The K-pop Musical I did not know I needed!
I have watched K-pop Demon Hunters and it was such a pleasant surprise! I went into it expecting a fun, light-hearted and silly story about a group of girls happily killing demons. Well, the movie was all of this, but also much much more.
The premise is a twist on the classical "magical girl" story. As per usual there is a group of girls fighting demons. Of course they do so by being both stylish and badass and by using some kind of feminine magic. In this case, the feminine magic used is k-pop, as Rumi, Mira and Zoey are Korean idols. Well, I think this idea is brilliant and it lets the story combine two different storylines:
- The idol storyline, where they have to write a song to win the Idol Awards against a dark-horse boyband
- The saving the world storyline, where they have to create a magical barrier out of the hearts of people to defeat the Big Bad
All in all the merge is wonderful and it gives a surprisingly cohesive narrative, despite the medium being a movie rather than a series. In fact one of the things I appreciated the most is how the story sets up a coherent worldbuilding without making it too distractive for the audience: the golden Honmoon, the magical weapons and the demonic marks are all set up efficiently in the very first scene. Moreover, they tie well with the story and help pushing it forward, but are not overly complicated. The same goes for Mira and Zoey's characterization. They are well characterized (Mira is the badass hardcore one and Zoey is the adorkable one) and given little crumbs of background that help making them more human. Moreover, they do comment loosely on Rumi's story, as their respective insecurities mirror hers:
- Just like Zoey, Rumi is a child of "two worlds" and struggles to reconcile her duality as a Huntress and a Demon
- Just like Mira, Rumi is a "problem child" whose "jagged edges" could cost her Celine's love
So, Rumi combines Zoey and Mira's struggles in a narrative, which goes surprisingly deep and that made me love this story.
RUMI = THE HEART OF THE MOVIE
Rumi's arc combines several ideas that work both as a commentary of the idol industry and as a broader existential exploration. In short, her arc is both specific and universal.
On the one hand you can see Rumi's struggle to be perfect aka "golden" as specific of the idol world. After all, she is expected to be the best idol ever, since she is "idol royalty" and is "meant to be a Queen". So, she must always shine and be without flaws. She must suppress her insecurities, her mental illness, her love life, her physical imperfections and never take a break. This constant pressure resulting in Rumi damaging her voice is a pretty clear metaphor.
On the other hand Rumi's story is that of an imperfect child, who wants to be loved by her parent as she is. And that is an experience everyone can relate to. Rumi trying to fix herself by suffocating a part of herself is heartbreaking. And yet, seeing her slowly accepting this part more and more until she is able to refuse her parent's damaging vision of the world is inspiring.
Rumi's final confrontation with Celine is probably my favorite scene of the movie. I liked the choice of Celine loving Rumi, but not being physically able to accept her. Her refusal to touch or even look at Rumi in her demonic form felt very very raw and you can also see Celine's own struggle. She clearly cares about Rumi, but is still not able to love her unconditionally. Her re-iteration of the anti-theme "Our weakness and flaws can never be seen" also helped humanize her for me. It is obvious Celine too is a victim of this same damaging world-view and that she has been repressing herself a lot. In the end, Rumi's choice to still love herself even if Celine won't felt incredibly powerful. You could say that's the moment Rumi truly becomes an adult and grows into herself.
In short, Rumi's story is about integrating your darkest parts, so it is by definition a narrative centered around the shadow archetype. This is why this archetype is explored in the most important bond of the movie.
RUJINU = FALLING FOR YOUR SHADOW
Rumi and Jinu are love interests, but also each other's shadows. So, they represent what the other is repressing:
- Rumi represents Jinu's humanity. She shows him that you do not have to just succumb to your shame. You can fight back not to let your flaws control you. You can choose which version of yourself you are gonna be.
- Jinu represents Rumi's demonic heritage. He shows her that there is humanity and feeling in being a demon. Actually, he ended up a demon for his very human flaws (selfishness). He is also the first person who truly accepts Rumi for who she is as a whole. There is also the obvious idea Rumi is clearly projecting her family issues on his relationship with Jinu. After all, she is the child of a human and a demon, so she sees herself as a mistake. However, if Jinu is human enough for her to love him, then maybe her parents' love was right and she herself is worthy of existing.
So, Rumi and Jinu awaken different parts of each other and struggle together on the main theme of the story: how to deal with shame.
Rumi hides the parts of herself she is ashamed of. In a sense, she wants to cut them off completely. She wants to become "golden".
Jinu wears them on the sleeve and lets them define him. In a sense, he lets them spread as an infection he has no control over.
None of these approaches is right, which is why Rumi and Jinu's final confrontation before the final battle is so powerful:
Jinu: I left them! That's right. I lied to you. I only made a deal with Gwi-Ma to get myself out of that miserable life. (...) I left them. I left them.
Rumi: But that's not all you are. This is just your demon talking. You have to fight it!
Jinu: That's not how it works!
Rumi: Yes, it is!
Jinu: Listen to yourself. Is it working? You're a demon, just like me. All we get to do is to live with our pain, our misery. That's all we deserve.
Here, both are proving each other wrong. On the one hand Jinu betrayed Rumi because he was scared she would not have accepted his real self. And yet, the moment he tells her the truth (even after he hurts her deeply), Rumi doesn't give up on him. On the other hand Rumi keeps telling Jinu he should fight his demons, like her. Still, Rumi is deep down not behaving that much differently from Jinu. Jinu wants to erase his demons by forgetting his mistakes. Rumi wants to erase her demons by forgetting her origin. Both want to erase their shadows, but they can't, which is why they both fail just before the climax.
