Christophersturniolo x populargirl!reader
CONTEXT: popular girl YN, who's dating the star football player, but secretly finds herself drawn to skater/stoner Chris, the boy she's always been warned to stay away from. YN begins crossing lines she shouldn't while still in a relationship, and Chris is the one person who sees through her perfect-girl act.
TW: lying, cheating, toxic dynamics, sexual content.
I knew the outfit was going to cause problems.
The skirt hugs my waist a little too well.
My boots click when I walk.
The off-the-shoulder sweater dips just enough to show skin my mom thinks should stay hidden.
My curls are perfect, soft, bouncy, framed around my face like I actually tried today.
Maybe I wanted to feel like someone other than the daughter who’s “always doing something wrong.”
Dinner starts with that forced holiday cheeriness. Fake smiles.
Everyone pretending everything’s fine because it’s Thanksgiving.
Like people have been waiting for the moment to pounce.
It starts when I take a sip of water.
“So, Y/N,” my aunt says, not even looking up from her plate, “your mother tells me you’ve been… distracted lately.”
My jaw tightens. I place the cup down too softly.
“So I can’t just… live my life now?”
My mom cuts in before I even finish.
“You haven’t been yourself. And we’re worried.”
Her tone is the kind that means I’m criticizing you, but I’ll disguise it as concern.
My dad nods like a stern judge.
“She’s right. You’ve been distant. Moody. And your grades—”
“It’s one B,” I say. “One.”
“You used to be more focused,” he adds. “Lately you’re always somewhere else.”
The words dig into me. Slow. Precise. Like they’ve been rehearsed.
Noah is beside me, eating quietly.
He’s been quiet all night.
Like he already knew they were going to dissect me.
Then he clears his throat.
Soft. Careful. Too careful.
“She does have a point, Y/N… you’ve been kinda distant with me too.”
I turn to him slowly, because I’m scared if I move too fast, I’ll explode, and he’ll know.
“You’re siding with them?” My voice is low. Sharp.
“No— I’m just saying…” He lifts his hands slightly. “I get worried too. You don’t answer my texts, you cancel plans—”
“Because I’ve been tired,” I say. “Because everything feels like too much sometimes.”
“Then say that,” he replies. “You don’t say anything anymore.”
My mom hums like she’s validated.
My dad shakes his head like I’m proving their point.
Something inside me cracks.
Like a clean break in bone.
“You guys don’t listen,” I say, voice shaking. “You don’t ask me anything. You just tell me what’s wrong with me.”
My aunt whispers to my mom, “See? The attitude.”
She raises her brows like I’m proving I’m the problem.
Then my dad puts his fork down, slow and heavy.
“Then stop talking about me like I’m not here!”
My voice shoots out, sharp and too loud, echoing through the dining room.
My mom’s face hardens. “Y/N, you’re being dramatic.”
Noah stands now too, reaching toward my wrist.
“Baby, come on, let’s step away—”
I jerk back before he touches me.
“Why are you acting like this?” he asks, eyes wide. “I’m trying to help you.”
“You are sitting here letting them talk shit about me,” I choke out. “And you didn’t say anything.”
“You weren’t disagreeing either,” I snap. “Adding your two cents in there too.”
He looks hurt, confused, maybe even embarrassed in front of my family.
But I can’t care right now.
“Yn,” he says softly, “just come outside with me—”
“Stop trying to control me,” I whisper. “You don’t get to fix me like I’m some problem you’re trying to manage.”
He swallows hard. “I’m not trying to control you—”
The room goes completely silent.
Tunes of judgement thick in the air.
Boots pounding against the hardwood.
I don’t care that everyone is staring.
I don’t care that Noah calls my name again.
I don’t care that my mom mutters something about “disrespect.”
The noise shakes the frame.
Inside my room, everything feels too small, too bright, too loud.
My breath hiccups in my chest.
My hands tremble like my body is still fighting the scene at the table. I sit on my bed, legs curled under me, muscles tight like I’m bracing for something else to break.
The screen lights up and, for a moment, I see my reflection in it eyes glossy, mascara perfect, lips trembling.
But I need to feel okay for five seconds.
I need someone who won’t look at me like I’m failing.
My thumbs move before the guilt can stop them.
The second it delivers, I inhale shaky but deeper.
Like I just opened a door in the middle of suffocating.
Because I know he’ll come.
And maybe that’s the problem.
Or maybe that’s the only thing keeping me sane.
My phone buzzes before I can even put it down.
