Avatar

but there is a story he can never tell...

@byelerheart / byelerheart.tumblr.com

twenty three. she/her. lesbian. byler shipper since season two. gay mike wheeler truther. conformitygate enthusiast. netflix hater

the more you think about it, the more eps 6-8 feel like a collective sabotage. and it just peaks in the finale. it's really not just writing - the script itself is worse, sets are worse, cgi is worse, acting is worse (only jamie seems to be giving his 100%), extras act worse too, camerawork is worse, there is an insane amount of continuity errors, editing is worse too, the whole product just feels like a Slop.

the only moment it picks up again to its previous quality is the epilogue but then everything in it just seems deeply off. the acting is not straight up bad it's just very theatrical and lacks naturalness. there is a huge amount of references and easter eggs to the point you're overloaded by them, the amount of detail in the background is suddenly insane after very lackluster blue screen sets for the most of the episode. color grading, lighting, editing and sound feels better too but not like previously. it has this very intense vibe that hasn't been seen in stranger things before - the closest thing we've seen to it is henry's mindscape/camazotz.

they've had a whole year to write this, another year to shoot it and then another year for everything concerning post-production. i refuse to believe it's just a coincidence.

whatever man. whatever man. not thinking about how will was looking at mike here, keeping his hands lingering on his arms and how mike was probably holding will's waist or something, whatever man. not thinking about how will was smiling at mike being really proud of him then the realisation dawning on him that he still failed to protect the kids, at least he got a moment of peace for a second.

oh my god will has been drawing mike with that heart shield for YEARS now and associating him with hearts hes so precious #tome

[...] that's our big swing this time. we've played around a lot with memory and dreams and things like that throughout the show and we really just wanted to go what if we fully dive in this year. cause there's nothing to me creepier than something like that. [...] we love the idea of something that yes, looks cozy, but there's just something off about it... and that can feel very nightmarish in its own way and just as scary as a big CG monster or scarier

Avatar
Reblogged

still the funniest part about all of this is that if we’re wrong, the ST writers, production team, and cast all created a set of coincidences SO DIABOLICALLY COMPLEX that we were able to recontextualize the entire show.

as a writer i’ve never in my LIFE had that many plot points, symbols, tropes, or parallels fall into place by random chance.

Mike the storyteller writes El’s goodbye with her affirming he has done what he wishes he could do.

He wishes he could understand her.

He wishes he could see the real her.

He wishes he could love her the way she wanted to be loved.

She said I love you.

He didn’t say it back.

He couldn’t even write it.

This theory makes more and more sense every day because I just remembered that absolutely all the characters who started the season with secrets and problems resolved them early on. All of them eventually had to admit what they kept hidden. Will had to face his fears. Nancy and Jonathan had to admit the things they didn't like about each other. Dustin and Steve had be honest with eachother. Eleven and Hopper had to learn to be honest and stop lying. Even Robin and Vickie had a moment of "confessing the truth". Even Vecna faced the memory that scared him the most. But the only character that we knew nothing about when it comes to their emotions, who never admitted anything, who continued to hide instead of facing his fears, is Mike.

Conformitygate is perfectly aligning with everything said during the press tour and here is why:

Ok, I am like 95% sure that conformitygate is happening atp because all the collected evidence leads to it. When finishing the finale I was feeling like I was losing my mind because I DIDN'T RECOGNISE MY BELOVED SHOW ANYMORE. Stranger Things is a show with flaws and obviously not perfect, but the finale felt so soulless and didn't align with anything the cast and crew has shared about it until date. A lot of us have been utterly disappointed because so many statements that were made by the cast didn't turn out to be true.

But if you look at these statements from the conformitygate-angle (yes, I know how I sound), they all make perfect sense:

  • Noah saying that he filmed most of his scenes with Finn.
  • Shawn Levy saying that Finn and Noah carried a lot of emotional weight.
  • The Duffers saying that no-one predicted the ending when rn it is literally the most predictable ending ever.
  • The emphasis on tiying up all the loose ends and giving the characters a satisfying ending, a process that was closely discussed with the actors: Well, rn there are tons of plotholes and you can't convince me that the actors would be happy with their endings. Especially Noah saying that his ending was "perfect" is really suspicious to me: As a gay man who openly shipped Byler during the past few years I don't think he would be satisfied with his storyline.
  • It is also strange how quit the cast hast been on Byler and how often they clash Mileven. If Mike and El are meant to be together in the end, why not give them more buildup.
  • The whole cast saying that the ending was perfect and the finale their favourite: They could obviously be lying for PR-reasons, but I have a hard time believing that Finn and Gaten, who are big nerds (and in Finn's case) filmmakers themselves would love the ending. The whole cast is frankly too intelligent to eat that shit up.

Let's bring me to my second point that is more of a reach, but would be mind-blowing if proven right:

Conformitygate is about an ending within an ending, a play within a play. But what if the presstour is too?