However, Rumi is able to come up with a new answer:
Gwi-Ma: The Honmoon is gone.
Rumi: It is. So we can make a new one.
She is true to what she herself told Jinu:
Rumi: That't the funny thing about hope. Nobody else gets to decide if you feel it. That choice belongs to you.
Rumi chooses to love herself despite everything. She chooses to forgive herself and others and to stay hopeful. Thanks to this, she is able to reconnect with Zoey, Mira and her fans. She is able to reconnect with Jinu too and she inspires him to choose his humanity. Jinu sacrifices himself for Rumi and integrates with her, both as his love interest and his shadow. He becomes a part of her. Personally, I think Jinu's final sacrifice works because it is not punitive. In fact even after his betrayal, Rumi never wishes to kill him nor gives up on him. Rumi's final words to him were in fact her wish to set him free. At the same time, for Jinu to sacrifice for Rumi works because his major flaw is selfishness. Jinu is fully capable of love, but he is also selfish. It is actually the first thing we are told about him:
Gwi-Ma: I know you, Jinu. In 400 years, you've never done a single thing that didn't serve yourself.
He loved his family, but chose himself over them. He loves Rumi, but chose himself over her at the Idol Awards. In the end, he is finally able to choose another person over himself. And in this way, he is finally choosing his own self, as well.
Of course the best part of the movie and the true key of its success is the music. They managed to make a musical out of the k-pop genre and I am all here for this!
Every song is used wonderfully, as it either pushes the story forward or adds dimension to the theme or both.
"How it's done" is used to introduce the characters, establish their personalities, fighting styles and how their powers work (they make weapons out of the Honmoon)
"Golden" starts exploring the theme of "No more hiding", but it does so superficially. The lyrics of the song seem to convey the theme, but the characters are not being true to them. Not only that, but the song only focuses on the best parts of our protagonists. Not on their flaws.
"Takedown" is the antitheme. It is about refusing your worst parts choosing to "rake them down". The way the composition of this song comments on the main story is also great. Rumi is the one who comes up with the idea, but she progressively grows more and more unsure about it. The moment Rumi's lies catch up to her and she is confronted with her worst nightmare as the fake Mira and Zoey sing the song is probably one of the best scenes in the movie.
"Soda Pop" and "Your Idol" are the two faces of the Saja Boys. "Soda Pop" basically says the same thing as "Your Idol", but with an upbeat and happy sound, which makes the demon boyband look harmless. When it comes to "Your Idol", it is the negation of the negation thematically. What is worse than repressing your worst parts? Well, giving it to them and letting them control you.
"What It Sounds Like" is the true theme of the story. It is a song about accepting your worst part and loving yourself regardless. Its lyrics also comment the girls' journeys like Rumi finally showing her "true voice" or Huntrix finally being able to write "the song they couldn't write". Zoey's reference to the different colors inside her head also ties visually with Rumi's marks becoming combination of different colors. Rumi herself and the Honmoon by the end are neither golden nor purple/black, but a whole rainbow.
Speaking of visuals, the animation and character designs were top notch. I am sure there are many many little details I missed about it. Still, one thing I noticed is how Huntrix's "golden outfits" commented on their emotional states.
When Rumi launches Golden and the trio wear their costumes, Demon Girl is the only one with a white top and a dark blue jacket. Mira and Zoey's costumes have instead white jackets over darker tops. I think this may be because Rumi is the one who is hiding and repressing the most out of the three. After all, her blue jacket is used to cover her purple marks. Mira and Zoey are instead more open about themselves. However, they too need to integrate some hurting parts hence why they tops are dark blue.
At the Idol Awards Performance, Huntrix's outfits have changed slightly. Both Mira and Zoey wear dark blue jackets over dark blue tops. Moreover, they added pads to their costumes. This shows how the accumulated tension within the group has taken a toll on them. Rumi's lies and inability to open up have been slowly piling up on Mira and Zoey emotionally. Rumi herself doesn't change colors, but she too adds a shoulder pad on only one side (in general, some asymmetry on her shoulders is a recurring visual motif with her). I think this shows that she is slowly accepting her duality and that she is not wearing a whole "armor" anymore. It is only half an armor because she has been slowly integrating her demonic parts.
Finally, when they sing "What It Sounds Like", Huntrix's outfits change again. On the one hand Mira and Zoey's costumes become completely white and golden after the three girls hug. There is no trace of blue left. On the other hand Rumi loses her jacket and dark blue parts during her "takedown". She does not cover herself up again. She actually refuses to be covered up again by Celine. Rumi's adoptive mother tries to cover her daughter's marks by using her own gray/green jacket. Interestingly, green is also the color Rumi wears as a child, when she and Celine are in front of the grave of Rumi's mother. Finally, gray/green is the color Rumi wears at the beginning of the "Golden" musical video:
So, it is clearly a color associated with Celine and her philosophy. For Rumi to free herself from it is symbolic of her truly becoming "the queen she is meant to be". As a result, Rumi faces the final battle with no walls, but she is actually the one who exposes the most skin. This lets her marks visible as a symbol that she is not hiding herself anymore. By the end of the song, all three girls have fully embraced their true selves.
In conclusion, I really really liked this movie. It was clearly made with passion and managed to use its screentime very well to pull off some amazing character arcs and to convey a multi-layered theme. It also clearly let room for spinoffs or a sequel. After all, the final frame is literally a giant Huntrix poster which has "Comeback" written on it :P