Then the screen lights up with his name.
It’s Thanksgiving, he’s probably sitting at his table with his family, eating dinner, laughing with his family
I press the back of my hand to my mouth, trying to breathe through the relief and the guilt twisting together.
I walk to my window, push the curtain aside.
Outside, the streetlights glow on the empty road.
Somewhere out there, he’s already on his way.
My heart starts beating fast.
My boots thud softly against the floor as I walk to my door.
The voices from the dining room leak down the hall—
Noah still trying to explain me like I’m homework he can’t finish.
I swing my bedroom door open and step into the hallway.
But the second my boots hit the wooden floor, all heads snap toward me.
“Where do you think you’re going?” my mom demands.
Her chair scrapes loudly as she stands.
“Y/N don’t you dare walk out of this house like this.”
I grab my bag from the counter without looking at her.
My dad’s brows furrow. “You are not leaving in the middle of Thanksgiving.”
“I’m not staying here and being picked apart like I’m some broken thing,” I say, voice tight but steady.
Noah tries to stand. “Yn, please… can we just talk—”
“Not right now,” I whisper.
Relief, sharp and sudden.
“Y/N!” my mom calls, footsteps fast behind me. “You better turn around right now—”
I walk down the driveway.
Unable to believe I’m actually leaving.
“What has gotten into you? Where are you going?” she snaps.
Headlights appear at the end of the street.
The engine louder than it should be.
That black Lexus that smells like weed.
The front bumper is slightly dented.
It turns the corner and slows in front of my driveway.
Chris rolls down the passenger window.
He just looks at me with that cool, unreadable expression, jaw tense, curls messy, jacket still on like he left mid-meal.
“Get in,” he says quietly.
My mom gasps. “Absolutely not… you are NOT getting into that car—”
I pull the door open, slide into the seat, slam it shut before she can grab me.
The interior smells like smoke and cologne.
Music is loud, bass vibrating under my feet.
My mom is shouting something—
her voice muffled through the glass.
Chris glances at her once, expression blank, then looks at me.
“You good?” he asks, voice low, rough, like he drove fast the whole way here.
Then he pulls away from the curb, tires crunching over the gravel, tension thick between us,
all of it, shrinks in the rearview mirror.
The moment we turn off my street, my body finally starts to unclench.
Like I’ve been holding my breath for hours. Days. Maybe months.
The faint smell of cologne clings to the air.
Chris drives with one hand on the wheel, jaw tight, eyes forward, like he’s trying not to look too hard at me.
But he keeps glancing anyway.
After a minute, he asks quietly,
I swallow hard, staring at my hands. “Nothing new. Just… them doing what they always do.”
He doesn’t say anything, but his grip on the wheel tightens.
“My aunt started in on me first,” I whisper. “Then my mom. Then my dad. Saying I’ve been ‘off.’ Distracted. Different.”
He clicks his tongue softly, like he already hates them for it.
“And Noah…” I pause. “He just sat there. Let them talk about me like I wasn’t even in the room.”
Chris glances at me again. Longer this time.
“He said I’ve been… distant.”
“Like he was agreeing with them.”
Chris exhales through his nose, sharp and annoyed.
The validation hits my chest harder than I expect.
I look out the window so he doesn’t see my eyes get glossy.
He stays quiet for a second.
“You wanna go to my place?”
The question startles me.
I turn to him, eyebrows raised.
“Isn’t your family having dinner right now?”
“Yeah,” he says simply. “Nick’s probably annoying everyone, Matt’s trying to not burn something, my mom’s yelling at someone for touching her mashed potatoes. You know… normal.”
He shrugs, like it’s obvious.
“They won’t care if I bring you.”
That makes heat rush to my cheeks.
“Chris… I don’t wanna be a problem.”
His lips quirk, barely, almost a smirk but softer.
“I just don’t wanna show up and make everything weird.”
“It won’t be weird,” he says. “They like you.”
“Your family doesn’t even know me,” I say under my breath.
“they likes anyone I don’t hate.”
I huff out a tiny laugh despite everything.
He slows at a stop sign, turns his body slightly toward me, voice low and gentle in a way that makes my stomach flip.
“You can come,” he says. “Eat with us. Sit next to me. Pretend they’re your family for the night if you want.”
I look at him, really look, the messy curls falling over his forehead, the small freckle under his eye, the softness in his eyes he doesn’t let anyone else see.
“Chris…” I whisper. “I don’t know if I should.”