@j-aquarian made an amazing post about how the series parallels the film "The Truman Show", and the amount of parallels is uncanny. I strongly recommend you all to go and read this post:

"The Truman Show" is the story of Truman Burbank who is living unknowingly in a reality show, where all the people around him are actors, until he discovers an exit by the end of the movie. As I said, the amount of parallels to this film is not coincidental, to the point where the ending of e8 parallels directly the ending of "The Truman Show". I still don't know exactly what significance these parallels have for the Stranger Things universe, but there are several things to be said about the press tour:

1. Tying up character arcs

The actors have said several times that they all cried a lot during the final table read, with Noah going as far as to say that "it felt like the Duffers wrote the end of our lives for real". In "The Truman Show" the whole world is watching Truman grow up, anticipating every event of his life and feeling emotionally attached to him. I find it interesting that this paralles heavily the experience of all the kid actors on the show. They have talked many times about how challenging it was to grow up in front of the world, and how weird it is when people still act surprised how grown up they are.

What if the ending reflects this phenomenon, essentially "liberating" the actors from their roles and releasing them into the "real world" outside of the show? That would certainly explain why they were so emotional and personally attached to the final script.

2. The TIME's cover / interview

The core "kids" were on the cover of TIME magazine in October and the shooting draws very direct visual parallels to the ending of "The Truman Show":

I also find it interesting that they are all dressed in grey during the interview when the show is essentially about the colourful eighties, but will come back to that point later.

3. Interviews

I don't remember what interview this was from exactly, but when asked where they think their characters would be in the future, Sadie replied with "She would be a mom" and Caleb said "He would be a soldier". Looking back, I find those answers a little strange, especially for a show that always wants to go against conformity. Max is always presented as a really independent woman, and while that doesn't contradict being a mother, the answer seems a little out of character to me. The whole show is also pretty anti-military, which makes me wonder why Lucas would like to be a soldier.

Are the actors also playing a role during the interviews, feeding certain narratives to the audience? This would be such a cool twist, as they would be essentially being the ones playing the audience, an audience that feels very entitled to them with how big the show has gotten. Might be too meta but I like the idea.

4. The cast's styling

I think it's interesting how a lot of the main cast's outfits is pretty formal attire, kind of similar to how they are dressed in the epilogue. This could be to underline that they are adults now, but I like the idea of it hinting at the twist of the forced conformity trope.

These are obviously just observations that can be purely coincidental, but I'm personally getting a feeling that we are being played by the cast, the Duffers, and even some narratives about them. It almost seems like they have taken certain roles to misguide us about stuff (Noah being the one to easily spoiler stuff, Millie acting disappointed about her ending in that one interview etc. etc.).

It would be an amazing twist to see that all this has been directly connected to the narrative of the show and its final big reveal. Let's see where this whole thing leads us, I can't wait for them to talk about it soon.

bruh "slow burn" you can genuinely tell that noah thought they'd be endgame im so sorry u were bylering out with the rest of us

everyone expected byler to happen. it was promoted, it was being build up in between the seasons in every media in stranger things universe - especially made by few of the writers themselves. after volume 1 every ending led to byler. you cannot tell me something didn't go terribly wrong

Avatar
Reblogged

i genuinely don't believe a person as smart as jamie would praise such a slop of a story. saying it's surprising when what we got is the most predictable and boring thing ever? he really didn't have to say all that

They're not really allowed to speak candidly about it, to be fair. And, even if they were, it could negatively impact their abilities to get more roles if they trash it. They're not nearly big enough stars to get away with it.

i am not talking about the young cast. i am talking about JAMIE CAMPBELL BOWER. he's not a big enough star to get away with it? c'mon now. he's been in countless iconic movies, bigger than this show. he literally doesn't have to do all this. he could step away, just like winona and david, but somehow he's one of the few that is the most excited? and his answers seem genuine, his emotions too. even if he wasn't allowed to speak negatively about it, he wouldn't hype it up so much himself

They actually can get away with it so much so that for months it was believed Millie hated the ending because of one of her responses.

And then I am pretty sure at one point she suggested she went back and forth on it but realized she liked it (I could be making this one up though).

My point is, if Noah can say the show is confusing without much fanfare (because directors and actors messing with each other are a thing) than they can speak more freely.

And yes, Jamie isn't a nobody, he was a part of Harry Potter, Shadowhunters and Twilight, he is going to be fine if he speaks freely.

Jamie is highly praised in a shit ton of circles.

Fantasy, Horror, Musicals, Voice Acting

It ain't going to impact him if he's not enthusiastic about it.

Also Winona Ryder could actively talk smack about the entire show, and it wouldn't impact her career. It might get her in trouble for breaking her NDA, but when has something having legal consequences ever stopped our queen?

Noah, on the other hand, as a young, openly gay actor, is really unable to speak out on stuff.

Which is what has intrigued me.

He's made comments that make the Duffers, rightfully, look bad.

And the Duffers themselves have claimed it was Noah's idea for the sequence that quite frankly saves that last scene: them putting the folders on the shelf and walking up the stairs.

It all just doesn't make sense.

the GA talking about conformitygate is funny to me because to them it’s all about “oh the props changed colors” but to us it’s “mike wheeler is a gay man doomed for eternity and this is not a fate he deserves”

Sponsored

You are using an unsupported browser and things might not work as intended. Please make sure you're using the latest version of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.