailed trial proceedings but the 'self-defense' acquittal was utter bullshit! Thanks, once again for a fantastic review.
@Rand: I'm glad that you found the review so meaningful, and must thank you both the recommendations and for the information you provided. I'm glad to hear that Marissa Alexander is getting a retrial, as hers is another case that I've been following for some time, and this is the best news I've heard concerning it yet.@Jonfaith: All writers appropriate, and all writers have agendas. Whether they pull it off or not and give the reader something worth reading is what is really at stake here, and I personally see Native Son as one of the best books I have come across thus far.
@Praj: Thank you very much, and was it brave? I suppose someone on the Internet could disagree and say as such, but frankly, I'm not here to make friends. It's a nice side effect of writing, of course, but when it comes to books like this, mincing words is the last thing on my mind.
@Praj: Thank you very much, and was it brave? I suppose someone on the Internet could disagree and say as such, but frankly, I'm not here to make friends. It's a nice side effect of writing, of course, but when it comes to books like this, mincing words is the last thing on my mindA candid opinion on controversial topics has always been put on a “with me or against me” binary stand without finding a middle ground resulting in resistance of honesty. Thus, to be able to take an sincere stand on a public platform, to me equates courage.
Ah, in that case, Praj, thank you. I've seen the claim of neutrality too often devolve into meaningless garble one too many times, and if I had to make the choice, I would either say what I thought, or admit ignorance. Either one leaves me a chance to hear arguments, input that I will not hide from behind the mask of neutrality for any sort of 'peace of mind'.
Such a brilliant piece of writing, Aubrey. Just as always. "Should I ignore his anger, his shame, his fearful panic in the face of living cut and dried at every second, every year, every century that his ancestors were first wrenched away from their homeland and have suffered in inhuman bondage ever since?Should I withhold my empathy for someone who looks the reality of his existence in the face, dregging out his life in a country that rapes him into a corner and sees that as the way it ought to be?" - Excellent way to put it.
I have been following the Travyon Martin case from the beginning. And I so hated seeing Zimmerman's smug face after the judge pronounced him not guilty (but wasn't he recently arrested again for assaulting his wife/brandishing a weapon again?).
When I had first learnt about the Ku Klux Klan from Grisham's A Time to Kill, I was shocked out of my wits. It's a little sad to see a country noted for its broad-mindedness when it comes to providing opportunities to immigrants and citizens alike, could also harbor such latent fanatical tendencies. But I suppose there's the good and there's the bad in everything, America being no exception.
Wow, Aubrey, this book just smacked you in the face. What an interesting review and what a fascinating reaction! The more people that read you, the better this world will be.
@Samadrita: Thank you very much. Yes, Zimmerman's been arrested again, and will likely be getting in trouble for spending money donated to his defense on rent and the like. And yes, America has a sordid history just like any other country. It admittedly does some things right, but there's always been a violently hypocritical reactionary movement resisting humane progress from the very beginning, and it's likely to survive so long as the country persists. Land of the free, it calls itself, founded on the genocide of a multitude of cultures and enslavement of another countless host of nations. Always a healthy thing to keep in mind.@Reem: Thank you very much, and yes, it did. My hopes are that the people who read me will go on to read the book, and then maybe there'll be a chance of a better world.
@Elizabeth: Ha ha, thank you very much. I certainly did my best to do so.





This is a powerful review, Aubrey... Thank You for introducing this book to me!