Because being next to you feels too good.
Because being near you makes everything else fall apart.
Because I shouldn’t want this as much as I do.
But I don’t say any of that.
Instead, I say, “I don’t wanna ruin your holiday.”
“You’re not,” he murmurs. “If anything, you’d make it better.”
He taps the wheel lightly, glancing at me from the corner of his eye.
“Just say yes,” he says, quiet, almost coaxing. “I don’t wanna drop you off somewhere alone.”
I bite the inside of my cheek.
The warmth in my chest spreads slowly, softly.
“Okay,” I whisper. “I’ll go.”
He nods once, like he expected that answer the whole time, and pulls the car forward.
The road stretches dark and quiet in front of us, and for the first time all night, I don’t feel alone. Not even a little.
Chris turns down his street, the glow of warm yellow windows spilling onto the pavement.
Like laughter is leaking out from the walls.
My stomach twists with nerves as he parks in the driveway.
I can hear voices inside, laughing in the background…
Chris turns the engine off.
“You sure?” he asks softly, like he’ll turn around if I even blink the wrong way.
I nod, even though my heart is pounding.
He watches me for a second, like he’s trying to read something in my face, then gets out. I follow, boots crunching against the driveway. The cold air hits my bare shoulders, and without even thinking, Chris shrugs off his jacket and drapes it over me.
He doesn’t make it a big deal.
Just says, “It’s cold,” and keeps walking.
But my heart… it does something.
We reach the porch, and before he can even open the door, I hear Nick yell from inside:
“BRO, HURRY UP, THE MAC AND CHEESE IS—”
He stops when Chris swings the door open.
Standing slightly behind Chris.
Hair curled, skirt tight, eyes still a little shiny from earlier.
“Ohhhhhh,” he says slowly, pointing between us. “No way. No way. Am I hallucinating? Matt, am I hallucinating?!”
Matt peeks around the corner, sees me, blinks twice, and gives Chris this soft but stunned smile.
Their mom comes out from the kitchen, hands on her apron, mid-sentence.
“Christopher, what took you so lon—”
Surprised, but in a way that feels welcoming.
“Oh! Hi sweetheart,” she says, instantly kind. “We weren’t expecting company but you’re more than welcome. I’m Marylou.”
“Hi… sorry for just showing up—”
“No, no, honey, you’re fine,” she says warmly. “Come in, you must be freezing.”
Before I can step fully inside, Jimmy looks up from the dining table where he’s pouring himself a drink.
He pauses when he sees me, eyebrows raising slightly.
“Well,” he says in that low, dad-voice that somehow fills the whole room, “Chris didn’t tell us he was bringing someone over.”
But he gives a small smile.
Nick practically bounces closer.
“Chris brought a girl home. CHRIS brought a GIRL. HOME.”
Chris groans. “Nick, shut up.”
“No, no, this is historical,” Nick says dramatically. “Do you understand he has never… and I mean NEVER, brought a girl here? Ever. Not even by accident. Not even in a dream.”
Jimmy snorts under his breath.
My cheeks heat instantly.
Chris runs a hand through his hair, annoyed but also slightly embarrassed.
“She just needed somewhere to go,” he mutters.
“Oh yeah? Is that what they call it now?”
“Nick,” Chris snaps, glaring.
Marylou swats Nick with a dish towel.
“Leave them alone. Go wash your hands.”
Nick laughs and heads to the kitchen, whispering loudly,
“Chris has a GIRL in the HOUSE—”
Jimmy shakes his head but he’s smiling into his glass.
Marylou tries to hide her grin.
Chris turns to me, jaw tight like he wants to kill Nick but also like he’s holding in a smile.
“Sorry about him,” he murmurs.
“No… it’s okay. They’re… sweet.”
Like people actually love each other here.
Marylou sets another plate at the table without question, patting my back gently.
“Sit wherever you like, darling. Make yourself at home.”
Jimmy pushes a chair out with his foot, nodding toward it.
I catch Chris watching me as I sit down, his eyes softer than they were in the car.
He sits beside me, his knee brushing mine under the table.
But I feel it everywhere.
The chaos of the table continues, Nick talking too loudly, Matt quietly asking if I want more stuffing, their mom fussing over Chris for leaving earlier without explanation, Jimmy asking if I want something to drink in the most dad-like tone ever.
But no one is criticizing me.
No one is looking at me like I’m ruining something.
No one is waiting to attack.
