Candi's Reviews > Orbital
Orbital
by
by
“The mind is in a dayless freak zone, surfing earth’s hurtling horizon. Day is here, and then they see night come upon them like the shadow of a cloud racing over a wheat field. Forty-five minutes later here comes day again, stampeding across the Pacific. Nothing is what they thought it was.”
This beautifully written novel about six men and women orbiting earth for nine months confirmed how I feel daily – that conflicting sense that in the grand scheme of things, I matter not at all and also very much. If you’re looking for a space adventure filled with tension, science and action, then this book won’t satisfy you on those terms. What Samantha Harvey has penned is cerebral and contemplative. Despite the speed at which these characters orbit earth (sixteen orbits in one day), the pace of the book is quite slow. It’s a slim book that made me slow down my reading so I could reflect on my own thoughts, my own purpose. The reverence held by these astronauts and cosmonauts for the earth is palpable and sublimely illustrated through Harvey’s prose. It sometimes veers towards the sensual, which I liked.
“You could never really comprehend the stars, but the earth you could know in the way you know another person, in the way he came quite studiedly and determinedly to know his wife. With a yearning that’s hungry and selfish. He wishes to know it, inch by inch.”
We spend a small amount of time with each of these characters. We view the mundaneness of their daily orbiting lives. We learn of the effects of microgravity on their bodies, the psychological effects of viewing their home planet from above and the infinite vastness of outer space from their spacecraft windows. Their backgrounds are revealed to us. We catch glimpses of their relationships on earth, how they are coping with being away from family. We understand a bit about their relationships with one another. Harvey doesn’t preach to the reader about the existence or non-existence of a God or some higher being. She does show us, however, through a couple of her characters at least, how views differ about the idea of creation.
“She’d point out of the port and starboard windows where the darkness is endless and ferocious. Where solar systems and galaxies are violently scattered… Look, she’d say. What made that but some heedless hurling beautiful force? And he would point… and he would say: what made that but some heedful hurling beautiful force? Is that all the difference there is between their views, then – a bit of heed?... The difference seems both trivial and insurmountable.”
Despite the obvious limitations and costs, perhaps if every single person on this planet (or maybe our world leaders for a start) could be launched into space for a several month orbit of the earth, more people would come away realizing the hubris of their vanities, desires and greed. The reliance on one another for survival and companionship, despite nationalities and belief systems, might convince a few of them, at least, that this is in essence, all about humanity. Man-made borders do not exist from space, and to survive on this planet governed by the violent forces of nature, this planet that is just a minuscule part, a tiny “dot” existing within an entire universe, one might truly grasp the truth that this is not an “us versus them” scenario. We might realize this on an intellectual level, but for some reason it seems to stay in the head and not truly felt. I suppose experience is the best teacher.
“You’ll see no countries, just a rolling indivisible globe which knows no possibility of separation, yet alone war. And you’ll feel yourself pulled in two directions at once. Exhilaration, anxiety, rapture, depression, tenderness, anger, hope, despair. Because of course you know that war abounds and that borders are something that people will kill and die for.”
I truly admired this book for the way it made me think. Not that these are completely original ideas. I’ve thought about our tiny planet in the grand scheme of things. I’ve considered my own place and purpose and usefulness plenty of times. Having this kind of reminder and absorbing the beauty of Samantha Harvey’s writing craft doesn’t hurt though. One thing I felt lacking was a fully realized connection to any of the characters. Harvey managed to convey her ideas through them effectively, yet I found them to be simply that – vehicles for these ideas. Ideas that I fully respect and agree with, but just the same I would have loved this even more had I been shown more depth of her characters. Perhaps the length of the novel had something to do with this. In only 200 pages, one can’t share the intellectual ideas and develop six main characters to the extent that I crave. That’s not a criticism but a personal preference. I still highly recommend this novel to anyone that loves to meditate about his or her place on this planet. Or anyone that thinks they are above all that – but those vain creatures won’t touch a book like this with a ten-foot pole!
“And in time we come to see that not only are we on the sidelines of the universe but that it’s of a universe of sidelines, that there is no centre, just a giddy mass of waltzing things, and that perhaps the entirety of our understanding consists of an elaborate and ever-evolving knowledge of our own extraneousness, a bashing away of mankind’s ego by the instruments of scientific enquiry until it is, that ego, a shattered edifice that lets light through.”
This beautifully written novel about six men and women orbiting earth for nine months confirmed how I feel daily – that conflicting sense that in the grand scheme of things, I matter not at all and also very much. If you’re looking for a space adventure filled with tension, science and action, then this book won’t satisfy you on those terms. What Samantha Harvey has penned is cerebral and contemplative. Despite the speed at which these characters orbit earth (sixteen orbits in one day), the pace of the book is quite slow. It’s a slim book that made me slow down my reading so I could reflect on my own thoughts, my own purpose. The reverence held by these astronauts and cosmonauts for the earth is palpable and sublimely illustrated through Harvey’s prose. It sometimes veers towards the sensual, which I liked.
