The Pentacle and Pentagram
Disclaimer: For the purpose of this post I am using the modern occult language of Pentacle to mean the up-right five pointed star within the circle and the word Pentagram to mean the ringless or free floating pentacle. An up-right five pointed star without the circle. So to simplify: Pentacle = Five pointed star with circle. Pentagram = Five pointed star without the circle. That is the language as it’ll be used in this post.
Secondary disclaimer: The etymology of these words both just roughly mean a five pointed shape. Neither, in their word origin, indicate a circle. So go figure. Now on with the rant.
Partly thanks to AI answers there has been a bit of a revisionist history about the symbol of the pentagram. The other night I was curious as to what others felt was the spiritual difference in the symbol of the Pentacle vs. The Pentagram.
I am aware that the ring in the symbol has had many meanings over the years from the cycles of life and the universe, to unity and balance, or contained within oneself or the human will represented as the circle. Or control. Or that the circle represents nature itself since all things in nature are cycler.
The five pointed star, itself, represents the elements of water, fire, Earth, air and spirit- the elements of nature and of magick. Now when I googled what the spiritual significance was in the difference between these two similar symbols I was surprised when the AI overview gave me an answer suggesting that the pentacle is magical and sacred and the Pentagram is just geometry. I know this to be a falsehood. And I realize that Googling different wordings can change how the AI answers the question. But this still struck me as wrong.
Another search result gave me Elphias Levi’s interpretation which claimed that the pentagram represented domination over the elements. Ironically I had once stumbled upon a similar interpretation for the pentacle within the circle with the circle representing control or dominion. It’s no wonder the meaning of these symbols has blurred and blended.
In the lore of werewolves as depicted in pop culture (Of the last eighty-five-years or so) the pentacle and pentagram have been used interchangeably to mean a ward against a werewolf, a warning as to who is the werewolf or who is doomed to be the next victim of the werewolf, and a symbol that could prevent the werewolf transformation if worn by a werewolf. In the lore of werewolf fiction the symbols of the Pentacle and Pentagram seem to have identical functions.
But that is pop culture and should be considered with some skepticism, despite it’s origin being derived from Germanic folklore, which also said that the pentacle could ward off demons, and trap the likes of the demon Mephistopheles (Goethe’s Faust Part 1 and the legend of Faust).
The pentagram was the sigil of Pythagoras (Father of music and mathematics) and was also a symbol of his followers. It was considered a keystone to modern geometry. But the symbol is more than geometry. It’s Sacred Geometry with a capital S.
There is an interesting phenomena where if you dig hard enough you’ll find a star, and in particular, the five pointed star, as a symbol of faith and protection in nearly all world religions. I’ll just name a few.
In Christianity in the middle ages it was believed that the ring given to King Solomon by the Archangel Michael depicted a pentagram or pentacle.
In medieval Germany until about the nineteenth century the pentacle was believed to ward off demons and hung over doorways as a symbol of protection.
Many medieval churches have a pentacle in the stain glass windows.
For a while Christians adopted the Pentacle and Pentagram to represent the wounds of Christ.
A version of the pentacle was used by Ancient Druids and The Ancient Greeks.
A crescent moon and five pointed star is the symbol of Islam. In Islam the star is supposed to represent God and his connection to humanity.
The pentagram without the circle is known in Baha’i as the Haykal and is symbolic of a person with his arms out stretched. People who follow Baha’i believe in harmony and acceptance of all people regardless of race, gender, or sexual identity. They also believe in equal access to education and that all religions have some truth to them.
Most Wiccans use a pentacle as their symbol of faith and magick while some use the pentagram. A few, like the Blue Star Wiccans, use a sepetegram (a seven sided star).
Other stars in faith to note include the Star of David of the Jewish Faith. The Star of Bethlehem that turns up in Catholicism and some other Christian denominations. And the five pointed star Pentagram that often tops Christmas trees though many don’t realize that actually is a pentagram.
Many police and sheriff badges have a five pointed star as a symbol of protection. Even Texas’s so-called “Lone Star” is actually a Pentacle. Many old barns and houses in upstate New York and New England feature a five pointed star or circular window with a five pointed star as an old symbol of protection, like hanging a horseshoe (which has its origin in warding off certain entities that are repulsed by or harmed by iron).
Why am I writing all this? Well, the point is simple. The five pointed star without the circle is just as sacred and just as valid as the version with the circle even if the meaning might be slightly different for some.
The pentagram is not just geometry. Nor does it have to mean “Dominion” over the elements (again, I’ve happened upon those who think the circle represents that). Like the pentacle, the pentagram is ancient, sacred, and bundled in meaning by different people.
There’s even the rhyme “Rowan twigs and strings of red, deflect all harm, gossip, and dread.” This is in regard to rowan twigs (twigs from a mountain ash tree) forming a pentagram and secured with red string (or ribbon or thread, yarn, etc).
So yes, the use of the pentagram (without the ring) is just as valid as a spiritual symbol and symbol of protection, and the five elements of nature and magick.
The use of the ring around it to represent unity, or the cosmos, or will, or nature itself, is your choice. The loss of the ring does not diminish the innate symbolic value of the five elements configured as an even pointed, upright, star.
I made this post because I happen to like the pentagram as much as I like the ringed pentacle version. And I don’t want the symbol diminished for anyone because of a misleading AI or some nineteenth century occultist. Is it geometry? Yes. Is it sacred and symbolic of the wonders of nature, spirituality, and magick, also yes.

