No Second Chances, Just a Hard Pass
I reached out to the Scarborough, Maine branch of OneMain Financial hoping to get some real help — not a miracle, just a fair shake. I’ve been working the same job over 10 years, steady income, checking account, good track record on my car payments. Yes, I have collections on my credit — I’m not hiding that. But I figured with all the other solid parts of my profile, they’d at least talk to me. Maybe offer a secured loan. Maybe mention a cosigner. Something.
No. I spoke to a sales rep — not a loan officer — and the moment they ran my credit, it was a done deal. No questions, no conversation, no “let’s see what we can work out.” Just a quick “you’re not eligible” and goodbye.
They advertise like they’re here to help people rebuild, but in reality? You get one shot to pass their automated checklist. If you’ve got any real dings on your report, you’re out — no nuance, no explanation, no human touch. Just a computer rejection and a hard pull on your credit for nothing.
How Onemain Financial can improve:
If OneMain truly wants to serve the credit-challenged market, they need to empower their staff to actually talk to applicants. Give people a chance to explain their situation — not just get flagged by software and dismissed. Bring back human underwriting, offer a real secured loan option, or at the very least, provide clarity on why someone was denied and what could change that. If you’re gonna market yourself as a second-chance lender, then act like one.
Follow-up to OneMain’s response:
Thanks for the response, but let’s cut the fluff — the problem wasn’t just the denial, it was how fast and dismissive it was. I spoke with a rep at your Scarborough, Maine office. He wasn’t reading a script, but it was clear he wasn’t interested in hearing a thing beyond what the screen told him. No questions, no attempt to understand my situation, no mention of secured options or a cosigner — just “you’re not eligible” and done.
I’ve held the same job over a decade, have steady income, and came in with a real need — not a handout. I wasn’t looking for sympathy. I was looking for a lender who’d actually listen. But apparently, once your system sees a credit blemish, that’s game over. Doesn’t matter what else is working in your favor.
If that’s how OneMain operates, fine — but don’t market yourselves as a second-chance lender. Because right now, it feels more like a bait-and-reject operation. People don’t need a sales rep to pull credit and read a rejection. They need someone who can actually think and talk like a human.
May 20, 2025
Unprompted review