“You could never really comprehend the stars, but the earth you could know in the way you know another person, in the way he came quite studiedly and determinedly to know his wife. With a yearning that’s hungry and selfish. He wishes to know it, inch by inch.”
We spend a small amount of time with each of these characters. We view the mundaneness of their daily orbiting lives. We learn of the effects of microgravity on their bodies, the psychological effects of viewing their home planet from above and the infinite vastness of outer space from their spacecraft windows. Their backgrounds are revealed to us. We catch glimpses of their relationships on earth, how they are coping with being away from family. We understand a bit about their relationships with one another. Harvey doesn’t preach to the reader about the existence or non-existence of a God or some higher being. She does show us, however, through a couple of her characters at least, how views differ about the idea of creation.
“She’d point out of the port and starboard windows where the darkness is endless and ferocious. Where solar systems and galaxies are violently scattered… Look, she’d say. What made that but some heedless hurling beautiful force? And he would point… and he would say: what made that but some heedful hurling beautiful force? Is that all the difference there is between their views, then – a bit of heed?... The difference seems both trivial and insurmountable.”
Despite the obvious limitations and costs, perhaps if every single person on this planet (or maybe our world leaders for a start) could be launched into space for a several month orbit of the earth, more people would come away realizing the hubris of their vanities, desires and greed. The reliance on one another for survival and companionship, despite nationalities and belief systems, might convince a few of them, at least, that this is in essence, all about humanity. Man-made borders do not exist from space, and to survive on this planet governed by the violent forces of nature, this planet that is just a minuscule part, a tiny “dot” existing within an entire universe, one might truly grasp the truth that this is not an “us versus them” scenario. We might realize this on an intellectual level, but for some reason it seems to stay in the head and not truly felt. I suppose experience is the best teacher.
“You’ll see no countries, just a rolling indivisible globe which knows no possibility of separation, yet alone war. And you’ll feel yourself pulled in two directions at once. Exhilaration, anxiety, rapture, depression, tenderness, anger, hope, despair. Because of course you know that war abounds and that borders are something that people will kill and die for.”
I truly admired this book for the way it made me think. Not that these are completely original ideas. I’ve thought about our tiny planet in the grand scheme of things. I’ve considered my own place and purpose and usefulness plenty of times. Having this kind of reminder and absorbing the beauty of Samantha Harvey’s writing craft doesn’t hurt though. One thing I felt lacking was a fully realized connection to any of the characters. Harvey managed to convey her ideas through them effectively, yet I found them to be simply that – vehicles for these ideas. Ideas that I fully respect and agree with, but just the same I would have loved this even more had I been shown more depth of her characters. Perhaps the length of the novel had something to do with this. In only 200 pages, one can’t share the intellectual ideas and develop six main characters to the extent that I crave. That’s not a criticism but a personal preference. I still highly recommend this novel to anyone that loves to meditate about his or her place on this planet. Or anyone that thinks they are above all that – but those vain creatures won’t touch a book like this with a ten-foot pole!
“And in time we come to see that not only are we on the sidelines of the universe but that it’s of a universe of sidelines, that there is no centre, just a giddy mass of waltzing things, and that perhaps the entirety of our understanding consists of an elaborate and ever-evolving knowledge of our own extraneousness, a bashing away of mankind’s ego by the instruments of scientific enquiry until it is, that ego, a shattered edifice that lets light through.”
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Orbital.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
September 16, 2024
– Shelved
September 16, 2024
– Shelved as:
to-read
September 16, 2024
– Shelved as:
literary-fiction
September 22, 2024
–
Started Reading
September 27, 2024
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 73 (73 new)
message 1:
by
Sara
(new)
Oct 04, 2024 03:43PM
What a beautifully written and intriguing review, Candi. I love how contemplative this book made you feel!
reply
|
flag
This one first came to my attention when it was longlisted for the Booker Prize. It was the only one that did not spark an interest in me...until now, thanks to your wonderful review.
"What Samantha Harvey has penned is cerebral and contemplative."I am glad you took time to reflect on the ideas shared here. I slo love reading your thoughts on this book, Candi.
"..that conflicting sense that in the grand scheme of things, I matter not at all and also very much."I love that thought of yours at the beginning of the review, Candi, and I found it kind of echoed a line in one of the quotes:
"The difference seems both trivial and insurmountable.
A perfect pairing.
