Earlier on
twitter, I was discussing
Elementary and
BBC Sherlock and how queer characters are/should be represented, so I’m assuming this anon is about that.
The Bechdel Test. This is a test that measures female representation in media via three qualifications: 1) having at least two named female characters, 2) who talk to each other for at least 60 seconds, 3) about something other than men.
The Troy and Abed Test. This is a test that measures POC representation in media via three qualifications: 1) having at least two named POC characters, 2) who talk at least once, 3) and who aren’t cultural stereotypes.
The Will and Jack Test. This is a test that measures queer representation in media via three qualifications: 1) has at least two named queer characters, 2) who talk to each other at least once, 3) and whose queer status isn’t treated as a joke and isn’t overemphasized.
To pass a test, the show must pass all three individual qualifications.
SHERLOCK
Bechdel Test: Fail (1/3)
At least two named female characters: Pass (Irene, Mrs. Hudson, Molly, Sally, Sarah, Athena, a few girls whom John dates)
Who talk to each other at least once for at least 60 seconds: Fail (an anon pointed out to me that Molly and Mrs. Hudson talk in “A Scandal in Belgravia”; but I timed the conversation and it was barely 10 seconds long. Thus, fail)
Not about men: Fail
Troy and Abed Test: Fail (1/3)
At least two named POC characters: Pass (Sally, Soo-Lin)
Who talk to each other at least once: Fail
And aren’t racial stereotypes: Fail (Soo-Lin is a pure, delicate, refugee of sorts; the entire [mostly unnamed] gang in “The Blind Banker” exist only as a shady, stupid Chinese Mafia)
Will and Jack Test: Fail (0/3)
At least two named LGBT+ characters: Fail
Who talk to each other at least once: Fail
And whose LGBT+ status isn’t a joke: Fail
BBC Sherlock manages to fail all three tests.
ELEMENTARY
Bechdel Test: Pass (3/3)
At least two named female characters: Pass (Joan, Ms. Hudson, Irene/Jamie, Pam)
Who talk to each other at least once: Pass
About something other than men: Pass
Troy and Abed Test: Pass (3/3)
At least two named POC characters: Pass (Joan, Detective Bell, Oren, Alfredo, multiple minor characters)
Who talk to each other at least once: Pass
And aren’t racial stereotypes: Pass
Will and Jack Test: Fail (2/3)
At least two named LGBT+ characters: Pass (Ms. Hudson and Crabtree, also a few minor characters like Gaye and the two women involved in an affair in 2x15 Corpse de Ballet)
Who talk to each other at least once: Fail (unless you count off-screen, then you could say that the affair in 2x15 would make it a pass)
And whose LGBT+ status isn’t played as a joke: Pass
Final count:
BBC Sherlock: 2/9
Elementary: 8/9
As you can clearly see, Elementary does much better than BBC Sherlock in representation of queer characters, characters of color, and female characters.
Also, like the original author said, Elementary has a trans woman where her gender is not played off as a joke and isn’t the only part of her character, which is amazing.
Have fun defending BBC Sherlock’s “queer” character as good representation.