And every few minutes, Chris leans closer and quietly asks:
“You okay?” Or, “Need anything?” Or just lets his knee touch mine again, grounding me.
When dessert is served, Nick leans across the table with a mischievous grin.
“So, Yn,” he says, “how long have you and Chris been secretly in love?”
Chris nearly chokes on his drink.
Jimmy lifts an eyebrow like he’s listening now.
I blush so hard I have to look at my plate.
“We’re not—” Chris starts.
Nick laughs. “Sure, man. Whatever you say.”
When I glance at Chris from the corner of my eye…
He’s already looking at me.
And he doesn’t look away.
The table’s chaos winds down.
Nick and Matt are bickering quietly over the last slice of pie.
Jimmy leans back in his chair, rubbing his hands together, already full but still surveying the room like a dad in charge of a small kingdom.
Marylou’s wiping the last few dishes, humming softly.
I get up without thinking.
“Here, let me help,” I say, grabbing a towel.
She hands me a plate with a smile.
“You’re a doll, Y/N. Thank you.”
The warmth of the kitchen, the chatter, the clatter of dishes, the laughter, feels different than my own house. No tension here, no judgment.
Even Jimmy nods at me from his chair. “Good work, kid,” he says, voice low but approving.
I find myself enjoying it, helping put away silverware, stacking plates.
Nick is still teasing Chris, who just shakes his head, muttering about how “he’s going to kill me later.”
Matt is quieter, watching, but he catches my glance and smiles softly.
Finally, the kitchen is tidy.
Marylou pats my shoulder, satisfied.
“You’ve done enough. Go, now. You need a break.”
I nod, stomach twisting again, a mix of nerves and excitement.
I know exactly where I want to go.
Chris is waiting at the top of the stairs, leaning casually against the railing.
He watches me with that familiar unreadable expression, half irritation, half… something softer, something warmer.
“You done being a good girl for the Sturniolos?” he asks, voice low, teasing.
I smirk, shrugging off the tension I’ve been carrying since the car.
He steps aside and gestures for me to pass.
I do, heart pounding as I climb the last few stairs to his room.
His door clicks shut behind us.
The house sounds fade: Nick and Matt laughing downstairs, the hum of lights, Jimmy’s chair scraping softly as he settles back.
Chris leans against his desk, eyes on me.
“Sit,” he says quietly, voice soft but commanding.
I sit on the edge of his bed, hugging my knees slightly, feeling small and nervous and… alive.
He sits beside me, shoulder brushing mine.
“Rough night,” he murmurs.
I exhale, finally letting some of the tension slip.
“Yeah,” I whisper. “They… they didn’t understand.”
He nods, hand brushing against mine lightly, just enough to make me shiver.
“Not our problem,” he says simply.
“You always make it sound so easy,” I murmur.
He smirks slightly, but it doesn’t reach his eyes.
“Not easy,” he says softly. “Just… worth it.”
We stay like that for a long moment, quiet, side by side, the weight of everything finally settling between us.
Not saying much. Just being.
And I realize, for the first time tonight…
I don’t feel like I have to explain anything.
Chris finally reaches out, fingers brushing a loose curl from my face.
“Stay,” he says quietly, leaning closer.
Because this, right here, right now is ours.
The quiet of his room is different from anywhere I’ve ever been.
No pressure, no judgment, just… us.
The faint smell of his cologne mixes with the lingering scent of weed, and somehow it feels comforting.
I sit on the edge of his bed, heart still hammering from the car, the teasing, the warmth of his family… and the memory of my own house, the tension, the anger, the weight of everyone telling me I was “off” or “distracted.”
He sits beside me, close enough that the warmth from his body drifts over me.
I can feel the pull, the electricity in the space between us, and it’s unlike anything I’ve ever felt.
Safe, yes, but also… sharp, like falling into something I shouldn’t and wanting it anyway.
It’s too much, this feeling swelling in my chest, and without thinking I lean closer.
“Chris…” My voice barely makes it out, thin and shaking.
He tilts his head, curls falling into his eyes, that soft unreadable look pulling the breath right out of me.
And before I can think, my lips brush his.
Just a test. A question.
But it hits like a shock, warmth, danger, safety, all crashing together.
He freezes for a heartbeat, then his hands rise, cupping my face gently. His thumbs sweep my cheeks like he’s memorizing something he shouldn’t.
“Yn…” he murmurs, low, rough, already unraveling.
I lean in without thinking, my heart thudding fast enough to hurt.