Sara wrote: "What a beautifully written and intriguing review, Candi. I love how contemplative this book made you feel!"Thanks so much, Sara. You know how much I love to mull over big ideas and questions! 🙂
K wrote: "This one first came to my attention when it was longlisted for the Booker Prize. It was the only one that did not spark an interest in me...until now, thanks to your wonderful review."I hadn’t paid a whole lot of attention to it either, K. Until I realized it had some thoughtful ideas and it was a slim book. I thought “why not?!” Thanks for your kind words ☺️
Barbara K. wrote: "Beautiful review, Candi. I’m glad you enjoyed it so much."Thanks a bunch, Barbara. I liked this a whole lot but am still rooting for Creation Lake for the prize. To be fair, those are the only finalists I’ve read though!
Candi wrote: "Barbara K. wrote: "Beautiful review, Candi. I’m glad you enjoyed it so much."Thanks a bunch, Barbara. I liked this a whole lot but am still rooting for Creation Lake for the prize. To be fair, those are the only finalists I’ve read though!..."
Creation Lake is my first choice as well - but I’ve only read that and Held. :-)
Laysee wrote: ""What Samantha Harvey has penned is cerebral and contemplative."I am glad you took time to reflect on the ideas shared here. I slo love reading your thoughts on this book, Candi."
A book like this begs the reader to reflect rather deeply, Laysee :) I appreciate your always kind and generous support!
Thought-provoking review, Candi. This one is on my list, and I hope to get to it some day. I like a book that makes me slow down and think about what I value.
Fionnuala wrote: ""..that conflicting sense that in the grand scheme of things, I matter not at all and also very much."I love that thought of yours at the beginning of the review, Candi, and I found it kind of ec..."
Thanks a bunch, Fionnuala. From my position in the universe, I often feel I don't matter at all. But then, to those that need me, I know I matter a whole lot! How else would we make it just one more revolution around the sun if it weren't for those that mean something to us?! :) Well, certainly, books help as well! :D
Lovely review, Candi! I liked it a bit less than you did, but to me it was a bit too long for its structure. Now I wonder if maybe, had she made it longer and indeed used the space to develop our six characters, if it would have been actually better.That said, I do love your review more than the book.
What a wonderful review Canders - I loved reading it. The hurl/heed differentiation on the creation of the universe. Is that the only difference - "a bit of heed"? Love it.After reading this, do you feel even smaller in the whole scheme of things??
It would be useful for world leaders to spend time in space to give some perspective on our singular insignificance, wouldn't it? Great stuff my friend :))
Another fantastic review, Candi. I'm not sure why, but I don't do well with novels that are set in short time frames. Though the questions you pondered are ones that I, too, ponder, so that aspect has me intrigued -- as do your comments about the possibility of humans truly understanding that our lives are not “us versus them,” should they journey to space and gain that perspective. Sigh. We humans, it seems, are utterly flawed in so many ways!Sorry the characterization was lacking. I feel similarly; there are very few 200-page books that manage to achieve deep characterization, so I do think length often is at play.
A wonderful review, delightfully brimming with ideas and wisdom, Candi - even if you couldn't fully connect with the characters, this novel sounds very much worth-while reading - rightfully reminding us of our miniscule place when tempted to fuss about silly nothings. Gorgeous quotes you picked, giving food for thought - thank you!
Barbara K. wrote: "Candi wrote: "Barbara K. wrote: "Beautiful review, Candi. I’m glad you enjoyed it so much."Thanks a bunch, Barbara. I liked this a whole lot but am still rooting for Creation Lake for the prize. ..."
I'd really like to read Held, too, Barbara. I've read Michaels before and was impressed with her. :)
Maureen ( NOT RECEIVING NOTIFICATIONS) wrote: "Such a lovely review Candi 💚"Thanks so much, Maureen! :)
Carmel wrote: "Thought-provoking review, Candi. This one is on my list, and I hope to get to it some day. I like a book that makes me slow down and think about what I value."Thanks very much, Carmel. Most readers are already pretty meditative, but this one will encourage you to think even further :) I can always appreciate something that makes me do this.
Bianca wrote: "To be honest, I enjoyed reading your lovely review more than listening to the novel."Well, thanks for your generous comment, Bianca! :) I'm sorry the book wasn't a bit better for you, but I totally get it!
Nataliya wrote: "Lovely review, Candi! I liked it a bit less than you did, but to me it was a bit too long for its structure. Now I wonder if maybe, had she made it longer and indeed used the space to develop our s..."Thanks so much for your kind words, Nataliya! I see what you mean about the structure. That's why I slowed down a lot more than I thought I'd need to for such a little book. Yes, I think more character development would have kept the reader invested a bit more. I'm interested to see what else Samantha Harvey might have to share with us in the future!
