“Does he think an empire is just a really big country” says the person who thinks that imperialism is only bad when it’s a western country doing it.
If Russia and China are not imperialist, then neither is the US, going by that tankie’s logic. How do they think Russia got so large? Did a magician just poof Russia out of thin air? Or do tankies think that Siberia was sparsely populated, so that justified Russian colonialism, which is the same thing that European colonialists used to justify their displacement of indigenous people in the US, Canada, and Australia (terra nullius). And what Soviet Russia did to Latvians, Estonians, Crimean Tatars, etc. was imperialistic. They displaced the native populations of the Baltic countries and Crimea and colonized those countries when the native populations refused to accept Soviet colonialism.
I’ve seen some western tankies refer to people who opposed the USSR’s “land reforms” as “feudal landlords”, as if the Soviet government didn’t target indigenous Siberians through forced collectivization and continued russification. Like, I thought that, caring so much about indigenous rights and sovereignty, anti-imperialists would side with indigenous Siberians. Or, do they think that only countries in the Americas/the American continent and Oceania (specifically Australia & New Zealand) are settler nation states?
Ukraine does not need an explanation. And no, don’t you dare give me that “NATO expansion” nonsense.
And as for China, need I remind you of Han Chauvinism, which is used to justify Han Settler Colonialism in Tibet and East Turkestan as well as the oppression and degradation of non-Han ethnic minorities in China?
I’m sure that people in Eastern and Central Europe, Northern Asia, and the Caucasus region would all be glad to hear that Russia was not imperialist. If we can accept that western imperialism, then we can accept that eastern imperialism is bad as well. Eastern countries have their own agency and are capable of imperialism just like western countries. If you cannot accept that, then you are not anti-imperialist. You’re just pro-imperialism as long as it’s not a western country doing it.