“Thank you,” I whisper against his jaw, not sure why, not sure for what, just needing him close.
His lips find mine again, soft at first, then deeper, purposeful, pulling the breath right out of me. I feel myself being guided onto his lap, his hands firm at my waist, grounding me, pulling me into a warmth that borders on dangerous.
The world blurs.
The stress, the guilt, Noah, everything dissolves under the weight of his closeness.
The kiss turns hungrier, like we’re trying to say everything we’ve kept locked up. My fingers twist into his shirt, holding on. His hands travel up my thighs, slow, sure, claiming me with every stroke.
I’ve never felt anything like this, this heat, this gravity that feels bigger than both of us.
When we pull away for just a breath, our foreheads meet. His eyes flutter closed, mine too, the space between us hot, trembling.
“I’ve… never felt like that,” I whisper.
A soft sound escapes him, half-groan, half-confession.
He kisses me again, deeper, slower, as if this one actually matters and something inside me gives way.
His hands slide along my skin, fingertips trailing my waist, my ribs, leaving sparks everywhere they touch. When his lips graze my neck, a shiver shoots straight through me. I bite my lip, but the sound escapes anyway, small and helpless.
He hears it.
He feels it.
His grip tightens.
“Yn,” he murmurs, voice wrecked, “look at me.”
I do. My heartbeat stutters at the way he’s staring, dark, intense, like he’s choosing me even when he shouldn’t.
His palm cups my cheek. My body leans into it instinctively.
“You’re here,” he whispers. “That’s all that matters.”
And God help me, I let myself fall.
The kiss deepens, messier now, breathing tangled, hands roaming like we’re trying to pull each other apart and hold each other together at the same time. His fingertips drag up my stomach and I gasp, clutching at his shoulders.
Clothes shift. Skin meets skin.
The heat sharpens, rising between us like a spark hitting gasoline.
His mouth trails down my jaw to my collarbone. My fingers slide into his curls, pulling him closer. Every inch of contact burns in the best way. His breath hits my shoulder and I swear I feel it in my knees.
“We shouldn’t…” I breathe, barely holding on.
He hums against my skin, a low vibration that makes me tremble.
“But you’re here,” he murmurs again, lips brushing my throat. “And I can’t stay away.”
His hands slide under my sweater, slow, reverent, like he’s waiting for me to stop him.
I don’t.
I lift my arms instead.
He pulls the sweater over my head, eyes dragging over me with something close to awe, and something darker. Goosebumps rise instantly under his touch.
“I need you,” I whisper, voice trembling. “I—”
“I know, princess,” he murmurs, kissing down my neck, my shoulder, the center of my chest. “I know.”
My hands push at his shirt, desperate, until he lifts his arms and lets me take it off. Heat radiates off him, chest warm under my palms, heartbeat hard enough to feel.
He pulls me closer, skin meeting skin, and everything inside me tilts.
“You feel that?” he breathes against my lips.
His body pressed to mine, heat, tension, desire.
“Yes,” I gasp. “God—yes.”
His lips curl into a soft, wicked smile.
“You bring the light to the sin,” he whispers, kissing me again, slow, deep, stealing my breath. “Every time you’re with me.”
I tremble, arching into him, the heat between us turning sharp and unbearable. His hands roam my body like he’s learning me, tracing lines no one’s touched before. Every brush of his fingers sends shivers down my spine.
I whisper his name like a confession, a plea, a warning.
“Chris…”
His breath stutters.
“Yeah?” he whispers back, lips brushing my ear.
“I can’t stop,” I breathe.
His hand slides to the back of my neck, pulling my lips to his.
“Good,” he murmurs. “Neither can I.”
The rest happens in a blur of skin and breath and whispered names, clothes vanishing between frantic kisses, bodies meeting without space to spare, warmth spreading everywhere his hands touch. Every movement he makes is slow but certain, guiding, grounding, claiming.
I cling to him, nails digging lightly into his shoulders, heart racing so hard I feel it through my whole body.
He groans softly, forehead pressed to mine, breath shaking.
“You feel what you do to me?” he whimpers.
I nod, trembling, lips finding his again.
“And I can’t let go of you,” he admits, voice barely holding together.
Skin on skin, breathless, urgent, dangerous,
we fall into each other completely, and there’s no going back.
Authors Note: thanksgiving special!! Happy Thanksgiving! I hope you all had the most amazing day and the yummiest dinner. I’m so grateful for every single one of you, thank you for being here.🤎