Mark wrote: "What a wonderful review Canders - I loved reading it. The hurl/heed differentiation on the creation of the universe. Is that the only difference - "a bit of heed"? Love it.After reading this, do..."
Thank you very much, Markus! Sometimes, when you distill the big questions down to the essence, things seem to make a lot more sense, don't they?! Or rather, maybe things are much simpler than we think, and it's best just to carry on with our lives in the best way possible :)
After reading this, I do feel a lot smaller, but at the same time it encourages me to "go for it" because really, in the scheme of things, it's not such a big deal to take a chance on living the best life, right?!
Melissa wrote: "Another fantastic review, Candi. I'm not sure why, but I don't do well with novels that are set in short time frames. Though the questions you pondered are ones that I, too, ponder, so that aspect ..."Thanks so much, Melissa! The ideas are thought-provoking, though surely not entirely new to us. That's why some deeper, well-done characterization would have moved this from four to five stars. Still, I'm glad I read it and will think about the concepts for a while yet!
Ilse wrote: "A wonderful review, delightfully brimming with ideas and wisdom, Candi - even if you couldn't fully connect with the characters, this novel sounds very much worth-while reading - rightfully remindi..."Many thanks for your kind comment, Ilse! It doesn't hurt to have a reminder and you're so right - "silly nothings" indeed! There were a ton of insightful quotes - I could have gone on and on with them! :D
Brilliant review, Candi! I love when a book makes me reflect about the bigger picture. Since I’ve retired I almost feel like my sphere has shrunk. Sure I’m enjoying the extra travel and reading time but it feels like I should be doing more. Might have to read this book at some point!
Antoinette wrote: "Brilliant review, Candi! I love when a book makes me reflect about the bigger picture. Since I’ve retired I almost feel like my sphere has shrunk. Sure I’m enjoying the extra travel and reading tim..."Thanks a bunch, Antoinette! This book fits that to a T! I can understand what you mean about your sphere shrinking. I felt like that when I stopped working altogether when my kids were teens. That's one of the main reasons I joined and became active on this site - to expand my world a little more, at least virtually. Reading and travel are great, but if you want something more, I hope you find that as well :) :)
Catherine wrote: "I'm in the middle of Orbital and came across your review. Beautifully written - as is this novel."I hope this book continues to impress you, Catherine! You're a kindred spirit if you like to reflect on the things that matter most :) Thanks very much for your nice comment :)
Oooh, this sound right up my alley, Candi, and it's hard to believe it's so short with all you have said about it. The cover is beautiful, as is your review, and the book is going right on Mt. TBR. Thanks!
Dan wrote: "Nice review. I’ve never heard of this book or this author, but now I’m interested in reading this."Thank you, Dan. This novel has been shortlisted for the Booker prize this year. That wasn't the reason I picked it up though :)
Jenna wrote: "Oooh, this sound right up my alley, Candi, and it's hard to believe it's so short with all you have said about it. The cover is beautiful, as is your review, and the book is going right on Mt. TBR...."I think you would truly appreciate the ideas within this book, Jenna - as long as you don't find it too slow-paced! It is short, but I paused quite a bit while reading it. Having said that, I'd love to hear your thoughts on it, if it should become uncovered from beneath the stack one day! Thanks so much :)
Fran (Not Receiving Notifications) wrote: "Brilliant review, Candi! I loved it!❤️📚"Thanks a ton, Fran!! The book inspired me :)
Great review. It's fun to think about the process by which Harvey wrote this book. Did she start with, "I wonder what it would be like to spend months and months in a tiny space capsule" and then just let her imagination take her there? Or did she start with the idea of illustrating our (in)significane when compared to the larger world, and look for a good way to tell the story? Anyway, thanks, this has triggered a lot of thoughts of my own.
Left Coast Justin wrote: "Great review. It's fun to think about the process by which Harvey wrote this book. Did she start with, "I wonder what it would be like to spend months and months in a tiny space capsule" and then j..."Thank you, Justin. Yes, it would be interesting to learn about Harvey's inspiration. Perhaps she's mentioned it somewhere, but I haven't gone looking for it. In any case, you know I like mulling over a book like this :)
Candi wrote: "After reading this, I do feel a lot smaller, but at the same time it encourages me to "go for it" because really, in the scheme of things, it's not such a big deal to take a chance on living the best life, right?!"100% agreed! And you never know what life is going to throw at you, so live with gusto and get and give all you can.
Candi wrote: "Despite the obvious limitations and costs, perhaps if every single person on this planet (or maybe our world leaders for a start) could be launched into space for a several month orbit of the earth, more people would come away realizing the hubris of their vanities, desires and greed."
I appreciate your optimistic thought here, and I'm not sure it would help. I'm afraid I've become a bit cynical in the last several years looking at our political leaders.













